Originally posted by NCommand:Tough calls indeed. Imma predict here that I think that Patton will probably be a last day cut. I've read that Smelter is much further along than the public thinks, and I hope that's true. And coupled with the reports I'm reading on D. White Patton could be is serious trouble his season. I know it's in shorts and t-shirts but if these reports continue through camp and preseason, and with Smelter having a real chance of seeing the field by week 6 or so, Patton is gonna have to REALLY ball out of his mind (something I'm not hearing so far) to maintain his roster spot. Given how the WR position has been addressed in the draft and the litany of WR's - young WR's - brought in post-draft this just don't look good for Patton.
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Originally posted by NCommand:If we can keep Dres Anderson on the PS THAT would be stealing. I doubt it though. I definitely hope we can keep both Millard and Miller. I doubt that too. But if we do I think the roles would be reversed in that I see Miller being more of the H-back (due to his versatility) and Millard being the FB. Millard is more of a "true" FB. Also, IMHO our O-line will be much stronger with Boone playing RT, Thomas at LG, and Pears at RG (we have Pears listed as a G). Personally I'd like to see Martin win the C job too.
1 edit. Think there is a small chance we can sneak Dres Anderson through on the PS.
Love your efforts here!
Think you're slightly reversed on the Miller/Millard points but I like your others.
I hadn't set the OL yet and just going with how we ended OTAs at the moment. I expect something similar to what you noted there as well.
We have to remember that Smelter is further along than we think and could be activated after week 6 with a 3 week window. Could we sneak Dres on by cutting an older Patton? Do we need to? Or drop a ST player like Lemonier, Bellore, Millard, etc.
Tough calls. I'd hate to have to do cuts. So much to factor in in age, contracts, versatility, upside, fit, etc.
There are 887 users in the forums
Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart
Jun 28, 2015 at 9:45 AM
- 9ersLiferInChicago
- Veteran
- Posts: 11,328
Jun 28, 2015 at 10:17 AM
- 9ersLiferInChicago
- Veteran
- Posts: 11,328
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:Indeed, I do think Wright was somewhat of a panic move [my words] on the part of Baalke. But I honestly think that is a problem of his own making. Going out and drafting so many injured players don't provide much flexibility when you suffer injuries to healthy players, and we're gonna be in trouble if that talent don't/can't produce like Baalke hopes.
I know Wright is making decent money but you're right... he's holding down a valuable roster spot that we can use on other guys with more upside. I think Baalke went too far the other way when he saw what injuries did to our team last year.
As far as the talent assembled its easy to see we are a very good team who should be in the mix of things. Anything less is just hating.
Jun 28, 2015 at 10:29 AM
- NCommand
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 123,365
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Tough calls indeed. Imma predict here that I think that Patton will probably be a last day cut. I've read that Smelter is much further along than the public thinks, and I hope that's true. And coupled with the reports I'm reading on D. White Patton could be is serious trouble his season. I know it's in shorts and t-shirts but if these reports continue through camp and preseason, and with Smelter having a real chance of seeing the field by week 6 or so, Patton is gonna have to REALLY ball out of his mind (something I'm not hearing so far) to maintain his roster spot. Given how the WR position has been addressed in the draft and the litany of WR's - young WR's - brought in post-draft this just don't look good for Patton.
100% agree on Patton. He'll get a legit chance but don't be surprised at the end if Dres and he are in a dead heat we go with the younger guy.
Jun 28, 2015 at 10:59 AM
- ninergold
- Veteran
- Posts: 846
think there might be a surprise trade right before the final cut, to open up a roster spot or two? like the haralson trade?
there is a lot of young, promising competition at wr, te and db. last year, i think farrell surprised a lot of people by making the team.
there is a lot of young, promising competition at wr, te and db. last year, i think farrell surprised a lot of people by making the team.
Jun 28, 2015 at 10:59 AM
- Luckycharms
- Veteran
- Posts: 950
Originally posted by NCommand:Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:Tough calls indeed. Imma predict here that I think that Patton will probably be a last day cut. I've read that Smelter is much further along than the public thinks, and I hope that's true. And coupled with the reports I'm reading on D. White Patton could be is serious trouble his season. I know it's in shorts and t-shirts but if these reports continue through camp and preseason, and with Smelter having a real chance of seeing the field by week 6 or so, Patton is gonna have to REALLY ball out of his mind (something I'm not hearing so far) to maintain his roster spot. Given how the WR position has been addressed in the draft and the litany of WR's - young WR's - brought in post-draft this just don't look good for Patton.
100% agree on Patton. He'll get a legit chance but don't be surprised at the end if Dres and he are in a dead heat we go with the younger guy.
Patton has gotten a lot of love during OTA's as well. If you use that as an example for D.White or Dres you have to include Patton as well. Even Curry the WR coach had a lot of good things to say about Patton. I think we would keep Patton over Simpson. I think Patton would be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart, which means Dres, white, and Simpson would be competing for the final 1 or 2 WR spots.
With all our young talent at WR I really think we keep 6 WR's on the roster.
Boldin
T. Smith
Ellington
Patton
Simpson
White
Then have Smelter on the NFI with a week 6 designation to return. If Smelter is completely healthy and able to contribute come week 6-9 then we can activate him and get rid of either Simpson or white, who ever has shown the least in practice/games. By then we should have a good feel for if White is the real deal, and if Simpson is worth keeping.
Jun 28, 2015 at 11:34 AM
- 9ersLiferInChicago
- Veteran
- Posts: 11,328
Originally posted by Luckycharms:I agree about 6 WR's, but I doubt that's gonna happen. I just don't know how we make 6 WR's fit on the 53.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Tough calls indeed. Imma predict here that I think that Patton will probably be a last day cut. I've read that Smelter is much further along than the public thinks, and I hope that's true. And coupled with the reports I'm reading on D. White Patton could be is serious trouble his season. I know it's in shorts and t-shirts but if these reports continue through camp and preseason, and with Smelter having a real chance of seeing the field by week 6 or so, Patton is gonna have to REALLY ball out of his mind (something I'm not hearing so far) to maintain his roster spot. Given how the WR position has been addressed in the draft and the litany of WR's - young WR's - brought in post-draft this just don't look good for Patton.
100% agree on Patton. He'll get a legit chance but don't be surprised at the end if Dres and he are in a dead heat we go with the younger guy.
Patton has gotten a lot of love during OTA's as well. If you use that as an example for D.White or Dres you have to include Patton as well. Even Curry the WR coach had a lot of good things to say about Patton. I think we would keep Patton over Simpson. I think Patton would be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart, which means Dres, white, and Simpson would be competing for the final 1 or 2 WR spots.
With all our young talent at WR I really think we keep 6 WR's on the roster.
Boldin
T. Smith
Ellington
Patton
Simpson
White
Then have Smelter on the NFI with a week 6 designation to return. If Smelter is completely healthy and able to contribute come week 6-9 then we can activate him and get rid of either Simpson or white, who ever has shown the least in practice/games. By then we should have a good feel for if White is the real deal, and if Simpson is worth keeping.
No way on the planet is Patton is gonna be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Simpson is all-that. But he does bring an element to the offense that Patton hasn't proven he can do: stretch the field. For far too long this team has been overstocked with "possession WR's", which is what Patton has been thus far. With Simpson we get both. The only thing Patton has over Simpson is toughness and blocking. Now, I know those things are important. But we have those things, and then some, in abundance from our two starters. But from what I'm reading and hearing of D. White, if he keeps that up he just could jump both Patton and Simpson on the depth chart. And based on what I've seen of Patton that just don't bode well for him.
Jun 28, 2015 at 1:31 PM
- niners9
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,286
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:Trust me, Busta will make the team. And you're right, we don't need two FB, unless one is strictly a ST ace. (See Kyle Nelson.) But if Miller and Millard are cut who will be our FB? Or do you predict that we won't be needing a FB in our 2015 offense?Originally posted by niners9:I hope Busta Anderson makes the team. I think he will be awesome. Also, am I the only one who thinks Miller AND Millard will not make the team. We don't need two FB. We have a lot of talent all around the roster. I think we could use body's in other positions.
I don't think they both make it. I would say Miller makes it and Millard on PS. And I hope your right about Busta, I see him as a faster Delanie Walker.
Jun 28, 2015 at 1:32 PM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
I know Wright is making decent money but you're right... he's holding down a valuable roster spot that we can use on other guys with more upside. I think Baalke went too far the other way when he saw what injuries did to our team last year.
As far as the talent assembled its easy to see we are a very good team who should be in the mix of things. Anything less is just hating.
I disagree...the injuries the team has suffered recently can be offset by having better depth going into TC...better to have too many good players than to be thin. There is a chance Brock and/or Johnson will be injured, leaving Wright as the most experienced replacement. It will all settle down through TC and the worst that could happen is they release or trade a pretty good player.
Jun 28, 2015 at 5:25 PM
- 9ersLiferInChicago
- Veteran
- Posts: 11,328
Originally posted by dtg_9er:I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
I know Wright is making decent money but you're right... he's holding down a valuable roster spot that we can use on other guys with more upside. I think Baalke went too far the other way when he saw what injuries did to our team last year.
As far as the talent assembled its easy to see we are a very good team who should be in the mix of things. Anything less is just hating.
I disagree...the injuries the team has suffered recently can be offset by having better depth going into TC...better to have too many good players than to be thin. There is a chance Brock and/or Johnson will be injured, leaving Wright as the most experienced replacement. It will all settle down through TC and the worst that could happen is they release or trade a pretty good player.
Jun 28, 2015 at 5:44 PM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?
Just an example...if the two starting CBs go down as they did last year we are in good shape with all the competion. If it happens in camp rather than during the season the team will be able to keep two more good players.
Jun 28, 2015 at 7:50 PM
- AB81Rules
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 34,309
Originally posted by Luckycharms:
Patton has gotten a lot of love during OTA's as well. If you use that as an example for D.White or Dres you have to include Patton as well. Even Curry the WR coach had a lot of good things to say about Patton. I think we would keep Patton over Simpson. I think Patton would be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart, which means Dres, white, and Simpson would be competing for the final 1 or 2 WR spots.
With all our young talent at WR I really think we keep 6 WR's on the roster.
Boldin
T. Smith
Ellington
Patton
Simpson
White
Then have Smelter on the NFI with a week 6 designation to return. If Smelter is completely healthy and able to contribute come week 6-9 then we can activate him and get rid of either Simpson or white, who ever has shown the least in practice/games. By then we should have a good feel for if White is the real deal, and if Simpson is worth keeping.
Something to keep in mind is that if Simpson makes the roster for week 1 his base salary is guaranteed for the season.
Jun 29, 2015 at 7:21 AM
- NCommand
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 123,365
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by Luckycharms:
Patton has gotten a lot of love during OTA's as well. If you use that as an example for D.White or Dres you have to include Patton as well. Even Curry the WR coach had a lot of good things to say about Patton. I think we would keep Patton over Simpson. I think Patton would be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart, which means Dres, white, and Simpson would be competing for the final 1 or 2 WR spots.
With all our young talent at WR I really think we keep 6 WR's on the roster.
Boldin
T. Smith
Ellington
Patton
Simpson
White
Then have Smelter on the NFI with a week 6 designation to return. If Smelter is completely healthy and able to contribute come week 6-9 then we can activate him and get rid of either Simpson or white, who ever has shown the least in practice/games. By then we should have a good feel for if White is the real deal, and if Simpson is worth keeping.
Something to keep in mind is that if Simpson makes the roster for week 1 his base salary is guaranteed for the season.
Agreed. Simpson is making this roster. If T.Smith goes down, no way do we want to eliminate a key ingredient from our offense...we need Simpson's electric speed and deep-play abilities to keep defenses honest. Even if it's just for the "threat" of a deep threat.
Jun 29, 2015 at 7:24 AM
- NCommand
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 123,365
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?
Just an example...if the two starting CBs go down as they did last year we are in good shape with all the competion. If it happens in camp rather than during the season the team will be able to keep two more good players.
Agreed...this is a "passing league" and therefore, we play a lot of DIME and NICKEL. In fact, in the past, our NT only plays 40% of the snaps...our slot CB plays the same. And if injuries hit us like last year, you need a lot of DB's who also, are excellent ST players. I'm guessing Tartt will also assume a 40% role as well in these sets but in place of either Bowman or Wilhoite on passing downs.
I have us keeping the same number of DB's as last year:
(3) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook & Kenneth Acker (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) SLOT/NICKEL/DIME: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright (NICKEL/DIME)
(7) Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 6 CB's in Culliver, Brock, Ward, Cook, Cox & Johnson
(1) FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward)
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt)
(1) NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt
(3) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 4 S's in Bethea, Reid, McCray & Dahl
[ Edited by NCommand on Jun 29, 2015 at 7:25 AM ]
Jun 29, 2015 at 10:37 AM
- 9ersLiferInChicago
- Veteran
- Posts: 11,328
Originally posted by NCommand:7 CB's, and 3 safeties? Hmmmm. . . . That would be interesting; I hadn't thought of it that way. Cannot say that I'd be against it. It'll certainly allow us to keep our young talent. And if we have injuies at either safety spot Ward could fill in. In that reality I cannot see Dahl making the roster. I actually would like to see fall that way, but I just don't think it will though.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?
Just an example...if the two starting CBs go down as they did last year we are in good shape with all the competion. If it happens in camp rather than during the season the team will be able to keep two more good players.
Agreed...this is a "passing league" and therefore, we play a lot of DIME and NICKEL. In fact, in the past, our NT only plays 40% of the snaps...our slot CB plays the same. And if injuries hit us like last year, you need a lot of DB's who also, are excellent ST players. I'm guessing Tartt will also assume a 40% role as well in these sets but in place of either Bowman or Wilhoite on passing downs.
I have us keeping the same number of DB's as last year:
(3) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook & Kenneth Acker (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) SLOT/NICKEL/DIME: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright (NICKEL/DIME)
(7) Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 6 CB's in Culliver, Brock, Ward, Cook, Cox & Johnson
(1) FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward)
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt)
(1) NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt
(3) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 4 S's in Bethea, Reid, McCray & Dahl
I agree that that this is a passing league, and we'll continue to play a lot of nickle and dime. I just don't think Wright was the guy for that. Plus, we have Reaser and Acker for a full season now. I could be wrong - and I hope so - but my worry is that neither Reaser nor Acker (or for that matter, Johnson or Cook) will truly get an honest shot at the other starting CB spot (or even get enough reps to prove they can start) with a guy on the roster who's gonna count the most among CB's against our cap - $3.2 mil, correct me if I'm wrong - a guy in Shareece Wright who has questionable tackling and, from what I can tell, contributes very little on special teams. So with the money Wright is getting paid do you think Johnson has a real chance to start (and I hope Johnson does start BTW)?
Jun 29, 2015 at 10:39 AM
- WRATHman44
- Staff
- Posts: 16,973
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Originally posted by NCommand:If we can keep Dres Anderson on the PS THAT would be stealing. I doubt it though. I definitely hope we can keep both Millard and Miller. I doubt that too. But if we do I think the roles would be reversed in that I see Miller being more of the H-back (due to his versatility) and Millard being the FB. Millard is more of a "true" FB. Also, IMHO our O-line will be much stronger with Boone playing RT, Thomas at LG, and Pears at RG (we have Pears listed as a G). Personally I'd like to see Martin win the C job too.
1 edit. Think there is a small chance we can sneak Dres Anderson through on the PS.
Love your efforts here!
Think you're slightly reversed on the Miller/Millard points but I like your others.
I hadn't set the OL yet and just going with how we ended OTAs at the moment. I expect something similar to what you noted there as well.
We have to remember that Smelter is further along than we think and could be activated after week 6 with a 3 week window. Could we sneak Dres on by cutting an older Patton? Do we need to? Or drop a ST player like Lemonier, Bellore, Millard, etc.
Tough calls. I'd hate to have to do cuts. So much to factor in in age, contracts, versatility, upside, fit, etc.
I also agree that Millard seems like more of an H Back than Miller. Millard is a more agile and explosive athlete. Both of them are positional lead blockers (they won't often pancake a guy, but they rarely miss blocks, and they get through the hole to their blocks reliably)