QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I know that when some of those INTs happened the announcers said that it was a poor decision. I seem to remember Brock himself saying it about a couple after the game. You can keep making excuses for his recent poor play but it is what it is. Mac Jones came in and played better than Brock in those 3 games. He had a knee injury that limited his mobility and was still able to play well enough to lead the team to wins. He had fewer weapons to throw to than Purdy did and he got the job done.

I'm not ready to suggest that Jones should replace him but you can't deny he's played better than Brock this year. Brock now needs to show he can return to that 2023 form.

Brock in Seattle was better than Mac against New Orleans or Arizona despite the turnovers. This last game Mac was impressive.

No. Mac's start in New Orleans was better Brock's start in Seattle. Brock got away with a 50/50 ball to beat Seattle.

Originally posted by Chance:

Originally posted by irief:
Not meant to be condescending at all. I was initially on the Jimmy bandwagon, but evolved also. Now it's Brock's turn.

You haven't changed his opinion, just understood it. The nuance of it doesn't make it mean what you think it does. Not everything is a bandwagon.

Why are you speaking for him, unless chance=genius?

Originally posted by irief:
Why are you speaking for him, unless chance=genius?

He is smart, but he's not Genus.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by irief:
Why are you speaking for him, unless chance=genius?

He is smart, but he's not Genus.

There is, however, a guy on this board with a 160 iq. Though he wastes his Steven Hawking-level intelligence on transgender bathroom issues.

Originally posted by Chance:
There is, however, a guy on this board with a 160 iq, though. Though he wastes his Steven Hawking-level intelligence on transgender bathroom issues.

Definitely the only genius here. Just ask him.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Chance:
There is, however, a guy on this board with a 160 iq, though. Though he wastes his Steven Hawking-level intelligence on transgender bathroom issues.

Definitely the only genius here. Just ask him.

😆

Originally posted by SFrush:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I know that when some of those INTs happened the announcers said that it was a poor decision. I seem to remember Brock himself saying it about a couple after the game. You can keep making excuses for his recent poor play but it is what it is. Mac Jones came in and played better than Brock in those 3 games. He had a knee injury that limited his mobility and was still able to play well enough to lead the team to wins. He had fewer weapons to throw to than Purdy did and he got the job done.

I'm not ready to suggest that Jones should replace him but you can't deny he's played better than Brock this year. Brock now needs to show he can return to that 2023 form.

Brock in Seattle was better than Mac against New Orleans or Arizona despite the turnovers. This last game Mac was impressive.

No. Mac's start in New Orleans was better Brock's start in Seattle. Brock got away with a 50/50 ball to beat Seattle.

Mac threw at least 2 balls against LA that were ez picks. That happens a lot in shanny's system because he constantly draws up crowded routes inside the hash to set up outside zone runs that aren't called anymore.

Still lovin our mac elopement but don't expect it to last forever. If brock isn't ready when the magic starts to wear off kiss the hendrickson trade googoodbye.

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:
Mac threw at least 2 balls against LA that were ez picks. That happens a lot in shanny's system because he constantly draws up crowded routes inside the hash to set up outside zone runs that aren't called anymore.

Still lovin our mac elopement but don't expect it to last forever. If brock isn't ready when the magic starts to wear off kiss the hendrickson trade googoodbye.

He will probably retire someday.

Originally posted by SFrush:

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
I know that when some of those INTs happened the announcers said that it was a poor decision. I seem to remember Brock himself saying it about a couple after the game. You can keep making excuses for his recent poor play but it is what it is. Mac Jones came in and played better than Brock in those 3 games. He had a knee injury that limited his mobility and was still able to play well enough to lead the team to wins. He had fewer weapons to throw to than Purdy did and he got the job done.

I'm not ready to suggest that Jones should replace him but you can't deny he's played better than Brock this year. Brock now needs to show he can return to that 2023 form.

Brock in Seattle was better than Mac against New Orleans or Arizona despite the turnovers. This last game Mac was impressive.

No. Mac's start in New Orleans was better Brock's start in Seattle. Brock got away with a 50/50 ball to beat Seattle.

Mac was missing easy throws that game. Watch JTOs breakdown.

Some people just can't accept criticism of the guy they like. Purdy fans can deny, explain away, make excuses, rationalize and whatever but the numbers can't be changed. Brock may come back and throw 20 TD passes with no INTs the rest of the year but it won't change what he's done in his last 5 games. Just like what he did in the last 5 games doesn't change what he did in 2023. Some of us are just pointing out the fact that he hasn't been good in those games and Jones has been good in the 3 he played.

It's not an argument to replace Brock as the starter when he's ready to come back but it does give him something to shoot for. Control that gunslinger urge and stop trying to make a big play when it's not needed. Take what's there and save the hero ball for the last second like he did with that throw to Tonges. It wasn't a great throw but at the time it was needed.

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Some people just can't accept criticism of the guy they like. Purdy fans can deny, explain away, make excuses, rationalize and whatever but the numbers can't be changed. Brock may come back and throw 20 TD passes with no INTs the rest of the year but it won't change what he's done in his last 5 games. Just like what he did in the last 5 games doesn't change what he did in 2023. Some of us are just pointing out the fact that he hasn't been good in those games and Jones has been good in the 3 he played.

It's not an argument to replace Brock as the starter when he's ready to come back but it does give him something to shoot for. Control that gunslinger urge and stop trying to make a big play when it's not needed. Take what's there and save the hero ball for the last second like he did with that throw to Tonges. It wasn't a great throw but at the time it was needed.

Gabbert had a 8 game stretch where he outplayed Rodgers on the Tomsula 9ers. What if this is just one of those stretches for each qb?

Just chill out and let Kyle choose who he wants. What is the point in constantly calling out Brock for not being great last year? He was still top 10 in qbr and pff last year so it seems a little over the top

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:
Gabbert had a 8 game stretch where he outplayed Rodgers on the Tomsula 9ers. What if this is just one of those stretches for each qb?

Just chill out and let Kyle choose who he wants. What is the point in constantly calling out Brock for not being great last year? He was still top 10 in qbr and pff last year so it seems a little over the top

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Gabbert had a 8 game stretch where he outplayed Rodgers on the Tomsula 9ers. What if this is just one of those stretches for each qb?

Just chill out and let Kyle choose who he wants. What is the point in constantly calling out Brock for not being great last year? He was still top 10 in qbr and pff last year so it seems a little over the top

Originally posted by CharlieSheen:

Lol. Stats… if we ever needed more reasons.