There are 346 users in the forums
Originally posted by captveg:
Your sarcasm detector is off. But I get it with how absurd some takes or on this forum, especially on game day.
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Just stop. You know absolutely zero about his injury status or its impacts and niether does Steve Young. No idea of severity, how it feels, when it was re-injured. Shanny cleared him before the Jax game, not on the injury list. and Purdy stated he would play if he was ready. According to Purdy, it started hurting after the game, not during. Brutal.
But you know right?
Show me his accuracy issues being like that before the game? You can't.
Now tell me the last time a team rushed a player back from injury then basically blamed the play on the injury?
You forgot how Brock said he wasn't sure if his mechanics were affected by the injury when asked if it caused his passes to sail in the game(and during practice). I'm sure because he didn't outright say no you'll believe what you want to believe and rather think that 2 weeks off made him forget how to throw the ball properly. Something that isn't an issue after he was out from his elbow injury...
Grasping.
If you only you had a fraction of objectivity you might be believable.
And not a single rebuttal of substance was had from TD.
Dont act you bring any substance to the convo. Your motherly love of Brock drives your opinions.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Fans here love drama, arguing and siding up over QBs. It can be pathetic and annoying but at least this time it is because the 49ers have two very capable QBs instead of 1 or zero.
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Fans here love drama, arguing and siding up over QBs. It can be pathetic and annoying but at least this time it is because the 49ers have two very capable QBs instead of 1 or zero.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by captveg:
Your sarcasm detector is off. But I get it with how absurd some takes or on this forum, especially on game day.
No, I know you're being sarcastic, lol. You made multiple posts like this before, during, and after the game.
It's unnecessarily defensive of Brock. There is no controversy. There are crazy fans, and people who enjoy trolling. Neither should be taken all that serious.
Originally posted by captveg:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Fans here love drama, arguing and siding up over QBs. It can be pathetic and annoying but at least this time it is because the 49ers have two very capable QBs instead of 1 or zero.
Every starting QB for the 49ers since Montana has been hated by at least half thr fan base at one time or another. It's what the fan base does.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Fans here love drama, arguing and siding up over QBs. It can be pathetic and annoying but at least this time it is because the 49ers have two very capable QBs instead of 1 or zero.
Who's "siding up" anyone? It's pointing out that our starter needs to get back to what he did in 22/23 when it comes to running this offense. We just saw how well it can go with a capable back up and 2nd/3rd string guys vs a top end D.
folks gotta stop getting so defensive about everything…not everything in life needs to be my tribe vs your tribe
Originally posted by dj43:
I'm not a doctor though I have spent a lot of time in sports medicine, specifically in treating foot injuries. Against that background, there is just no way the foot can go through a normal range of motion with a plate in the shoe. Now, of course that isn't going to impact the decision-making process, but it will impact the follow-thru in throwing, and as Tom Brady pointed out, the usual result is a shortened motion and higher release point which results in the ball going over the target.
A knee brace that only protects against excessive or unusual movements, doesn't impact the throwing motion to a significant degree.
All of this is only fodder for discussion as Purdy is not likely to see the field again for a couple of weeks. In that time, let's all be Mac Jones fans and let Brock heal.
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Just stop. You know absolutely zero about his injury status or its impacts and niether does Steve Young. No idea of severity, how it feels, when it was re-injured. Shanny cleared him before the Jax game, not on the injury list. and Purdy stated he would play if he was ready. According to Purdy, it started hurting after the game, not during. Brutal.
But you know right?
Show me his accuracy issues being like that before the game? You can't.
Now tell me the last time a team rushed a player back from injury then basically blamed the play on the injury?
You forgot how Brock said he wasn't sure if his mechanics were affected by the injury when asked if it caused his passes to sail in the game(and during practice). I'm sure because he didn't outright say no you'll believe what you want to believe and rather think that 2 weeks off made him forget how to throw the ball properly. Something that isn't an issue after he was out from his elbow injury...
Grasping.
If you only you had a fraction of objectivity you might be believable.
And not a single rebuttal of substance was had from TD.
Dont act you bring any substance to the convo. Your motherly love of Brock drives your opinions.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dj43:
I'm not a doctor though I have spent a lot of time in sports medicine, specifically in treating foot injuries. Against that background, there is just no way the foot can go through a normal range of motion with a plate in the shoe. Now, of course that isn't going to impact the decision-making process, but it will impact the follow-thru in throwing, and as Tom Brady pointed out, the usual result is a shortened motion and higher release point which results in the ball going over the target.
A knee brace that only protects against excessive or unusual movements, doesn't impact the throwing motion to a significant degree.
All of this is only fodder for discussion as Purdy is not likely to see the field again for a couple of weeks. In that time, let's all be Mac Jones fans and let Brock heal.
Oh I never said it doesn't impact his throwing. The stability just isn't there like it needs to be. I'm saying recognize that you have that going on and adjust. This isn't just one game thing either. His processing and accuracy imo last yr was nowhere near what it was in 22/23.
Yeah we're lucky to have a QB that can run this offense in Mac right now. Brock needs to get right AND think about how he's played the past yr and change it up.
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TD49ers:
Just stop. You know absolutely zero about his injury status or its impacts and niether does Steve Young. No idea of severity, how it feels, when it was re-injured. Shanny cleared him before the Jax game, not on the injury list. and Purdy stated he would play if he was ready. According to Purdy, it started hurting after the game, not during. Brutal.
But you know right?
Show me his accuracy issues being like that before the game? You can't.
Now tell me the last time a team rushed a player back from injury then basically blamed the play on the injury?
You forgot how Brock said he wasn't sure if his mechanics were affected by the injury when asked if it caused his passes to sail in the game(and during practice). I'm sure because he didn't outright say no you'll believe what you want to believe and rather think that 2 weeks off made him forget how to throw the ball properly. Something that isn't an issue after he was out from his elbow injury...
Grasping.
If you only you had a fraction of objectivity you might be believable.
And not a single rebuttal of substance was had from TD.
Dont act you bring any substance to the convo. Your motherly love of Brock drives your opinions.
Your bias is showing as well.
Now, try to follow the Rules guideline regarding constructive posting and move on.
Originally posted by 9moon:
JUST stay with hot hand !!
MATTY ICE 2.0 !!!