49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 722 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
Alex haters gonna hate, LOL!

- 98

The dude is 5-1, I cant hate on that.
Originally posted by jdc49:
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.


Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team

Hey what the heck is this talk?!?! WE ARE A TOP 3 TEAM!!! Frick dat we are the BEST TEAM IN THE NFL!!! Has it been so long you guys have forgotten?!?! We are the 9ERS BABY!!! Who's got it better than us?!?!
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team

Hey what the heck is this talk?!?! WE ARE A TOP 3 TEAM!!! Frick dat we are the BEST TEAM IN THE NFL!!! Has it been so long you guys have forgotten?!?! We are the 9ERS BABY!!! Who's got it better than us?!?!
That's the spirit!
Q: Did Alex Smith's fundamentals or footwork start to wane a little bit at the end of the Detroit game?

HARBAUGH: No.

Q: He was on point?

HARBAUGH: It wasn't perfect, but I wouldn't say that his fundamentals waned, no.

Q: Was there something he worked on during his days off?

HARBAUGH: Yes, Alex participated in our opportunity practice last Tuesday. He threw again on Thursday. Don't know if he threw yesterday. I believe he's going to throw some balls around today. He definitely worked at it. He's working at it. Keep staying sharp. I didn't think he wanted to go any longer than two, three days without throwing the ball. That's what he told me.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by jdc49:
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.



Long, long paragraph...but... If OTC gives a thumbs up, I'll read.

Glad I did. Right on point and a different, fresher perspective on Alex. Nice job.
[ Edited by ninertico on Oct 24, 2011 at 1:42 PM ]
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team

Hey what the heck is this talk?!?! WE ARE A TOP 3 TEAM!!! Frick dat we are the BEST TEAM IN THE NFL!!! Has it been so long you guys have forgotten?!?! We are the 9ERS BABY!!! Who's got it better than us?!?!

NOBODY!!!
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team

Hey what the heck is this talk?!?! WE ARE A TOP 3 TEAM!!! Frick dat we are the BEST TEAM IN THE NFL!!! Has it been so long you guys have forgotten?!?! We are the 9ERS BABY!!! Who's got it better than us?!?!

NOBODY!!!

these other guys over here would be in the locker room sayin, "well let's see there's the packers, the patriots, the saints, who else am i forgetting..."
HAHAHA
i can just imagine.. it's crickets and the whole team turns around just shakin their heads ...lol ...it's a funny scene in my head right now.
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team

Hey what the heck is this talk?!?! WE ARE A TOP 3 TEAM!!! Frick dat we are the BEST TEAM IN THE NFL!!! Has it been so long you guys have forgotten?!?! We are the 9ERS BABY!!! Who's got it better than us?!?!

NOBODY!!!

these other guys over here would be in the locker room sayin, "well let's see there's the packers, the patriots, the saints, who else am i forgetting..."
HAHAHA
i can just imagine.. it's crickets and the whole team turns around just shakin their heads ...lol ...it's a funny scene in my head right now.

I have a similar scene, except the guy in the corners says, 'Smith ain't elite. Can't throw for 300yds.'

And we're back on thread!!
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by jdc49:
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.



Long, long paragraph...but... If OTC gives a thumbs up, I'll read.

Glad I did. Right on point and a different, fresher perspective on Alex. Nice job.

I'll drink to that
Alex is going to be just fine.
  • Nes49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,105
http://blog.sfgate.com/49ers/2011/10/24/alex-smith-threw-often-during-the-bye-week/

KEEP WORKING!
I looked at the qbr ratings for the year and I think they are accurate as far as the below average quarterbacks
17 Matthew Stafford 34.0 -1.0 -14.6 0.9 19.3 328 1.0 50.3 18 Kyle Orton 15.8 2.1 -10.9 3.4 10.4 192 1.1 47.9 19 Josh Freeman 18.6 6.2 -7.5 -2.2 15.2 340 1.0 47.0 20 Jay Cutler 22.3 -0.4 -12.1 0.5 10.3 298 0.8 45.7 21 Joe Flacco 18.0 0.7 -8.8 -0.9 9.0 268 0.8 45.2 22 Donovan McNabb 10.4 5.1 -8.7 0.4 7.1 206 0.9 44.3 23 Andy Dalton 16.9 0.6 -9.2 1.4 9.7 234 1.3 42.9 24 Rex Grossman 15.8 -1.1 -9.5 2.0 7.2 198 1.1 42.6 25 Colt McCoy 15.2 1.5 -9.8 2.6 9.5 315 1.1 41.5 26 Tarvaris Jackson 17.3 3.3 -13.9 -1.7 5.0 212 1.0 40.2 27 Curtis Painter 12.0 0.4 -11.8 3.4 4.0 143 1.2 39.9 28 Alex Smith 24.3 -2.0 -18.1 0.3 4.5 219 1.1 38.5 29 Kevin Kolb 28.0 -0.6 -24.1 1.6 4.9 262 1.1 38.0 30 Mark Sanchez 15.1 -0.6 -15.3 3.3 2.6 299 1.0 35.6 31 Matt Moore 5.9 -1.3 -9.2 1.2 -3.4 111 1.0 24.9 32 Sam Bradford 7.7 -3.8 -11.0 1.0 -6.0 252 0.7 24.7 33 Blaine Gabbert 3.1 -3.6 -15.1 0.5 -15.1 197 1.0 15.8 33 Kerry Collins -2.9 -0.8 -6.1 1.0 -8.8 116 0.8 13.6

Alex Smith is #28 and I don't think he's better than anyone above him except Chad Henne and he's definitely not better than Rivers or Newton who are on the edge of the top 15. No one would suggest that Dilfer was a great qb even though his team won a championship. Maybe we can win a championship with Alex Smith being the way he is.
Originally posted by eddie_arkadia:
Originally posted by ninertico:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by jdc49:
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.



Long, long paragraph...but... If OTC gives a thumbs up, I'll read.

Glad I did. Right on point and a different, fresher perspective on Alex. Nice job.

I'll drink to that

Read it, love it and totaly agree!!!
Originally posted by Archie:
I looked at the qbr ratings for the year and I think they are accurate as far as the below average quarterbacks
17 Matthew Stafford 34.0 -1.0 -14.6 0.9 19.3 328 1.0 50.3 18 Kyle Orton 15.8 2.1 -10.9 3.4 10.4 192 1.1 47.9 19 Josh Freeman 18.6 6.2 -7.5 -2.2 15.2 340 1.0 47.0 20 Jay Cutler 22.3 -0.4 -12.1 0.5 10.3 298 0.8 45.7 21 Joe Flacco 18.0 0.7 -8.8 -0.9 9.0 268 0.8 45.2 22 Donovan McNabb 10.4 5.1 -8.7 0.4 7.1 206 0.9 44.3 23 Andy Dalton 16.9 0.6 -9.2 1.4 9.7 234 1.3 42.9 24 Rex Grossman 15.8 -1.1 -9.5 2.0 7.2 198 1.1 42.6 25 Colt McCoy 15.2 1.5 -9.8 2.6 9.5 315 1.1 41.5 26 Tarvaris Jackson 17.3 3.3 -13.9 -1.7 5.0 212 1.0 40.2 27 Curtis Painter 12.0 0.4 -11.8 3.4 4.0 143 1.2 39.9 28 Alex Smith 24.3 -2.0 -18.1 0.3 4.5 219 1.1 38.5 29 Kevin Kolb 28.0 -0.6 -24.1 1.6 4.9 262 1.1 38.0 30 Mark Sanchez 15.1 -0.6 -15.3 3.3 2.6 299 1.0 35.6 31 Matt Moore 5.9 -1.3 -9.2 1.2 -3.4 111 1.0 24.9 32 Sam Bradford 7.7 -3.8 -11.0 1.0 -6.0 252 0.7 24.7 33 Blaine Gabbert 3.1 -3.6 -15.1 0.5 -15.1 197 1.0 15.8 33 Kerry Collins -2.9 -0.8 -6.1 1.0 -8.8 116 0.8 13.6

Alex Smith is #28 and I don't think he's better than anyone above him except Chad Henne and he's definitely not better than Rivers or Newton who are on the edge of the top 15. No one would suggest that Dilfer was a great qb even though his team won a championship. Maybe we can win a championship with Alex Smith being the way he is.

That qbr crap is so effed up that it should be thrown out the window with the guys that came up with it. As far as who you think is better, all I gotta say is there are not ten qbs better than Smith, much less 27. 5-1 is the only stat that matters.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone