QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

Na.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

How do you know that doc?

Originally posted by pd24:
Brock has the skill set, hopefully he is learning from these games and can adjust some of his bad habits

Just gotta get back to what he was doing in 22/23, folks just the other day were in here tossing out how bad the roster is around him…well look at what our backup did with what was a worse situation imo

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Just gotta get back to what he was doing in 22/23, folks just the other day were in here tossing out how bad the roster is around him…well look at what our backup did with what was a worse situation imo

....While hurt

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by pd24:
Brock has the skill set, hopefully he is learning from these games and can adjust some of his bad habits

Just gotta get back to what he was doing in 22/23, folks just the other day were in here tossing out how bad the roster is around him…well look at what our backup did with what was a worse situation imo

Agreed.

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

How do you know that doc?

Why don't you try to google it champ.

Originally posted by krizay:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Just gotta get back to what he was doing in 22/23, folks just the other day were in here tossing out how bad the roster is around him…well look at what our backup did with what was a worse situation imo

....While hurt

Clearly hurt the last drive in the Saints game and most of the game yesterday.

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

He has been hurt. However there are different injuries. Some are a matter of pain tolerance, some are painful and may impact your ability to play the game more than others.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

How do you know that doc?

Why don't you try to google it champ.

A PCL injury isn't nothing either. So both are "injured" both have basically the same roster (I'd saying last nights was worse this yr) and yet one is playing better?

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

How do you know that doc?

Why don't you try to google it champ.

Your medical prognosis is in a google search? Really?

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

He has been hurt. However there are different injuries. Some are a matter of pain tolerance, some are painful and may impact your ability to play the game more than others.

Steve Young on Brock Purdy's injury:

"It's the ligament in the big toe. He's a righty so it's on his right foot and that's the plant foot… The whole throw is through your right big toe if you think about it. So for Brock, you saw him last week, he had to stay off of it. So what… pic.twitter.com/LtLw5sQq0j

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) October 2, 2025

Give it up man. You have no idea of what or how much the injuries hurt or how they are impacting each QB. We saw what we saw. Purdy was moving better than Mac.

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

He has been hurt. However there are different injuries. Some are a matter of pain tolerance, some are painful and may impact your ability to play the game more than others.

Steve Young on Brock Purdy's injury:

"It's the ligament in the big toe. He's a righty so it's on his right foot and that's the plant foot… The whole throw is through your right big toe if you think about it. So for Brock, you saw him last week, he had to stay off of it. So what… pic.twitter.com/LtLw5sQq0j

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) October 2, 2025

Give it up man. You have no idea of what or how much the injuries hurt or how they are impacting each QB. We saw what we saw. Purdy was moving better than Mac.

I'm not Steve Young but I'm sure you believe you know more than him as well...

Lol I guess ppl think all injuries are the same, makes sense.

Me thinks Doordash has delivered too many preservatives and Brawndo to your brains.

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by pd24:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by JC_916:
Here's an interesting comparison someone on YouTube was discussing this morning:

Mac Jones playing with scrubs but obviously hurt is balling out verse a healthy Purdy in 2024 playing with scrubs who was just mediocre. 🤔🤔🤔

Once again 2024 is not comparable to 2025.

Here is at least one comparison for 2025 which includes Purdy playing on the bad toe which clearly impacted his accuracy.

QB value versus team record

Brock Purdy
5th EPA per play
1-1 Record

Mac Jones
13th EPA per play
3-0 Record

— Kevin Cole (@KevinCole___) October 3, 2025

Mac has been playing hurt also since his preseason injury. Last night was clearly hurt. So let's include that too when mentioning injuries effecting the QBs.

He has been hurt. However there are different injuries. Some are a matter of pain tolerance, some are painful and may impact your ability to play the game more than others.

Steve Young on Brock Purdy's injury:

"It's the ligament in the big toe. He's a righty so it's on his right foot and that's the plant foot… The whole throw is through your right big toe if you think about it. So for Brock, you saw him last week, he had to stay off of it. So what… pic.twitter.com/LtLw5sQq0j

— Coach Yac 🗣 (@Coach_Yac) October 2, 2025

Is his big toe affecting his processing too? Mac isn't making these all world throws. He's processing quickly and making the correct reads. He's taking what is given and moving the ball.

Brock for the past yr + is playing hero ball when he doesn't have too. He's putting the ball in harms way too much, which has equal an uptick in TOs.

people are correct in questioning what Brock is doing out there. We all love the gunslinger mindset…but there's a time and place to be like that. I think Brock even recognized that over the off season, but it hasn't totally transferred onto the field yet.