49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 705 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Geeked:
I have a feeling both the current Safeties will be replaced within two years Bathia - age and Reid - concussions .

Very possible! I like Tartt and Ward but they will need another safety if the two you mention retire shortly. Hope they can keep McCray as a developmental guy for another year! It doesn't hurt that Tartt and Ward played on the same team in HS and are good friends.

McCray is a good one. We have to find a way to keep him...like DeUh noted, I.R.?

Those hang nails can be vicious!
  • cools
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,828
My Pre-TC Predictions...

QB- Kaepernick
QB- Gabbert
* Thompson to PS

RB- Hyde
RB- Hunter
RB- Bush
RB- Davis

FB- Miller
FB- Millard

TE- Davis
TE- McDonald
TE- Carrier
TE- Ball
* Anderson to PS

LT- Staley
LG- Thomas
C- Kilgore
RG- Boone
RT- Pears
C/G- Martin
C/G- Farrell
OT- Brown
* Silberman to PS

WR- Smith
WR- Boldin
WR- Simpson
WR- Patton
WR- Ellington
WR- Anderson
* White to PS

S- Bethea
S- Reid
S- Tartt
S- McCray

CB- Brock
CB- Wright
CB- Ward
CB- Johnson
CB- Reaser
CB- Acker
* Cromartie protected on IR/PuP/PS

OLB- Brooks
OLB- Smith
OLB- Lynch
OLB- Harold

ILB- Bowman
ILB- Wilhoite
ILB- Wheeler
ILB- Belore

DL- Dial
DL- Williams
DL- Dorsey
DL- Dockett
DL- Carradine
DL- Armstead
DL- Jerod-Eddie
* Need to find a way to protect Okoye one more year

P- Pinion
K- Dawson
LS- Nelson

Edited...
Yep, Davis looks too good to red shirt. He's in and im going with one less OL
A bit worried about OT depth, I expect we may add a vet along the way, and/or move Brown to PS or red shirt him
[ Edited by cools on Jul 9, 2015 at 10:12 AM ]
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,400
I see this roster happening, but I have a feeling that (RB) Davis if doesn't get injured will have a strong preseason and that Hunter will be traded to the Colts for another 5th rounder..

HYDE
BUSH
DAVIS
Ya know, a lot of media hacks believe that our roster has been seriously depleted and weakened due to certain retirements and personnel losses. I guess that remains to be seen and they've continued to rehash it to death for weeks now but I found something interesting. The Steelers who we play in week 2 had guess what? Three stalwart defensive players (Polamalu, Taylor and Worillds) all retire this past off-season. Guess how much you've seen written about that by the national media the past couple months? Almost nothing. Well somebody can say that Polamalu and Taylor were old, declining players and the other guy retired to devote himself to religious causes (which is really no different than Borland retiring, just different reasons) but they're really not losing that much personnel wise, and they have young players ready to step up in their place. Well Justin and Pat were older, declining players also (along with Ray McDonald for that matter) with young up-and-coming players waiting in the wings. If we can fortify and stabilize the O-line in the first few games this team will be just fine, and all the dips**t media can sit back & eat crow.
[ Edited by ninerjok on Jul 8, 2015 at 11:49 AM ]
Originally posted by cools:
My Pre-TC Predictions...

QB- Kaepernick
QB- Gabbert
* Thompson to PS

RB- Hyde
RB- Hunter
RB- Bush
* Davis "protected" on Pup/IR, Hayne to PS

FB- Miller
FB- Millard

TE- Davis
TE- McDonald
TE- Carrier
TE- Ball
* Anderson to PS

LT- Staley
LG- Thomas
C- Kilgore
RG- Boone
RT- Pears
C/G- Martin
C/G- Farrell
OT- Vet not on team yet via trade or waivers
OT- Brown
* Silberman to PS

WR- Smith
WR- Boldin
WR- Simpson
WR- Patton
WR- Ellington
WR- Anderson
* White to PS

S- Bethea
S- Reid
S- Tartt
S- McCray

CB- Brock
CB- Wright
CB- Ward
CB- Johnson
CB- Reaser
CB- Acker
* Cromartie protected on IR/PuP/PS

OLB- Brooks
OLB- Smith
OLB- Lynch
OLB- Harold

ILB- Bowman
ILB- Wilhoite
ILB- Wheeler
ILB- Belore

DL- Dial
DL- Williams
DL- Dorsey
DL- Dockett
DL- Carradine
DL- Armstead
DL- Jerod-Eddie
* Need to find a way to protect Okoye one more year

P- Pinion
K- Dawson
LS- Nelson

I hate this idea of "protecting" Mike Davis, he is making the roster, and will play, if anyone is in danger of not making the opening day roster it's Hunter, he needs to prove he can stay healthy.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Geeked:
I have a feeling both the current Safeties will be replaced within two years Bathia - age and Reid - concussions .

Very possible! I like Tartt and Ward but they will need another safety if the two you mention retire shortly. Hope they can keep McCray as a developmental guy for another year! It doesn't hurt that Tartt and Ward played on the same team in HS and are good friends.

McCray is a good one. We have to find a way to keep him...like DeUh noted, I.R.?

Those hang nails can be vicious!

Right!?!
Originally posted by ninerjok:
Ya know, a lot of media hacks believe that our roster has been seriously depleted and weakened due to certain retirements and personnel losses. I guess that remains to be seen and they've continued to rehash it to death for weeks now but I found something interesting. The Steelers who we play in week 2 had guess what? Three stalwart defensive players (Polamalu, Taylor and Worillds) all retire this past off-season. Guess how much you've seen written about that by the national media the past couple months? Almost nothing. Well somebody can say that Polamalu and Taylor were old, declining players and the other guy retired to devote himself to religious causes (which is really no different than Borland retiring, just different reasons) but they're really not losing that much personnel wise, and they have young players ready to step up in their place. Well Justin and Pat were older, declining players also (along with Ray McDonald for that matter) with young up-and-coming players waiting in the wings. If we can fortify and stabilize the O-line in the first few games this team will be just fine, and all the dips**t media can sit back & eat crow.

Booyeah!
http://www.csnbayarea.com/49ers/early-odds-make-49ers-53-man-roster

MM

When the 49ers report to training camplater this month, the organization will begin the process of transforming their 90-man roster to the 53 players who will open the regular season.

As we look ahead and attempt to project the players who will suit up for the 49ers this season, we placed each of the players into one of four status categories:

Locks: Each of the 33 players listed should be destined for the 53-man roster. Looking good: It might not be 100 percent, due mostly to competition and outside forces, but we project 12 of the 15 players listed will be with the 49ers when the season begins. 50-50: It can go either way, but expect seven or eight of the 17 players in this category will secure spots on the roster. Must impress: It's an uphill battle, and in most cases the practice squad is a viable option. But we're leaving room on the roster for one or two of these players to emerge and win a spot on the 53-man roster.

Here's a position-by-position rundown of the 49ers' early roster odds:

QUARTERBACK (3; keep 2-3)
Locks: Colin Kaepernick, Blaine Gabbert
Must impress: Dylan Thompson
The 49ers carried two quarterbacks a year ago, and that's the most-likely scenario for this season, too. The only difference would be if Thompson impresses so much during the exhibition season that the 49ers believe there's a good chance he would be claimed if placed on waivers.

RUNNING BACK (8; keep 5-6)
Locks: Carlos Hyde, Reggie Bush, Mike Davis
Looking good: Bruce Miller, Kendall Hunter
Must impress: Trey Millard, Kendall Gaskins, Jarryd Hayne
If you believe Miller and Hunter should be placed into the "locks" category, you're probably right. But if Millard and Hayne perform so well on special teams and show enough on offense, it might force the 49ers to make a difficult decision.

WIDE RECEIVER (12; keep 6-7)
Locks: Torrey Smith, Anquan Boldin, DeAndre Smelter
Looking good: Bruce Ellington, Quinton Patton
50-50: Jerome Simpson, Dres Anderson, DeAndrew White
Must impress: Chuck Jacobs, Issac Blakeney, DiAndre Campbell, Mario Hull
Although we expect Smelter to begin the season on the non-football injury list, we're including him in the "locks" category because the 49ers will certainly retain him under all circumstances. There should be very strong competition for the final two receiver spots on the 53-man roster.

TIGHT END (8; keep 3-4)
Locks: Vernon Davis
Looking good: Derek Carrier, Blake Bell
50-50: Vance McDonald, Garrett Celek, Asante Cleveland, Busta Anderson
Must impress: Xavier Grimble
This is the position where a lot of things can happen. The 49ers will look to deal a player or two from this position group, and who might have the most trade value? That's why there's some uncertainty whether McDonald will be on the roster to open the season. Bell has the least experience of anyone on the roster, but the 49ers appear committed due to their investment of a fourth-round draft pick.

OFFENSIVE LINE (15; keep 8-9)
Locks: Joe Staley, Alex Boone, Daniel Kilgore, Marcus Martin, Erik Pears, Brandon Thomas
Looking good: Trent Brown
50-50: Joe Looney, Dillon Farrell, Ian Silberman, Andrew Tiller
Must impress: Justin Renfrow, Ben Gottschalk, Sean Hooey, Patrick Miller
It appears as if seven players are battling for the five starting jobs. But the 49ers have to figure out what positions to place Boone and Pears. After that, the rest of the pieces should fall into place.

DEFENSIVE LINE (11; keep 6-7)
Locks: Arik Armstead, Darnell Dockett, Glenn Dorsey
Looking good: Tank Carradine, Quinton Dial, Ian Williams
50-50: Tony Jerod-Eddie
Must impress: Mike Purcell, Kaleb Ramsey, Garrison Smith, Lawrence Okoye
This is another spot where there should be good competition. Carradine, Dial and Williams are probably locks, but there's just enough competition behind them to bump them from the "lock" category.

LINEBACKER (13; keep 8-9)
Locks: Aldon Smith, NaVorro Bowman, Michael Wilhoite, Aaron Lynch, Eli Harold
Looking good: Ahmad Brooks, Nick Moody, Nick Bellore
50-50: Philip Wheeler, Corey Lemonier
Must impress: Desmond Bishop, Shayne Skov, Marcus Rush
After a strong offseason, Brooks looks like a "lock." But there remains a lingering question off the field that must be cleared up before he rises to that category. The Santa Clara County District Attorney's office has to yet to determine if any charges against him are warranted stemming from an incident in December at Ray McDonald's house. Brooks was named in a civil lawsuit, accusing him of sexual assault.

CORNERBACK (9; keep 5-6)
Locks: Tramaine Brock, Shareece Wright, Dontae Johnson
Looking good: Keith Reaser, Chris Cook
50-50: Kenneth Acker
Must impress: Marcus Cromartie, Leon McFadden, Mylan Hicks
Brock and Wright enter camp as the favorites to win starting jobs, but there's a solid group of young players who might emerge as factors before the season begins.

SAFETY (7; keep 5)
Locks: Antoine Bethea, Eric Reid, Jimmie Ward, Jaquiski Tartt
50-50: L.J. McCray, Craig Dahl
Must impress: Jermaine Whitehead
The 49ers have chosen a safety high in the draft in each of the past three years. Dahl has been the No. 3 safety for two years in a row. He'll definitely be back if he proves he's the best option as a backup.

SPECIALISTS (4; keep 3)
Locks: K Phil Dawson, P Bradley Pinion, LS Kyle Nelson
Must impress: K Corey Acosta
All the drama ended when the 49ers traded away the best punter in franchise history, Andy Lee, to the Cleveland Brown last month. Pinion takes over, and he'll compete with Dawson for the kickoff chores, too.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 9, 2015 at 12:50 PM ]
Originally posted by DeUh:
Week 1 Roster Projection Jul 7, 2015


QB C.Kaepernick / B.Gabbert

RB C.Hyde / M.Davis
RB K.Hunter / R.Bush
FB B.Miller / T.Millard

WR T.Smith / J.Simpson / D.Anderson
WR A.Boldin / Q.Patton
WR B.Ellington

TE V.Davis / V.McDonald / B.Bell

LT J.Staley
LG A.Boone / B.Thomas
C D.Kilgore / D.Farrell
RG M.Martin
RT E.Pears / T.Brown

LDE Q.Dial / D.Dockett / T.Jerod-Eddie
NT I.Williams
RDE G.Dorsey / T.Carradine / A.Armstead

OLB A.Brooks / A.Lynch
LB M.Wilhoite / P.Wheeler
LB N.Bowman / N.Bellore
OLB A.Smith / E.Harold

LCB T.Brock / C.Cook
RCB S.Wright / D.Johnson / K.Reaser
SCB J.Ward

FS E.Reid / C.Dahl
SS A.Bethea / J.Tartt

K P.Dawson
P B.Pinion
LOS K.Nelson


Reserve / Injured

NFI WR D.Smelter
PUP TE D.Carrier
IR TE R.Anderson / WR D.White / FS LJ.McCray


Returner

K B.Ellington
P R.Bush


Kick Off Coverage Unit

L5 J.Ward
L4 C.Cook
L3 E.Harold
L2 C.Dahl
L1 N.Bellore
K B.Pinion
R1 P.Wheeler
R2 T.Millard
R3 A.Lynch
R4 D.Johnson
R5 J.Tartt


Punt Coverage Unit

Line E.Reid / P.Wheeler / N.Bellore / K.Nelson / E.Harold / A.Lynch / T.Millard
Gunner J.Tartt / J.Ward
Personal Protector C.Dahl
Punter B.Pinion


Inactives

1. M.Davis
2. D.Anderson
3. B.Bell
4. T.Brown
5. T.Jerod-Eddie
6. A.Armstead
7. K.Reaser


Practice Squad

1. D.Thompson
2. I.Blakeney
3. J.Hayne
4. P.Miller
5. I.Silberman
6. G.Smith
7. L.Okoye
8. S.Skov
9. K.Acker
10. J.Whitehead

D. After listening to the podcast in the Mangini thread, we may have to get Moody and/or LJ McCray on this 53. You could probably swap out Dahl with McCray (McCray already is a good ST player) but 50/50 on Moody. We know Baalke loves depth at like-positions. So if Tartt goes down, McCray is in. Or maybe Moody is a better fit for the hybrid SS/ILB role? We may not need both but probably 1 for sure now. Dahl should be done now despite being the personal protector?
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 7:54 AM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by NCommand:
53-man Roster Projections:

Starter --- Rookie --- (Injured Reserve/Inactive PUP)(Key Backup)

Offensive Personnel: (25) (23 last year)
(2) QB: Colin Kaepernick; Blaine Gabbert (Blake Bell)
(2) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 3 QB's in Kaepernick, Gabbert & Johnson

(2) RB1: Carlos Hyde; Mike Davis
(2) RB2: Reggie Bush; Kendall Hunter
(4)
Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 3 RB's in Gore, Hyde & James

(1) H-Back: Trey Millard
(3)
TE: Vernon Davis; Vance McDonald & Blake Bell
(4) Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 3 TE's in Davis, McDonald & Carrier

(1) FB: Bruce Miller; (Trey Millard)
(1) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 1 FB in Miller

(2) X WR: Torrey Smith; Jerome Simpson
(2) Y WR (SLOT): Bruce Ellington; DeAndrew White
(2) Z WR: Anquan Boldin; Quinton Patton (DeAndre Smelter)
(6) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 6 WR's in Crabtree, Boldin, Johnson, Lloyd, Patton & Ellington

(1) LOT: Joe Staley; (Alex Boone)
(2) LG: Alex Boone; Brandon Thomas
(2) C: Daniel Kilgore; Joe Looney
(1) RG: Marcus Martin (Joe Looney)
(2) ROT: Erik Pears; Trenton Brown
(8) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 9 OL's in Staley, Iupati, Kilgore, Boone, Looney, J.Martin, Davis, Farrell & M.Martin

Defensive Personnel: (25) (27 last year)
(3) RDE: Glenn Dorsey; Tank Carradine & Arik Armstead
(1) NT: Ian Williams; (Glenn Dorsey & Quinton Dial)
(2)
LDE: Quinton Dial; Darnell Dockett
(6)
Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 7 DL's in Smith, McDonald, Carradine, Jerod-Eddie, Dial, Dobbs & Dorsey

(3) WILL: Aldon Smith; Corey Lemonier & Eli Harold
(2) TED: Michael Wilhoite; Philip Wheeler
(2) MIKE: Navarro Bowman; Nick Bellore
(2) SAM: Ahmad Brooks; Aaron Lynch
(9) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 9 LB's in Smith, Brooks, Willis, Wilhoite, Skuta, Lemonier, Borland, Moody & Lynch

(2) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook
(2) SLOT (S/CB): Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright
(6) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 6 CB's in Culliver, Brock, Ward, Cook, Cox & Johnson

(1) FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward)
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt)
(1) NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt; L.J. McCray
(4) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 4 S's in Bethea, Reid, McCray & Dahl

Special Teams: (3) (3 last year)
(1) LS: Kyle Nelson
(1) PK: Phil Dawson; (Bradley Pinion)
(1) P: Bradley Pinion
(3) Notes: Even – Last year we kept 3 ST's in Dawson, Lee & Nelson

PR/KOR: Bruce Ellington/Reggie Bush/Kendall Hunter

Inactive PUP: Z WR DeAndre Smelter & H-Back Derek Carrier

Tough cuts: Offense: Dres Anderson, Dillon Farrell & Jarryd Haynes; Defense: Lawrence Okoye, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Nick Moody, Shane Skov & Kenneth Acker; Special Teams: Andy Lee

Updated.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 8:07 AM ]
Maybe a few guys will start out on IR, with the ability to activate later on in the season. Ward is still having foot problems? Haven't heard much about Thomas and his knee? I hope Smelter starts out on IR.
Originally posted by ninergold:
Maybe a few guys will start out on IR, with the ability to activate later on in the season. Ward is still having foot problems? Haven't heard much about Thomas and his knee? I hope Smelter starts out on IR.

Thomas seems fine and they continue to bring him along slowly. Ward and Smelter are two guys to keep an eye on for sure but for different reasons. Ward b/c of how his foot is healing and the key role he'll play for us and Smelter b/c he seems to be much further along in his rehab than initially expected.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 8:18 AM ]
Originally posted by ninerjok:
Ya know, a lot of media hacks believe that our roster has been seriously depleted and weakened due to certain retirements and personnel losses. I guess that remains to be seen and they've continued to rehash it to death for weeks now but I found something interesting. The Steelers who we play in week 2 had guess what? Three stalwart defensive players (Polamalu, Taylor and Worillds) all retire this past off-season. Guess how much you've seen written about that by the national media the past couple months? Almost nothing. Well somebody can say that Polamalu and Taylor were old, declining players and the other guy retired to devote himself to religious causes (which is really no different than Borland retiring, just different reasons) but they're really not losing that much personnel wise, and they have young players ready to step up in their place. Well Justin and Pat were older, declining players also (along with Ray McDonald for that matter) with young up-and-coming players waiting in the wings. If we can fortify and stabilize the O-line in the first few games this team will be just fine, and all the dips**t media can sit back & eat crow.
This
I've been making a similar argument for some time now. Like I said before, anyone seriously looking at this roster cannot be negative about the 49ers 2015 unless they want to be.
  • DeUh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,006
Originally posted by NCommand:
D. After listening to the podcast in the Mangini thread, we may have to get Moody and/or LJ McCray on this 53. You could probably swap out Dahl with McCray (McCray already is a good ST player) but 50/50 on Moody. We know Baalke loves depth at like-positions. So if Tartt goes down, McCray is in. Or maybe Moody is a better fit for the hybrid SS/ILB role? We may not need both but probably 1 for sure now. Dahl should be done now despite being the personal protector?


The reason I chose Dahl for the Pre-TC Projection is his new contract (old contract savings if cut -> $1.7M / new contract savings if cut -> $650K).

My hope is Tartt wins the Nr.3 Safety spot (1st team FS snaps at minicamp) and we cut Dahl despite his contract ($0.8M Dead Cap).




ST Coverage Unit (C.Dahl cut)


Kick Off Coverage Unit

L5 J.Ward
L4 C.Cook
L3 E.Harold
L2 LJ.McCray
L1 N.Bellore
K B.Pinion
R1 P.Wheeler
R2 T.Millard
R3 A.Lynch
R4 D.Johnson
R5 J.Tartt

Punt Coverage Unit

Line E.Reid / P.Wheeler / N.Bellore / K.Nelson / E.Harold / A.Lynch / T.Millard
Gunner J.Tartt / J.Ward
Personal Protector D.Johnson
Punter B.Pinion
[ Edited by DeUh on Jul 12, 2015 at 8:37 AM ]
Originally posted by DeUh:
Originally posted by NCommand:
D. After listening to the podcast in the Mangini thread, we may have to get Moody and/or LJ McCray on this 53. You could probably swap out Dahl with McCray (McCray already is a good ST player) but 50/50 on Moody. We know Baalke loves depth at like-positions. So if Tartt goes down, McCray is in. Or maybe Moody is a better fit for the hybrid SS/ILB role? We may not need both but probably 1 for sure now. Dahl should be done now despite being the personal protector?


The reason I chose Dahl for the Pre-TC Projection is his new contract (old contract savings if cut -> $1.7M / new contract savings if cut -> $650K).

My hope is Tartt wins the Nr.3 Safety spot (1st team FS snaps at minicamp) and we cut Dahl despite his contract ($0.8M Dead Cap).




ST Coverage Unit (C.Dahl cut)


Kick Off Coverage Unit

L5 J.Ward
L4 C.Cook
L3 E.Harold
L2 LJ.McCray
L1 N.Bellore
K B.Pinion
R1 P.Wheeler
R2 T.Millard
R3 A.Lynch
R4 D.Johnson
R5 J.Tartt

Punt Coverage Unit

Line E.Reid / P.Wheeler / N.Bellore / K.Nelson / E.Harold / A.Lynch / T.Millard
Gunner J.Tartt / J.Ward
Personal Protector D.Johnson
Punter B.Pinion

Yeah I figured as much. And Fangio was a big fan of McCray but Fangio is gone and like you said, the FO restructured Dahl who they clearly value as a ST ace only. Dahl probably has that edge for now.

But side by side, McCray has more upside, can play that hybrid role, is younger, cheaper, on his rookie contract, etc. and we're in good cap space either way.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone