QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by PA49ersfan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Love how the handful of Trey haters are just standing on their soap box saying he can't play in Kyle's system and can't get Ws for this team. Just so passionate about it, like zero doubt in their mind lol.

same folks that probably couldn't name what play calls he couldn't run or explain any of it from a football standpoint…for sure their tales are gonna change everyone's opinion on it

Yes very very strange. As it usually is on the zone.

It's really weird and imo a lot of it is based off their feelings of Jimmy and how people criticized him after being allowed years worth of play in this system. They refuse to allow him the same time for whatever weird reason.

Kyle and Co clearly loved a lot about him, so let him play. We all know he's not gonna be Tom Brady day 1 but he's never gonna get better if he doesn't play. He was never gonna get marginally better by not playing, anyone that thought that differently had other motives…If people can't handle development by playing, cry me a river. It's always been the process, we got lucky with Brock but he's gotta get better and that s**t could take a while.

Originally posted by riverrunzthruit:
100% Brock set the standard and TL can't meet it, will have to sign Jimmy G too keep BCB's seat warm until he is healthy enough to lead the team again.

Nah ain't happening Jimmy is gone

Originally posted by NYniner85:
It's really weird and imo a lot of it is based off their feelings of Jimmy and how people criticized him after being allowed years worth of play in this system. They refuse to allow him the same time for whatever weird reason.

Kyle and Co clearly loved a lot about him, so let him play. We all know he's not gonna be Tom Brady day 1 but he's never gonna get better if he doesn't play. He was never gonna get marginally better by not playing, anyone that thought that differently had other motives…If people can't handle development by playing, cry me a river. It's always been the process, we got lucky with Brock but he's gotta get better and that s**t could take a while.

It's very suspect they don't wanna give him a chance like at all.

Originally posted by eric_anthony:
It's very suspect they don't wanna give him a chance like at all.

Its less about not giving him a chance and more about wanting to win and not go through growing pains that are inevitable with a guy who hasn't played more than 20 football games since high school. Deshaun Watson was an MVP caliber QB, he missed a season and a half and looked like ass after coming back to the Browns this season.

If this was a 7-10 team, sure, go ahead and let him take his lumps, let him make the mistakes and if they finish 8-9 or 9-8, no biggie.

However this should be a team competing for a SB next season and if Shanahan thinks Lance can be that guy to keep up the same level of play as Purdy, great, but if not, they need to keep their options open.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

When can Brock Purdy return from elbow surgery?

Our panel of doctors break down his return timeline after suffering a complete UCL tear Sunday

⏩https://t.co/IQhK9k2By4#NFL #49ers #49ersfaithful pic.twitter.com/sffyE4xZW1

— Sports Injury Central (@SICscore) January 31, 2023

"Mullens was able to begin throwing about three months after surgery"

That is good to know.

Originally posted by libertyforever:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

When can Brock Purdy return from elbow surgery?

Our panel of doctors break down his return timeline after suffering a complete UCL tear Sunday

⏩https://t.co/IQhK9k2By4#NFL #49ers #49ersfaithful pic.twitter.com/sffyE4xZW1

— Sports Injury Central (@SICscore) January 31, 2023

"Mullens was able to begin throwing about three months after surgery"

That is good to know.

What's interesting is that I've tried to find out whether Mullens had a complete tear, and I haven't been able to track anything down. Maybe I'm just missing it

Originally posted by BYisGod:
What's interesting is that I've tried to find out whether Mullens had a complete tear, and I haven't been able to track anything down. Maybe I'm just missing it

It was torn but able to be repaired rather than requiring reconstruction. It was reported that when they went in to do the surgery, the surgeon found the damage was less extensive than feared so they were able to do a brace which allows for a much quicker recovery time.

In Purdy's case, if the ligament is amenable to repair, he could undergo a surgical UCL repair augmented with an InternalBrace. The brace is a synthetic "check-rein" implanted alongside the repair to help reinforce the ligament as it heals. A repair is typically less invasive and would offer a shorter recovery time for Purdy. Whereas Tommy John surgery can require a year or longer to return to form, athletes in other sports are returning within six months from UCL repairs.

In 2020, Nick Mullens suffered a right elbow injury that many initially feared would require Tommy John surgery. But Mullens' injury fit the criteria, and he became the first NFL quarterback to undergo a UCL repair with InternalBrace, a procedure that also enabled him to return to the field sooner than if he had required a full reconstruction.

Originally posted by libertyforever:
"Mullens was able to begin throwing about three months after surgery"

That is good to know.

Very good indeed

Originally posted by BYisGod:

Originally posted by libertyforever:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

When can Brock Purdy return from elbow surgery?

Our panel of doctors break down his return timeline after suffering a complete UCL tear Sunday

⏩https://t.co/IQhK9k2By4#NFL #49ers #49ersfaithful pic.twitter.com/sffyE4xZW1

— Sports Injury Central (@SICscore) January 31, 2023

"Mullens was able to begin throwing about three months after surgery"

That is good to know.

What's interesting is that I've tried to find out whether Mullens had a complete tear, and I haven't been able to track anything down. Maybe I'm just missing it

I don't think you missed anything.

Originally posted by PA49ersfan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Love how the handful of Trey haters are just standing on their soap box saying he can't play in Kyle's system and can't get Ws for this team. Just so passionate about it, like zero doubt in their mind lol.

same folks that probably couldn't name what play calls he couldn't run or explain any of it from a football standpoint…for sure their tales are gonna change everyone's opinion on it

Yes very very strange. As it usually is on the zone.

Forgive me for wanting to actually win instead of wasting a year of a championship roster while a raw project QB gets on the job training.

So Be It!

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Brady either breaks the curse and stays healthy all season, or he gets wrecked and we're free of him forever. Win/win in my book.

Originally posted by libertyforever:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

When can Brock Purdy return from elbow surgery?

Our panel of doctors break down his return timeline after suffering a complete UCL tear Sunday

⏩https://t.co/IQhK9k2By4#NFL #49ers #49ersfaithful pic.twitter.com/sffyE4xZW1

— Sports Injury Central (@SICscore) January 31, 2023

"Mullens was able to begin throwing about three months after surgery"

That is good to know.

Yeah but what direction was he throwing, backwards or sideways?

Originally posted by DaleGribble:

Originally posted by PA49ersfan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Love how the handful of Trey haters are just standing on their soap box saying he can't play in Kyle's system and can't get Ws for this team. Just so passionate about it, like zero doubt in their mind lol.

same folks that probably couldn't name what play calls he couldn't run or explain any of it from a football standpoint…for sure their tales are gonna change everyone's opinion on it

Yes very very strange. As it usually is on the zone.

Forgive me for wanting to actually win instead of wasting a year of a championship roster while a raw project QB gets on the job training.

One could argue Jimmy wasted the years we should have won the SB, right?

If the goal is to win the SB, Jimmy hasn't done that either. This franchise doesn't care about second place.