Does Jarryd Hayne make the team?

Originally posted by Cattledog:
I must also say to hell with keeping pad levels down as it did not do this poor Charges CB any good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Unfortunately, that's not going to work if he tries to run high and truck a guy like Navarro Bowman.

Originally posted by theninermaniac:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

no

Love how he casually steps out of bounds.....

Definitely on the the team! Look at the other 2 defenders posture changed after they saw dude get wrecked..."Oh hell no, I'm not getting in his way" BAD ASS!
Fro the beginning I saw his running style like Demarco Murray that's why I was worried about health longevity, but he brings an it factor to our team that may just help us win some of the tight games.

Originally posted by Empire49:

Unfortunately, that's not going to work if he tries to run high and truck a guy like Navarro Bowman.

he plays on the team that employs a guy like navarro bowman... there is no other navarro. come on bro lol

Originally posted by Empire49:

Originally posted by Cattledog:

I must also say to hell with keeping pad levels down as it did not do this poor Charges CB any good!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Unfortunately, that's not going to work if he tries to run high and truck a guy like Navarro Bowman.

dude.

Next you'll be saying he can't make world ping pong champion, or start a successful shrimp farm in Alabama or finally sleep with jenny or somesuch.

Hey Guys,

Aussie fan here. Very keen watcher of the NFL prior to Haynes arrival albeit following Philly. Although after visiting your great city in 2014 and falling absolutely in love with the place i'm now a keen watcher of not only the Giants but the 49ers also.

Being a Rugby League fan (Parramatta Eels to be exact) i was devastated when Hayne announced he was leaving as he was our best player and pretty much everything our team did revolved around him. The guy is a freak not only as an athlete and for the individual performances he shows but also the way he can also lift his teams morale just by pulling off a big play.

I really hope the 49ers pick him in the 53 man squad. The bloke is a world class athlete.

out of curiosity with haynes arrival and rise in the NFL has it peaked your interests in our competition the NRL at all?

Originally posted by Tulip:
Could Hayne start as an RB for any team in the NFL yet?
Or just not good enough?

The only thing keeping him from being a starter is lack of knowledge in blitz pickup. I haven't seen enough of his blocking skills to know if he'd be effective even if he was good at blitz pickup. He finds holes and runs the ball very well, so there's no problem there.

Originally posted by Empire49:
The only thing keeping him from being a starter is lack of knowledge in blitz pickup. I haven't seen enough of his blocking skills to know if he'd be effective even if he was good at blitz pickup. He finds holes and runs the ball very well, so there's no problem there.

I disagree. We're in the middle of a topic titled "Does Jarryd Hayne make the team?" We're talking about a fringe-53 player. I think he is talented enough to make the 53 man roster as a role player, but being in the conversation of a staring-caliber RB? No way. Totally disagree with you there.

Originally posted by Method:

Originally posted by Empire49:
Unfortunately, that's not going to work if he tries to run high and truck a guy like Navarro Bowman.

he plays on the team that employs a guy like navarro bowman... there is no other navarro. come on bro lol

You got me there. I guess I should have said it isn't going to work if he tries it on a good-to-great NFL linebacker.

Navarro Bowman >>>> good-to-great NFL linebacker.

Originally posted by JimA49ers:

Originally posted by defenderDX:

Originally posted by JimA49ers:
Hayne is Tomsula's "no NFL experience" project, and makes the team in his first year. Tank Carradine was Harb's "no NFL experience" project and gets cut after a few years. Just sayin'...

you don't have a clue as to what you're talking about, just saiyan.

I know, too much for you to comprehend.

Yeah, can't comprehend how Tank Carradine came in as a project with no NFL experience lol

Originally posted by theduke85:

Originally posted by Empire49:
The only thing keeping him from being a starter is lack of knowledge in blitz pickup. I haven't seen enough of his blocking skills to know if he'd be effective even if he was good at blitz pickup. He finds holes and runs the ball very well, so there's no problem there.

I disagree. We're in the middle of a topic titled "Does Jarryd Hayne make the team?" We're talking about a fringe-53 player. I think he is talented enough to make the 53 man roster as a role player, but being in the conversation of a staring-caliber RB? No way. Totally disagree with you there.

OK. Why?

If he gets his blitz pickup and knowledge up to NFL standards, what do you feel would prevent him from being a starter? Is it the fact that he has vision and can find holes? Is it the fact he is elusive? What makes you feel he couldn't be a starter? It doesn't matter if he is currently a fringe player. I'm saying if he can gain the knowledge necessary, there is no reason he couldn't be.

that CB that got trucked looked visibly shaken lol

Originally posted by theduke85:
Well, that's not what I reasoned. I said that if this is really a "retooling" year -- and a lot of people objectively think it is, no matter how much we don't want to believe it -- the team is going to favor potential and long-term impact over what they can do this year. I'm not saying that Hayne can't provide value this year (of course he can), but I think he would've had a harder time making the 2012 team than the 2015 team; the 2012 team had to maximize the marginal/incremental contribution of players, because they had such high aspirations. The 2015 team arguably needs to be thinking longer-term.

You say we are retooling TB says we are reloading but this is week 1 so as a fan I ain't looking to just do the best we can and charge it to the game for a better 2016. I get your reasoning but I gotta believe TB is always looking both short and long term because he has already said as much on countless occasions. Just because we've shifted personnel doesn't mean this team is settling on just being here. I gotta believe we're focused on winning as many games as we can and go as far as we can go. Hayne can help and it seems he can be a significant factor on ST right away so this is why I think he has earned his spot. No need to overthink this. We've had issues on kick returns for a couple years now and along comes Hayne. We need to keep him

Originally posted by natheel:
Hey Guys,

Aussie fan here. Very keen watcher of the NFL prior to Haynes arrival albeit following Philly. Although after visiting your great city in 2014 and falling absolutely in love with the place i'm now a keen watcher of not only the Giants but the 49ers also.

Being a Rugby League fan (Parramatta Eels to be exact) i was devastated when Hayne announced he was leaving as he was our best player and pretty much everything our team did revolved around him. The guy is a freak not only as an athlete and for the individual performances he shows but also the way he can also lift his teams morale just by pulling off a big play.

I really hope the 49ers pick him in the 53 man squad. The bloke is a world class athlete.

out of curiosity with haynes arrival and rise in the NFL has it peaked your interests in our competition the NRL at all?

When does your season start? I definitely have more interest in it now and you better believe NFL scouts are already looking for the next Hayne

List of rugby dudes with similar skills as Hayne please!

Glad he didn't chose Detroit over us. If he would of chosen The Lions over us he probably would be competing for their starting RB spot.