Originally posted by btthepunk:Originally posted by Niners99:Originally posted by 4ML:Originally posted by Niners99:Originally posted by Garce:Barry Bonds went to Serra
Crazy that the greatest baseball player and arguably football player went to the same HS.
You call yourself a 49ers fan?
I hate Brady but do ppl still question that Brady isn't the greatest QB of all time?
How the rings were won matters. I think Montana won his 4 more decisively and dominantly than Brady did. People weren't really comfortable saying Brady was better until he won his 5th ring, yet one of those 5 was literally handed over by the Seahawks. Factor in Adam Vinatieri, the Falcons idiotically not running clock out and guaranteeing the victory, Deflate-gate, Spy-gate, etc.
Im comfortable called Montana at a perfect 4-0 with 0 picks, and a clean record the GOAT. He didn't get the benefits of ref protection either.
You're not wrong but you also have to factor in the team around them. Joe had the biggest offensive innovator ever at HC, and assistant coaches who went on to be HC. His defenses are the most underrated possibly ever. He had the greatest player of all time for 2 of his super bowls. A RB who had 1000 yards rushing and receiving.
The Super Bowls that Brady won, he never had that kind of talent around him.
Id counter that by saying Montana didn't get to play for Walsh for 17+ years. Imagine an injury free Joe with 17+ seasons with Walsh.
And lets be honest with Jerry Rice. His entire career was spent playing for Joe Montana and Steve Young. His GOAT status was afforded by his mutually beneficial situation. Montana went 18-1 and blew out Marino in the SB before he had Rice.
To me the biggest factor is era. Joe Montana was bashed around like a crash test dummy, and the refs had zero issues with it. He had career shortening back and elbow problems that caused chronic issues, and needed countless surgeries. He was a pretty small guy for the abuse he took.
Between the scandals, the Vinatieri bailouts, and the Seahawks choke job, I just cant call Brady the superior player in the biggest moments. Brady lost thr Super Bowl, twice. He threw picks. Its just not the same. Ill take quality over quantity.