Emmit Smith - stayed too long. Staying just showed his true mediocrity as a back, and that it was his offensive line that carried him.
Brett Favre - stayed too long. Tarnished his career, pissed off even GB fans.
Barry Sanders - left way too early.
Tiki Barber - BOTH left too early. Left 1 year prior to Giants winning Superbowl.
stayed too long - IF he returns, as he is claiming.
[ Edited by JimA49ers on Mar 9, 2011 at 1:28 PM ]