All Decade Team - a work in progress

Sep 25, 2009 at 2:59 PM

blacksailsmd
Veteran
Posts: 2,803

Originally posted by danimal:
Tough one between Brady and Manning but I would have to go with Peyton Manning

Anyway here is my top 5 QBs of this decade

Peyton Manning IND
Tom Brady NE
Drew Brees SD, NO
Kurt Warner STL, NYG, ARI
Rich Gannon OAK

are you serious!!!!!
Brady hands down bar none. Dumb question to even ask. And as a 9er fan you should know why, SB Rings

Sep 25, 2009 at 3:04 PM

danimal
Veteran
Posts: 14,705

Originally posted by blacksailsmd:
Originally posted by danimal:
Tough one between Brady and Manning but I would have to go with Peyton Manning

Anyway here is my top 5 QBs of this decade

Peyton Manning IND
Tom Brady NE
Drew Brees SD, NO
Kurt Warner STL, NYG, ARI
Rich Gannon OAK

are you serious!!!!!
Brady hands down bar none. Dumb question to even ask. And as a 9er fan you should know why, SB Rings

While I respect the Rings argument, I think there is a BIG BIG BIG difference between One vs None. So when Brady was 3-0 on Peyton I would have to agree, but once Peyton Won 1 and Tom Lost 1.....I think the argument became much more debatable

Sep 25, 2009 at 3:19 PM

49erfeeeever808
Veteran
Posts: 31,326

Originally posted by danimal:
Originally posted by blacksailsmd:
Originally posted by danimal:
Tough one between Brady and Manning but I would have to go with Peyton Manning

Anyway here is my top 5 QBs of this decade

Peyton Manning IND
Tom Brady NE
Drew Brees SD, NO
Kurt Warner STL, NYG, ARI
Rich Gannon OAK

are you serious!!!!!
Brady hands down bar none. Dumb question to even ask. And as a 9er fan you should know why, SB Rings

While I respect the Rings argument, I think there is a BIG BIG BIG difference between One vs None. So when Brady was 3-0 on Peyton I would have to agree, but once Peyton Won 1 and Tom Lost 1.....I think the argument became much more debatable

true.... but it's still 3 vs 1, and 4 appearances vs 1. Also Brady took another step ahead of Brady when he broke Manning's TD record.

Yeah Brady had Randy Moss.... yeah the Pats lost the SB that season.... but Manning had Harrisson, who some people (i'm not one of them) argued is better than Moss, and the Colts lost in the playoffs to the Patriots when Manning had his record 49 TD season.

IMO, Roethlisberger should be on there too....

[ Edited by 49erfeeeever808 on Sep 25, 2009 at 3:22 PM ]

Sep 25, 2009 at 3:27 PM

SybErkRimInAL
Veteran
Posts: 59,185

a.smith

Sep 25, 2009 at 3:29 PM

GoNiners
Veteran
Posts: 5,418

if it weren't for Vinateri Brady would have no rings

Sep 25, 2009 at 3:55 PM

49erfeeeever808
Veteran
Posts: 31,326

Originally posted by GoNiners:
if it weren't for Vinateri Brady would have no rings

the games were tied when he kicked those FG's, who knows what would have happened in OT.

This is Brady vs. Manning not Brady vs. Montana.

....and Manning wouldn't have been to the Superbowl if it wasn't for Bob Sanders. Then when he gets there he has a gift opponent with Rex Grossman.

Brady > Manning

but as a fan i like Manning better.

[ Edited by 49erfeeeever808 on Sep 25, 2009 at 3:59 PM ]

Sep 25, 2009 at 4:07 PM

Chief
Veteran
Posts: 28,272

Manning is one of the best QB's ever, but Brady has the rings.

Sep 25, 2009 at 4:16 PM

danimal
Veteran
Posts: 14,705

also this is the last year of the decade...so both can still do more to further their case.

Another small point. Major Injury. While I don't blame players for being injured I can't ignore the effect it has on their teams. The Colts never had to deal with a season without their man at the helm. I think that adds a bit more value to Peyton.

Sep 25, 2009 at 4:17 PM

GEEK
Veteran
Posts: 19,412

Manning
Brady
Warner
Rothlesburger
Brees

In that order.

Sep 25, 2009 at 4:18 PM

#10

BHulman
Veteran
Posts: 4,338

Originally posted by blacksailsmd:
Originally posted by danimal:
Tough one between Brady and Manning but I would have to go with Peyton Manning

Anyway here is my top 5 QBs of this decade

Peyton Manning IND
Tom Brady NE
Drew Brees SD, NO
Kurt Warner STL, NYG, ARI
Rich Gannon OAK

are you serious!!!!!
Brady hands down bar none. Dumb question to even ask. And as a 9er fan you should know why, SB Rings

Brady has the rings. Ultimately that is what a QB is judged on.

Sep 25, 2009 at 4:19 PM

#11

BHulman
Veteran
Posts: 4,338

Originally posted by GoNiners:
if it weren't for Vinateri Brady would have no rings

And vice versa.

Sep 25, 2009 at 5:26 PM

#12

49erfeeeever808
Veteran
Posts: 31,326

title is kinda misleading. i think you mean All-Decade team.

...i was about to post Patriots #1, Steelers #2.

Sep 25, 2009 at 5:29 PM

#13

danimal
Veteran
Posts: 14,705

Originally posted by 49erfeeeever808:
title is kinda misleading. i think you mean All-Decade team.

...i was about to post Patriots #1, Steelers #2.

fixed...thanks. What are your thoughts on WR's?

Sep 25, 2009 at 5:37 PM

#14

49erfeeeever808
Veteran
Posts: 31,326

Originally posted by danimal:
Originally posted by 49erfeeeever808:
title is kinda misleading. i think you mean All-Decade team.

...i was about to post Patriots #1, Steelers #2.

fixed...thanks. What are your thoughts on WR's?

Moss, TO, Harrison