Originally posted by tjd808185:Originally posted by LA9erFan:
He's definitely the best QB I've ever seen.
The playoff record argument is silly. To compare the level of talent that the Colts have to the level of talent that those Niner teams had is completely disingenuous. Manning was absolutely phenomenal yesterday, but the Saints did a great job of keeping him off of the field for almost two consecutive quarters.
Yup. Tell me one key player that the Colts have gotten thru free agency? Gary Brackett and after that it's pretty much crickets. Indy's done a better job than anyone else at finding players that fit their offensive and defensive schemes, but pound for pound they're not as talented as people give them credit for.
Peyton will never be as clutch as Montana and nobody else will for that matter, but if he can rack up 3 Super Bowl wins and rack up every single passing stat known to man than he's made his case. We won't know that until he's finished.
3 of the Colt's 5 starting OL were acquired in free agency. They weren't big names when they hit the market, but I'm not sure what point you were trying to make so I'll point that out. I do think Joe's niner teams were more talented (particularly on defense) fwiw.
And I also agree that this is really a poor conversation to have until Manning hangs up his cleats. Joe never lost the SB on an interception, but Peyton could still accomplish a lot of things that Joe never did.