Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Webb was a better pitcher by postseason of 2021. He was 10-0 and hadn't lost since May. He crushed the Dodgers.
there is a dif between maintaining your rotation, and changing it. if you look at 2021, Webb started game 162 and game 1 of postseason, so we went out of our way to get him the ball in g1
that's not what happened with Zito
A couple things.
1) The Giants won every one of Zito's last 11 starts that season (he was 7-0). So your justification for your opinion is the exact same as what I just said about Zito.
2) just because a pitcher is your team's #1, doesn't mean he is a true #1. Every team in baseball has identified a pitcher as their #1. That doesn't mean the pitcher is one.
Look, I like Webb. A lot. I don't want you or anyone else to think that I am s**t talking him or minimizing how good he is. Thats not the case at all. My position is simply he is not a #1 starter. I don't believe a team with Webb as its ace would ever be a World Series contender.