49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 770 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?

Just an example...if the two starting CBs go down as they did last year we are in good shape with all the competion. If it happens in camp rather than during the season the team will be able to keep two more good players.

Agreed...this is a "passing league" and therefore, we play a lot of DIME and NICKEL. In fact, in the past, our NT only plays 40% of the snaps...our slot CB plays the same. And if injuries hit us like last year, you need a lot of DB's who also, are excellent ST players. I'm guessing Tartt will also assume a 40% role as well in these sets but in place of either Bowman or Wilhoite on passing downs.

I have us keeping the same number of DB's as last year:

(3) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook & Kenneth Acker (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) SLOT/NICKEL/DIME: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright (NICKEL/DIME)
(7) Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 6 CB's in Culliver, Brock, Ward, Cook, Cox & Johnson

(1) FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward)
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt)
(1) NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt
(3) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 4 S's in Bethea, Reid, McCray & Dahl
7 CB's, and 3 safeties? Hmmmm. . . . That would be interesting; I hadn't thought of it that way. Cannot say that I'd be against it. It'll certainly allow us to keep our young talent. And if we have injuies at either safety spot Ward could fill in. In that reality I cannot see Dahl making the roster. I actually would like to see fall that way, but I just don't think it will though.

I agree that that this is a passing league, and we'll continue to play a lot of nickle and dime. I just don't think Wright was the guy for that. Plus, we have Reaser and Acker for a full season now. I could be wrong - and I hope so - but my worry is that neither Reaser nor Acker (or for that matter, Johnson or Cook) will truly get an honest shot at the other starting CB spot (or even get enough reps to prove they can start) with a guy on the roster who's gonna count the most among CB's against our cap - $3.2 mil, correct me if I'm wrong - a guy in Shareece Wright who has questionable tackling and, from what I can tell, contributes very little on special teams. So with the money Wright is getting paid do you think Johnson has a real chance to start (and I hope Johnson does start BTW)?

Yeah, like I just posted in the Mangini thread, all of these DB's will be packaged in different roles. For instance, we're not going to put a 5'10" Ward exclusively on a 6'5" Marshall or TE, etc. We'll move Dontae over there now and if Donate was slated to RCB, Cook will come in if Mangini wants to stay big (like last year) or if there is a speedster WR out there, perhaps he slides Reaser out there.

So labels aren't as important as the roles they will play. Ward and Tartt are hybrids...Ward can play the slot and continue to learn the S role. Tartt can play the robber role taking either Wilhoite/Bowman off the field for better coverage while also learning the S role. Most of the CB's can play outside (both sides) and inside in DIME/NICKEL. We can go big and physical in Cook and Johnson (jam-press at the LOS), go more experienced with Wright and Brock or go youth and speed with Acker and Reaser.

Matchups...this is what Mangini wants and I think this group of 10 players give you the best flexibility to matchup and win with various personnel groupings!

PS: Don't get down on Wright b/c of his time in SD. I live in SD and his stats only tell a small story to how SD uses their CB's (hint...it ain't good). Like Baalke said, don't be surprised if suddenly he looks great here just like Rogers. Wright also started out in the slot before being thrust into an outside role. So again, more experience and versatility.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jun 29, 2015 at 10:52 AM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I can see Brock. But why is D. Johnson gonna be injured?

Just an example...if the two starting CBs go down as they did last year we are in good shape with all the competion. If it happens in camp rather than during the season the team will be able to keep two more good players.

Agreed...this is a "passing league" and therefore, we play a lot of DIME and NICKEL. In fact, in the past, our NT only plays 40% of the snaps...our slot CB plays the same. And if injuries hit us like last year, you need a lot of DB's who also, are excellent ST players. I'm guessing Tartt will also assume a 40% role as well in these sets but in place of either Bowman or Wilhoite on passing downs.

I have us keeping the same number of DB's as last year:

(3) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook & Kenneth Acker (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) SLOT/NICKEL/DIME: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser (NICKEL/DIME)
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright (NICKEL/DIME)
(7) Notes: +1 – Last year we kept 6 CB's in Culliver, Brock, Ward, Cook, Cox & Johnson

(1) FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward)
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt)
(1) NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt
(3) Notes: -1 – Last year we kept 4 S's in Bethea, Reid, McCray & Dahl
7 CB's, and 3 safeties? Hmmmm. . . . That would be interesting; I hadn't thought of it that way. Cannot say that I'd be against it. It'll certainly allow us to keep our young talent. And if we have injuies at either safety spot Ward could fill in. In that reality I cannot see Dahl making the roster. I actually would like to see fall that way, but I just don't think it will though.

I agree that that this is a passing league, and we'll continue to play a lot of nickle and dime. I just don't think Wright was the guy for that. Plus, we have Reaser and Acker for a full season now. I could be wrong - and I hope so - but my worry is that neither Reaser nor Acker (or for that matter, Johnson or Cook) will truly get an honest shot at the other starting CB spot (or even get enough reps to prove they can start) with a guy on the roster who's gonna count the most among CB's against our cap - $3.2 mil, correct me if I'm wrong - a guy in Shareece Wright who has questionable tackling and, from what I can tell, contributes very little on special teams. So with the money Wright is getting paid do you think Johnson has a real chance to start (and I hope Johnson does start BTW)?

Yeah, like I just posted in the Mangini thread, all of these DB's will be packaged in different roles. For instance, we're not going to put a 5'10" Ward exclusively on a 6'5" Marshall or TE, etc. We'll move Dontae over there now and if Donate was slated to RCB, Cook will come in if Mangini wants to stay big (like last year) or if there is a speedster WR out there, perhaps he slides Reaser out there.

So labels aren't as important as the roles they will play. Ward and Tartt are hybrids...Ward can play the slot and continue to learn the S role. Tartt can play the robber role taking either Wilhoite/Bowman off the field for better coverage while also learning the S role. Most of the CB's can play outside (both sides) and inside in DIME/NICKEL. We can go big and physical in Cook and Johnson (jam-press at the LOS), go more experienced with Wright and Brock or go youth and speed with Acker and Reaser.

Matchups...this is what Mangini wants and I think this group of 10 players give you the best flexibility to matchup and win with various personnel groupings!

PS: Don't get down on Wright b/c of his time in SD. I live in SD and his stats only tell a small story to how SD uses their CB's (hint...it ain't good). Like Baalke said, don't be surprised if suddenly he looks great here just like Rogers. Wright also started out in the slot before being thrust into an outside role. So again, more experience and versatility.
Yeah Bro. I feel you. But I do feel that Tartt will likely replace Wilhiote in nickle. Wilhoite has always been a liability on obvious passing downs. Bowman has always been good in coverage. As for Wright, well, even in Mangini's [reported] scheme I still don't think hes a good fit, and fear he'll cost this team plenty before Jimmie T. & Co. becomes convinced of it. Plus, no matter how SD used him he was the most penalized CB in the league. That has nothing to do with how they used him but with him alone.
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Yeah Bro. I feel you. But I do feel that Tartt will likely replace Wilhiote in nickle. Wilhoite has always been a liability on obvious passing downs. Bowman has always been good in coverage. As for Wright, well, even in Mangini's [reported] scheme I still don't think hes a good fit, and fear he'll cost this team plenty before Jimmie T. & Co. becomes convinced of it. Plus, no matter how SD used him he was the most penalized CB in the league. That has nothing to do with how they used him but with him alone.

I do too...but I wouldn't be surprised if Tartt replaces Bowman the most to start the season to allow his body/knee to slowly integrate back into 100% football shape and mobility. But yeah, once Bowman is rolling again, Wilhoite will probably be the better option of the two to be replaced by Tartt.

When I watch tape of Wright, it reminds me so much of Cook's tape in Minnesota last year. You could see all the talent, the ability, height, physicality, range, positioning, etc. So once Cook got here, Donatell reviewed his game tapes and taught him better techniques on tracking balls in the air. Then Cook worked his ass off on it all off season and suddenly, he looked like a totally different player. I would not be surprised if Wright ends up in this same boat.

Now all that said, he's not going to be handed anything. He's got a serious battle on his hand if he wants to start outside facing off against arrow-ups in Johnson, Cook, Brock, Acker, etc. In fact, I would not be surprised if his more realistic shot is against the formally I.R.'d slot CB in Ward (former S with minimal experience). But even then, he's got Reaser to attend with also now who looks electric.

If he does win the battles that 1) means he worked on his weaknesses and earned it and 2) doesn't mean he'll be stuck in that role given the different personnel matchups Mangini promises to deliver.

But he will be one to keep a very close eye on.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jun 30, 2015 at 6:58 AM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Yeah Bro. I feel you. But I do feel that Tartt will likely replace Wilhiote in nickle. Wilhoite has always been a liability on obvious passing downs. Bowman has always been good in coverage. As for Wright, well, even in Mangini's [reported] scheme I still don't think hes a good fit, and fear he'll cost this team plenty before Jimmie T. & Co. becomes convinced of it. Plus, no matter how SD used him he was the most penalized CB in the league. That has nothing to do with how they used him but with him alone.

I do too...but I wouldn't be surprised if Tartt replaces Bowman the most to start the season to allow his body/knee to slowly integrate back into 100% football shape and mobility. But yeah, once Bowman is rolling again, Wilhoite will probably be the better option of the two to be replaced by Tartt.

When I watch tape of Wright, it reminds me so much of Cook's tape in Minnesota last year. You could see all the talent, the ability, height, physicality, range, positioning, etc. So once Cook got here, Donatell reviewed his game tapes and taught him better techniques on tracking balls in the air. Then Cook worked his ass off on it all off season and suddenly, he looked like a totally different player. I would not be surprised if Wright ends up in this same boat.

Now all that said, he's not going to be handed anything. He's got a serious battle on his hand if he wants to start outside facing off against arrow-ups in Johnson, Cook, Brock, Acker, etc. In fact, I would not be surprised if his more realistic shot is against the formally I.R.'d slot CB in Ward (former S with minimal experience). But even then, he's got Reaser to attend with also now who looks electric.

If he does win the battles that 1) means he worked on his weaknesses and earned it and 2) doesn't mean he'll be stuck in that role given the different personnel matchups Mangini promises to deliver.

But he will be one to keep a very close eye on.
A close eye indeed. But just remember, we don't have Donatell anymore. Tim Lewis is the secondary guy now. I just hope Jimmie T. & Co. don't give him more of a shot than the others mentioned due to his salary. From the video I saw of Wright he didn't look all that physical to me, especially at the LOS. He seemed VERY finesse-like, but handsy downfield. He's on the light side, and plays like it. And on a team with bigger and heavier, more physical CB's, he's the lightest at 182lbs. I'm just not sure if his frame, or his game, matches well in this division. Perhaps Baalke is seeing something I'm not (well, that is why they pay him the big bucks and not me I guess). But I just don't see Wright as a good fit for this team in this division.

. . . . . . Oh yeah, BTW, I honestly think Tartt will eventually be the full time starter over Bethea at some point this season. He's that good.
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
A close eye indeed. But just remember, we don't have Donatell anymore. Tim Lewis is the secondary guy now. I just hope Jimmie T. & Co. don't give him more of a shot than the others mentioned due to his salary. From the video I saw of Wright he didn't look all that physical to me, especially at the LOS. He seemed VERY finesse-like, but handsy downfield. He's on the light side, and plays like it. And on a team with bigger and heavier, more physical CB's, he's the lightest at 182lbs. I'm just not sure if his frame, or his game, matches well in this division. Perhaps Baalke is seeing something I'm not (well, that is why they pay him the big bucks and not me I guess). But I just don't see Wright as a good fit for this team in this division.

. . . . . . Oh yeah, BTW, I honestly think Tartt will eventually be the full time starter over Bethea at some point this season. He's that good.

Wow...now THAT is a bold prediction! But I love it.

Yeah, I almost see Wright as major insurance for Ward if that foot doesn't heal 100%. Wright is certainly best suited for the off coverage schemes we run here...not so much for bump and run, press and esp. not jam-press.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
A close eye indeed. But just remember, we don't have Donatell anymore. Tim Lewis is the secondary guy now. I just hope Jimmie T. & Co. don't give him more of a shot than the others mentioned due to his salary. From the video I saw of Wright he didn't look all that physical to me, especially at the LOS. He seemed VERY finesse-like, but handsy downfield. He's on the light side, and plays like it. And on a team with bigger and heavier, more physical CB's, he's the lightest at 182lbs. I'm just not sure if his frame, or his game, matches well in this division. Perhaps Baalke is seeing something I'm not (well, that is why they pay him the big bucks and not me I guess). But I just don't see Wright as a good fit for this team in this division.

. . . . . . Oh yeah, BTW, I honestly think Tartt will eventually be the full time starter over Bethea at some point this season. He's that good.

Wow...now THAT is a bold prediction! But I love it.

Yeah, I almost see Wright as major insurance for Ward if that foot doesn't heal 100%. Wright is certainly best suited for the off coverage schemes we run here...not so much for bump and run, press and esp. not jam-press.

Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
I agree about 6 WR's, but I doubt that's gonna happen. I just don't know how we make 6 WR's fit on the 53.

No way on the planet is Patton is gonna be ahead of Simpson on the depth chart. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Simpson is all-that. But he does bring an element to the offense that Patton hasn't proven he can do: stretch the field. For far too long this team has been overstocked with "possession WR's", which is what Patton has been thus far. With Simpson we get both. The only thing Patton has over Simpson is toughness and blocking. Now, I know those things are important. But we have those things, and then some, in abundance from our two starters. But from what I'm reading and hearing of D. White, if he keeps that up he just could jump both Patton and Simpson on the depth chart. And based on what I've seen of Patton that just don't bode well for him.

This is an excerpt from MM's Q and A reguarding White/Patton/Simpson.

"@DaBRANCH Is the new kid on the block, DeAndrew White a true diamond in the rough? Will he jump the likes of Veteran Patton or Simpson?



MM: White's best chance, of course, is to beat out Simpson, who was not in the league a year ago. If Simpson is not the No. 3 receiver, I don't see the value of keeping him on the roster. Any receiver who is a No. 4 guy has to earn his keep on special teams. Patton and Ellington are the front-runners for that No. 3 job. Plus, if the 49ers part ways with Simpson, it's doubtful he's going anywhere. The 49ers could bring him back after a few weeks if there is an injury or two."

I tend to agree with Maiocco's thinking. I trust what he says since he tends to have a good feel about what the FO and coaching staff think about our players.
  • DeUh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,006
Week 1 Roster Projection Jul 7, 2015


QB C.Kaepernick / B.Gabbert

RB C.Hyde / M.Davis
RB K.Hunter / R.Bush
FB B.Miller / T.Millard

WR T.Smith / J.Simpson / D.Anderson
WR A.Boldin / Q.Patton
WR B.Ellington

TE V.Davis / V.McDonald / B.Bell

LT J.Staley
LG A.Boone / B.Thomas
C D.Kilgore / D.Farrell
RG M.Martin
RT E.Pears / T.Brown

LDE Q.Dial / D.Dockett / T.Jerod-Eddie
NT I.Williams
RDE G.Dorsey / T.Carradine / A.Armstead

OLB A.Brooks / A.Lynch
LB M.Wilhoite / P.Wheeler
LB N.Bowman / N.Bellore
OLB A.Smith / E.Harold

LCB T.Brock / C.Cook
RCB S.Wright / D.Johnson / K.Reaser
SCB J.Ward

FS E.Reid / C.Dahl
SS A.Bethea / J.Tartt

K P.Dawson
P B.Pinion
LOS K.Nelson


Reserve / Injured

NFI WR D.Smelter
PUP TE D.Carrier
IR TE R.Anderson / WR D.White / FS LJ.McCray


Returner

K B.Ellington
P R.Bush


Kick Off Coverage Unit

L5 J.Ward
L4 C.Cook
L3 E.Harold
L2 C.Dahl
L1 N.Bellore
K B.Pinion
R1 P.Wheeler
R2 T.Millard
R3 A.Lynch
R4 D.Johnson
R5 J.Tartt


Punt Coverage Unit

Line E.Reid / P.Wheeler / N.Bellore / K.Nelson / E.Harold / A.Lynch / T.Millard
Gunner J.Tartt / J.Ward
Personal Protector C.Dahl
Punter B.Pinion


Inactives

1. M.Davis
2. D.Anderson
3. B.Bell
4. T.Brown
5. T.Jerod-Eddie
6. A.Armstead
7. K.Reaser


Practice Squad

1. D.Thompson
2. I.Blakeney
3. J.Hayne
4. P.Miller
5. I.Silberman
6. G.Smith
7. L.Okoye
8. S.Skov
9. K.Acker
10. J.Whitehead
[ Edited by DeUh on Jul 7, 2015 at 10:02 AM ]
  • DeUh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,006
Edited post above (LB Depth Chart / Coverage Unit Typos)
If Lemonier is actually as improved as mentioned in some articles...they will have a tough decision at OLB. He may make it before Dahl if they keep Ward as a S/CB.
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
A close eye indeed. But just remember, we don't have Donatell anymore. Tim Lewis is the secondary guy now. I just hope Jimmie T. & Co. don't give him more of a shot than the others mentioned due to his salary. From the video I saw of Wright he didn't look all that physical to me, especially at the LOS. He seemed VERY finesse-like, but handsy downfield. He's on the light side, and plays like it. And on a team with bigger and heavier, more physical CB's, he's the lightest at 182lbs. I'm just not sure if his frame, or his game, matches well in this division. Perhaps Baalke is seeing something I'm not (well, that is why they pay him the big bucks and not me I guess). But I just don't see Wright as a good fit for this team in this division.

. . . . . . Oh yeah, BTW, I honestly think Tartt will eventually be the full time starter over Bethea at some point this season. He's that good.

Wow...now THAT is a bold prediction! But I love it.

Yeah, I almost see Wright as major insurance for Ward if that foot doesn't heal 100%. Wright is certainly best suited for the off coverage schemes we run here...not so much for bump and run, press and esp. not jam-press.


I have a feeling both the current Safeties will be replaced within two years Bathia - age and Reid - concussions .
Originally posted by DeUh:

Reserve / Injured
NFI WR D.Smelter
PUP TE D.Carrier
IR TE R.Anderson / WR D.White / FS LJ.McCray

Returner
K B.Ellington
P R.Bush

Kick Off Coverage Unit
L5 J.Ward
L4 C.Cook
L3 E.Harold
L2 C.Dahl
L1 N.Bellore
K B.Pinion
R1 P.Wheeler
R2 T.Millard
R3 A.Lynch
R4 D.Johnson
R5 J.Tartt

Punt Coverage Unit
Line E.Reid / P.Wheeler / N.Bellore / K.Nelson / E.Harold / A.Lynch / T.Millard
Gunner J.Tartt / J.Ward
Personal Protector C.Dahl
Punter B.Pinion

Inactives
1. M.Davis
2. D.Anderson
3. B.Bell
4. T.Brown
5. T.Jerod-Eddie
6. A.Armstead
7. K.Reaser

Practice Squad
1. D.Thompson
2. I.Blakeney
3. J.Hayne
4. P.Miller
5. I.Silberman
6. G.Smith
7. L.Okoye
8. S.Skov
9. K.Acker
10. J.Whitehead

53-man Roster Projections:

Starter --- Rookie --- (Injured Reserve/Inactive PUP)(Key Backup)

Offensive Personnel: (25) (23 last year)
QB: Colin Kaepernick; Blaine Gabbert (Blake Bell) --- QB C.Kaepernick/B.Gabbert
RB1: Carlos Hyde; Mike Davis --- C.Hyde/M.Davis
RB2: Reggie Bush; Kendall Hunter --- R.Bush/K.Hunter
H-Back: Trey Millard --- T.Millard
TE: Vernon Davis; Vance McDonald & Blake Bell --- V.Davis/V.McDonald/B.Bell
FB: Bruce Miller; (Trey Millard) --- FB B.Miller
X WR: Torrey Smith; Jerome Simpson --- T.Smith/J.Simpson
Y WR (SLOT): Bruce Ellington; DeAndrew White --- B.Ellington/D.Anderson
Z WR: Anquan Boldin; Quinton Patton (DeAndre Smelter) --- A.Boldin/Q.Patton
LOT: Joe Staley; (Alex Boone) --- J.Staley
LG: Alex Boone; Brandon Thomas --- A.Boone/B.Thomas
C: Daniel Kilgore; Joe Looney --- D.Kilgore/D.Farrell
RG: Marcus Martin (Joe Looney) --- M.Martin
ROT: Erik Pears; Trenton Brown --- E.Pears/T.Brown

Defensive Personnel: (25) (27 last year)
(3) RDE: Glenn Dorsey; Tank Carradine & Arik Armstead --- G.Dorsey/T.Carradine/A.Armstead
NT: Ian Williams; (Glenn Dorsey & Quinton Dial) --- I.Williams
LDE: Quinton Dial; Darnell Dockett --- Q.Dial/D.Dockett/T.Jerod-Eddie
WILL: Aldon Smith; Corey Lemonier & Eli Harold --- A.Smith/E.Harold
TED: Michael Wilhoite; Philip Wheeler --- M.Wilhoite/P.Wheeler
MIKE: Navarro Bowman; Nick Bellore --- N.Bowman/N.Bellore
SAM: Ahmad Brooks; Aaron Lynch --- A.Brooks/A.Lynch
RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook & Kenneth Acker (NICKEL/DIME) --- D.Johnson/C.Cook
SLOT/NICKEL/DIME: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser (NICKEL/DIME) --- J.Ward/K.Reaser
LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright (NICKEL/DIME) --- T.Brock/S.Wright
FS: Eric Reid; (Jimmie Ward) --- E.Reid/C.Dahl
SS: Antoine Bethea; (Jaquiski Tartt) --- A.Bethea
NICKEL/DIME (SS/ILB Robber): Jaquiski Tartt --- J.Tartt

Special Teams: (3) (3 last year)
(1) LS: Kyle Nelson --- K.Nelson
(1) PK: Phil Dawson; (Bradley Pinion) --- P.Dawson
(1) P: Bradley Pinion --- B.Pinion

PR/KOR: Bruce Ellington/Reggie Bush/Kendall Hunter

Inactive PUP: Z WR DeAndre Smelter & H-Back Derek Carrier

Tough cuts: Offense: Dres Anderson, Dillon Farrell & Jarryd Haynes; Defense: Lawrence Okoye, Tony Jerod-Eddie, Nick Moody, LJ McCray & Shane Skov and Special Teams: Andy Lee

DeUh, b/c I have so much respect for your work/perspective, I did a side-by-side (---) comparison; players only, not positions, per se.

No real huge differences; you kept TJE, Dahl, Anderson, Farrell where I didn't. I also kept Lemonier and Acker for ST's and White over Anderson by comparison. Without you even having to say a word, I can understand your lean in this direction as well.

I especially liked your Reserve / Injured list:
NFI WR D.Smelter
PUP TE D.Carrier
IR TE R.Anderson / WR D.White / FS LJ.McCray

Genius! This is a way to keep 4 very good developing players in Carrier, Anderson, White and McCray on the roster one more year and we can assume Smelter may be ready to be activated after week 6.

And as if THAT wasn't enough, you went full bore and did the ST including the coverage units, inactives and Practice Squad!

Well...freaking...done!
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 7, 2015 at 11:36 AM ]
  • DeUh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,006
Originally posted by NCommand:
DeUh, b/c I have so much respect for your work/perspective, I did a side-by-side (---) comparison; players only, not positions, per se.

No real huge differences; you kept TJE, Dahl, Anderson, Farrell where I didn't. I also kept Lemonier and Acker for ST's and White over Anderson by comparison. Without you even having to say a word, I can understand your lean in this direction as well.

I especially liked your Reserve / Injured list:
NFI WR D.Smelter
PUP TE D.Carrier
IR TE R.Anderson / WR D.White / FS LJ.McCray

Genius! This is a way to keep 4 very good developing players in Carrier, Anderson, White and McCray on the roster one more year and we can assume Smelter may be ready to be activated after week 6.

And as if THAT wasn't enough, you went full bore and did the ST including the coverage units, inactives and Practice Squad!

Well...freaking...done!


[ Edited by DeUh on Jul 8, 2015 at 6:50 AM ]
Originally posted by Geeked:
I have a feeling both the current Safeties will be replaced within two years Bathia - age and Reid - concussions .

Very possible! I like Tartt and Ward but they will need another safety if the two you mention retire shortly. Hope they can keep McCray as a developmental guy for another year! It doesn't hurt that Tartt and Ward played on the same team in HS and are good friends.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by Geeked:
I have a feeling both the current Safeties will be replaced within two years Bathia - age and Reid - concussions .

Very possible! I like Tartt and Ward but they will need another safety if the two you mention retire shortly. Hope they can keep McCray as a developmental guy for another year! It doesn't hurt that Tartt and Ward played on the same team in HS and are good friends.

McCray is a good one. We have to find a way to keep him...like DeUh noted, I.R.?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone