49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 773 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 9ersLiferInChicago:
Originally posted by ninerjok:
Ya know, a lot of media hacks believe that our roster has been seriously depleted and weakened due to certain retirements and personnel losses. I guess that remains to be seen and they've continued to rehash it to death for weeks now but I found something interesting. The Steelers who we play in week 2 had guess what? Three stalwart defensive players (Polamalu, Taylor and Worillds) all retire this past off-season. Guess how much you've seen written about that by the national media the past couple months? Almost nothing. Well somebody can say that Polamalu and Taylor were old, declining players and the other guy retired to devote himself to religious causes (which is really no different than Borland retiring, just different reasons) but they're really not losing that much personnel wise, and they have young players ready to step up in their place. Well Justin and Pat were older, declining players also (along with Ray McDonald for that matter) with young up-and-coming players waiting in the wings. If we can fortify and stabilize the O-line in the first few games this team will be just fine, and all the dips**t media can sit back & eat crow.
This
I've been making a similar argument for some time now. Like I said before, anyone seriously looking at this roster cannot be negative about the 49ers 2015 unless they want to be.

And the Ravens lost twice as much as them yet, not a peep. It was just the natural transition of a team the year after a Superbowl win.

With our depth we just extended that transition two more years so that Justin, McDonald, Willis, Gore, Crabtree, etc. didn't have to play every down. We rode it as long as possible.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 9:25 AM ]
Originally posted by NCommand:
And the Ravens lost twice as much as them yet, not a peep. It was just the natural transition a team the year after a Superbowl.

With our depth we just extended that transition two years so that Justin, McDonald, Willis, Gore, Crabtree, etc. didn't have to play every down.


As always...people are tied to the "names" we lost rather than the production those "names" were able to give at this point in their respective careers.

Not that they weren't productive (don't get me wrong)...but you cannot miss an opportunity to give a talented, younger player a chance in the name of preserving nostalgia.
Originally posted by reasonable1:
As always...people are tied to the "names" we lost rather than the production those "names" were able to give at this point in their respective careers.

Not that they weren't productive (don't get me wrong)...but you cannot miss an opportunity to give a talented, younger player a chance in the name of preserving nostalgia.

Here's a question fans need to ask.

With the conditions the lost players are in RIGHT NOW, are we capable of winning the Superbowl this year?

Justin's torn up shoulder st 35, Willis' horrible turf toe and torn up feet, Borland and Davis' 'fear' and body-type, specific position and conditioning for a ZBS, Crabtree's overall game, Gore's miles plus the ZBS, etc.

If you are honest with yourself, the answer is that these players are best suited for PT play or backup roles now and expensive ones at that and many young players would have to be cut b/c of the roster tie-ups.

It sucks to lose icons but IMHO this is a natural progression and one that will end up being good for the team in the long run. This statement isn't meant to devalue the love and respect we had for the older regime but a look to transition to the new and to players that have worked hard and have waited patiently for their chance...a chance they are finally getting NOW.
  • DeUh
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 4,006
Originally posted by NCommand:
Yeah I figured as much. And Fangio was a big fan of McCray but Fangio is gone and like you said, the FO restructured Dahl who they clearly value as a ST ace only. Dahl probably has that edge for now.

But side by side, McCray has more upside, can play that hybrid role, is younger, cheaper, on his rookie contract, etc. and we're in good cap space either way.


He also knows Tomsula since ´12.
Originally posted by DeUh:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Yeah I figured as much. And Fangio was a big fan of McCray but Fangio is gone and like you said, the FO restructured Dahl who they clearly value as a ST ace only. Dahl probably has that edge for now.

But side by side, McCray has more upside, can play that hybrid role, is younger, cheaper, on his rookie contract, etc. and we're in good cap space either way.


He also knows Tomsula since ´12.

Dahl's primary problem isn't McCray, his problem is Tartt.

IIRC the 9ers went with four safeties last year (Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Dahl).

There are four locks this year: Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Tartt.

Dahl and McCray are both competing with the whole rest of the team for a ST slot.
Originally posted by DeUh:
He also knows Tomsula since ´12.

That's a solid point. I'm sure Mangini is familiar with him too. I like this roster a lot and the coaching changes in philosophy and personnel usage. Exciting.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by reasonable1:
As always...people are tied to the "names" we lost rather than the production those "names" were able to give at this point in their respective careers.

Not that they weren't productive (don't get me wrong)...but you cannot miss an opportunity to give a talented, younger player a chance in the name of preserving nostalgia.

Here's a question fans need to ask.

With the conditions the lost players are in RIGHT NOW, are we capable of winning the Superbowl this year?

Justin's torn up shoulder st 35, Willis' horrible turf toe and torn up feet, Borland and Davis' 'fear' and body-type, specific position and conditioning for a ZBS, Crabtree's overall game, Gore's miles plus the ZBS, etc.

If you are honest with yourself, the answer is that these players are best suited for PT play or backup roles now and expensive ones at that and many young players would have to be cut b/c of the roster tie-ups.

It sucks to lose icons but IMHO this is a natural progression and one that will end up being good for the team in the long run. This statement isn't meant to devalue the love and respect we had for the older regime but a look to transition to the new and to players that have worked hard and have waited patiently for their chance...a chance they are finally getting NOW.

I refuse to believe that losing Anthony Davis will be an upgrade to the offensive line. Same for losing Ray Mac on the defensive line, but that one is a little different.
Originally posted by NickSh49:
I refuse to believe that losing Anthony Davis will be an upgrade to the offensive line. Same for losing Ray Mac on the defensive line, but that one is a little different.

Davis now? His fat quitting ass would need to 1) get healthy 2) hit the diet and cardio hard to fit the ZBS and 3) be fully committed to winning.

Obviously IF he did all that we'd ALL be stoked...but...yeah.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by NickSh49:
I refuse to believe that losing Anthony Davis will be an upgrade to the offensive line. Same for losing Ray Mac on the defensive line, but that one is a little different.

Davis now? His fat quitting ass would need to 1) get healthy 2) hit the diet and cardio hard to fit the ZBS and 3) be fully committed to winning.

Obviously IF he did all that we'd ALL be stoked...but...yeah.

We're going to pretend that Anthony Davis wasn't a key part of the success the offensive line has had running the ball over the last four years?

I'm not saying he didn't necessarily regress a tad, but suddenly thinking he's a fat & lazy player is a stretch.
Originally posted by PopeyeJonesing:
Dahl's primary problem isn't McCray, his problem is Tartt.

IIRC the 9ers went with four safeties last year (Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Dahl).

There are four locks this year: Bethea, Reid, Ward, and Tartt.

Dahl and McCray are both competing with the whole rest of the team for a ST slot.

Last year the 4 safety's were Reid, Bethea, Dahl, and McCray. Ward was listed as a CB, but early in TC last year the coaching staff mentioned he and DJ could play safety in emergencies. So this year with the addition of Tartt that will leave Dahl and McCray fighting for that last safety spot.

I would prefer we stick with McCray since he's younger and cheaper, plus I look at his ST ability as about the same as Dahl, along with his play on the field.
Originally posted by NCommand:
D. After listening to the podcast in the Mangini thread, we may have to get Moody and/or LJ McCray on this 53. You could probably swap out Dahl with McCray (McCray already is a good ST player) but 50/50 on Moody. We know Baalke loves depth at like-positions. So if Tartt goes down, McCray is in. Or maybe Moody is a better fit for the hybrid SS/ILB role? We may not need both but probably 1 for sure now. Dahl should be done now despite being the personal protector?

I never thought moody was a good fit to play the hybrid SS/ILB role even though he was a safety for 2 years in college. He struggled with pass coverage and even lost playing time his junior year due to that struggle. Also he is listed at 245lbs now which is more than whilhote (240lbs) and Bowman (242lbs), and he might even be closer to 250 so I'm not sure how well he would be able to cover a TE or RB if he had to.

There's definitely a spot on the roster for a guy like moody though, he's good on ST and is a solid back up ILB, he's also young and can continue to get better, but I just see Tartt as the perfect SS/ILB to play in the box when we go to a 3 or 4 safety look. I'm just a really big fan of Tartt and his potential. I think he will make some big contributions to our defense as a rookie and will take over for Bethea in a year or 2 and be one of the better safety's in the league.
Originally posted by NickSh49:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by NickSh49:
I refuse to believe that losing Anthony Davis will be an upgrade to the offensive line. Same for losing Ray Mac on the defensive line, but that one is a little different.

Davis now? His fat quitting ass would need to 1) get healthy 2) hit the diet and cardio hard to fit the ZBS and 3) be fully committed to winning.

Obviously IF he did all that we'd ALL be stoked...but...yeah.

We're going to pretend that Anthony Davis wasn't a key part of the success the offensive line has had running the ball over the last four years?

I'm not saying he didn't necessarily regress a tad, but suddenly thinking he's a fat & lazy player is a stretch.

Certainly not. Davis was a motivated player back then (2 years ago)...with an attitude and a perfect fit for the power run scheme against a league that was more focused on stopping the pass (not the run). He played 7 games last year and was average at best. Now? He's retired. We can't live in the past or focus on hypothetical situations.

Does Pears have more overall talent than Davis? Of course not...but Pears right NOW, is a much better fit for a ZBS, is proven in that scheme in the NFL (Davis is not), and may have been able to give Davis a run for his money at RT esp. if Davis' heart, body and mind wasn't in the right place.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 3:36 PM ]
Originally posted by Luckycharms:
Last year the 4 safety's were Reid, Bethea, Dahl, and McCray. Ward was listed as a CB, but early in TC last year the coaching staff mentioned he and DJ could play safety in emergencies. So this year with the addition of Tartt that will leave Dahl and McCray fighting for that last safety spot.

I would prefer we stick with McCray since he's younger and cheaper, plus I look at his ST ability as about the same as Dahl, along with his play on the field.

This for sure!

Originally posted by Luckycharms:
I never thought moody was a good fit to play the hybrid SS/ILB role even though he was a safety for 2 years in college. He struggled with pass coverage and even lost playing time his junior year due to that struggle. Also he is listed at 245lbs now which is more than whilhote (240lbs) and Bowman (242lbs), and he might even be closer to 250 so I'm not sure how well he would be able to cover a TE or RB if he had to.

There's definitely a spot on the roster for a guy like moody though, he's good on ST and is a solid back up ILB, he's also young and can continue to get better, but I just see Tartt as the perfect SS/ILB to play in the box when we go to a 3 or 4 safety look. I'm just a really big fan of Tartt and his potential. I think he will make some big contributions to our defense as a rookie and will take over for Bethea in a year or 2 and be one of the better safety's in the league.

Agreed. Right now I don't have Moody making the 53 esp. b/c of the hybrid abilities of both Tartt and now, McCray. This is going to be very fun to watch Tartt as an enforcer in the middle of the field for sure!
Moody will need to prove his worth now that Bellore is on the team.
Originally posted by ninergold:
Moody will need to prove his worth now that Bellore is on the team.

Agree and MM agrees as well:

http://www.csnbayarea.com/49ers/early-odds-make-49ers-53-man-rosterMMWhen
SAFETY (7; keep 5)
Locks: Antoine Bethea, Eric Reid, Jimmie Ward, Jaquiski Tartt
50-50: L.J. McCray, Craig Dahl
Must impress: Jermaine Whitehead
The 49ers have chosen a safety high in the draft in each of the past three years. Dahl has been the No. 3 safety for two years in a row. He'll definitely be back if he proves he's the best option as a backup.

I think McCray edges out Dahl.
[ Edited by NCommand on Jul 12, 2015 at 3:42 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone