So based on what we've seen thus far from the youth who will most likely be here next year as cornerstones or key contributors when we're ready to make a run next year (with a great off season and a little luck) or the year after, here's where we're at:
OFFENSE:
Quarterback:
QB: C.J. BeatHard
Need: Excellent depth with Hoyer and potentially BeatHard but this off season will be all about securing a FQB.
Running Backs:
RB2: Matt Breida - #23 PFF grade at 74.2
OW: Kyle Juszczyk - #8 PFF grade at 68.4
Need: It looks like the future is very bright here and we still have Joe Williams waiting in the wings. Hyde has proven to be an excellent insides zone runner but Kyle likes the stretches so the FO has a choice to make here (update: we're fielding offers for Hyde).
Tight Ends:
TE: George Kittle - NG. Cole Hikutini - NG.
Need: I couldn't find his current PFF grade here but he had a monster game last game and above average in run blocking. As a rookie he's had 3 huge drops but he's also played through 3 injuries too. If he finds consistency, look out. If nothing else, he'd be an excellent #2. Now it's time to see what Cole can do.
XWR: Marquise Goodwin - #49 PFF grade at 72.4 (Torrey Smith #98 at 44.2)
YWR: Trent Taylor - #90 PFF grade at 46.2
ZWR: Pierre Garcon - #5 PFF at 83.2
Need: After the early dropsies Goodwin has started to come on the last two games. Every team needs a #3 deep threat. Garcon has the conditioning to play this effective for 3 more years but he's best served for a #2 role. With Taylor an effective returner and shifty slot WR, we might be looking at a premier ZWR next off season to compliment Garcon.
Offensive Line:
LOT: Joe Staley - #17 PFF at 77.5
LG: Laken Tomlinson - #63 PFF grade at 38.3
C: Daniel Kilgore - #32 PFF grade at 38.9
RG: None
ROT: Trenton Brown - #8 PFF grade at 81.0
Need: There is no question we need to start grooming a T behind Staley but the real work will be in FA trying to massively improve all 3 interior spots. Those guys stink!
DEFENSE:
Base/Nickel DL:
LDE/BE: Arik Armstead - #38 ER PFF grade at 78.2. Tank Carradine - #39 PFF at 79.9
NT: D.J. Jones - #78 PFF grade at 71.4
RDT: DeForest Buckner - a beast
LEO: Solomon Thomas - #90 PFF grade at 49.0
NER: Aaron Lynch - #44 PFF grade at 75.9
Need: Tank is a premier 6T and needs to be resigned, Buckner needs to man the 1T with Thomas full time at 3T (think Stubblefield + B.Young). Jones adds short yardage depth and Armstead adds interior depth at pass rush. This FO will be searching long and hard for a true LEO coupled with current depth in Dumervil/Lynch to work with. We need a consistent edge rush coming on every down to couple with premier inside talent and depth.
Linebackers:
SAM: Eli Harold - #62 PFF grade at 45.5
MIKE: Reuben Foster - he's coming back soon
WILL: Ray-Ray Armstrong - #2 PFF grade again right behind Buckner at 83.7 two weeks in a row. Overall #52 at 49.9
Need: Bowman's days are numbered (correction: released) so we'll need a dynamic WILL with Foster sliding over to MIKE (confirmed). Malcolm Smith will be returning next year but we could use another dynamic WILL and an excellent pass rushing SAM that can play every down opposite the LEO.
RCB: Dontae Johnson; Ahkello Witherspoon - #100 per PFF at 40.8. Same scheme issues as Robinson (see below)
S/CB: K'Waun Williams - up and down, NG
LCB: Rashard Robinson - #97 per PFF at 42.3. He was PFF's #1 rookie coming into the season at 13.2 coverage snaps per reception. Saleh's off coverage scheme and trail technique has eff'd his game up IMHO
FS: Jimmie Ward - #74 PFF FS at 41.5
SS: Jaquiski Tartt - #4 PFF SS at 88.9. Eric Reid - #30 PFF at 77.4
Need: At S, the FO has to decide if Reid is the future. Saleh would like both Tartt and Reid as one would be the dime SS/LB. These upcoming games with Witherspoon and consistency of Robinson will go a long ways in helping set our off season moves in motion. I think off coverage and trail techniques have turned RR's talent upside down. An upgrade over Johnson is a must unless Saleh moves to jam press but he's best served as a backup as it stands. Ward will have to grow more and more if he wants to lock down the most critical position in the secondary.
SPECIAL TEAMS:
Specialists:
LS: Kyle Nelson - Perfection
PK: Robbie Gould - 100% at 14 for 14
P: Bradley Pinion - #2 on PFF and 3rd in punts inside the 20
KOR: Victor Bolden Jr. - 242 yards = 3rd
PR: Trent Taylor - 3rd in Avg with 10+ returns
GR: Adrian Colbert & Raheem Mostert - two of the best in the league (PFF)
Need: Outside of PK, we could be set at ST for the next 5-10 years.
[ Edited by NCommand on Oct 14, 2017 at 1:48 PM ]