Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 737 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by HessianDud:
if you watched the Stanford game last night, you saw the ideal version of Harbaugh's offense. Overwhelming power running game. 400 yards rushing.

...And Andrew Luck, the "most sure-fire NFL ready college QB ever," the king of QB Hype, completed 16 of 21 passes for 169 yards, 2 TD's, no INTs.

Why does that stat line look familiar?

The other inconvenient truth.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by TT49ers:
There are alot reasons why Alex doesn't have a lot of yards in the stat Column.

1. Great field position like FireHouse538 mentioned. (Due to special teams and turnovers)
2. Harbaugh wants a balanced team to keep the Defense guessing. (That's why Alex's pass attempts are low compared to other QB's in the league.)
3. Offensive system is WCO, relying on short passes to set up runs and play-action passes. (Unfortunately the receivers are not getting to much YAC)
4. No real deep threat to scare the defense. (Crabtree is quick but not fast, maybe Braylon can be that guy when he gets back and healthy)
5. Drops and penalties see Dtg_9er's post! (This is a huge factor, not only does it effects the QB stats but also kills drives)
6. Being in the lead or keeping the score close. (Not needing to throw to get back into the game)
7. O-line not allowing routes to develop and giving QB a clean pocket to set his feet (Needs more reps at pass-blocking, due to pass years as a so-call power run team)
8. Alex taking the safer play vs the high risk high reward play. (Alex playing smart and not forcing things, in other words taking what the defense gives him)

Great post...and not just because you agree with me!
Originally posted by HessianDud:
if you watched the Stanford game last night, you saw the ideal version of Harbaugh's offense. Overwhelming power running game. 400 yards rushing.

...And Andrew Luck, the "most sure-fire NFL ready college QB ever," the king of QB Hype, completed 16 of 21 passes for 169 yards, 2 TD's, no INTs.

Why does that stat line look familiar?

Hmm...does seem familiar, wonder where I've seen that before? What a game that was, for a Stanford fan anyway.

yep
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
Alex is playing very efficent, but I dont know that if something happened to him, he couldn't be replaced. Harbaugh seems to have the ability to really mold a QB and bring them along in a way that ensures success. To Alex credit, he has taken advantage of this opportunity. With Alex's personality, I think the more he wins, the better he will be. I'd expect him to get better as the season progresses. With that said, I wouldn't be suprised to see his stats go down, but his playmaking increase.

Good offensive systems allow players to be successful almost without regard for who is in the game. I recall Joe Montana being injured and season and Jeff Kemp coming in for a 4 game run and putting up better passing numbers than Montana. Kemp had a much stronger arm than Montana so Walsh just adjusted the routes to allow Kemp to throw deeper passes. Kemp played 10 games that season with a rating of 85 and average gain of 7.5 yards.

Other backups played similarly well for Walsh. Harbaugh seems to be channelling Walsh well.
I for one feel that since 2005 this franchise has let Alex down WAAAAAAAY more than it has been the other way around.finally the franchise gets it right and brings in some legitimate coaching and 6 games in we're 5-1 and Alex is playing very good ball! Of course he's not playing as well as rodgers and Brady and brees who have all had the SAME players and playbooks for how many years in a row now? Watch as this thing unfolds and Alex will only get more and more more comfortable /capable with this O. One thing we should all be praising him for is how he has always represented the red and gold with dignity and class. I'll take that over 300+ yards from big Ben or vick or cutler or cam newton any day! THANK YOU ALEX!!!
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
I for one feel that since 2005 this franchise has let Alex down WAAAAAAAY more than it has been the other way around.finally the franchise gets it right and brings in some legitimate coaching and 6 games in we're 5-1 and Alex is playing very good ball! Of course he's not playing as well as rodgers and Brady and brees who have all had the SAME players and playbooks for how many years in a row now? Watch as this thing unfolds and Alex will only get more and more more comfortable /capable with this O. One thing we should all be praising him for is how he has always represented the red and gold with dignity and class. I'll take that over 300+ yards from big Ben or vick or cutler or cam newton any day! THANK YOU ALEX!!!
Yup. I kinda look at this year as Alex's first REAL rookie season. All the others didn't count because of the crappy coaching. Now we'll get to see what kind of a QB Alex really is!!
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
I for one feel that since 2005 this franchise has let Alex down WAAAAAAAY more than it has been the other way around.finally the franchise gets it right and brings in some legitimate coaching and 6 games in we're 5-1 and Alex is playing very good ball! Of course he's not playing as well as rodgers and Brady and brees who have all had the SAME players and playbooks for how many years in a row now? Watch as this thing unfolds and Alex will only get more and more more comfortable /capable with this O. One thing we should all be praising him for is how he has always represented the red and gold with dignity and class. I'll take that over 300+ yards from big Ben or vick or cutler or cam newton any day! THANK YOU ALEX!!!

your my new hero. this makes more sence than almost every thing ive read in these forums. i cant stand all the haters in here. kids doing good but they think we would be 6-0 with kaep....fkntools.
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.

I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.

82 of Smith's completions have been to wide-receivers or tight-ends. 12 have gones to Gore, 5 to Miller and 4 to Hunter. What is this majority you speak of? Craig and Rathman were catching a higher pecentage back in the day. What game are you watching? Just saying.

Just more unsubstantiated hyperbole. But hey, that's part of what made me a Smith fan in the first place.
[ Edited by 9erfanAUS on Oct 23, 2011 at 7:47 PM ]
Originally posted by Ancient9r:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.

So have I ('watched the team since 76). I watched Joe take the team to the Championship, his third year working with Walsh. Just as Harbaugh's guiding Alex, Walsh was in Montana's ear constantly. These past six games I saw Smith read progressions, defenses, adlib and also make mistakes, so did Joe (this coming from the memory and eyes of a fourteen year old). Your asking for immediate satisfaction (don't worry it's common in this generation), but can't see that through each game the Kid has progressed, improved and yes made a few mistakes, this off of ten weeks of work. I have absolutely no idea if Alex will become the next Deberg, but there will never be another Joe in my eyes. But I believe that this young man has the heart and is willing to do what our past greats have done, absolutely everything. So before you develop an ulcer, let this season play out, watch this team and stop being so biased.

Fantastic post.
Originally posted by 9erfanAUS:
Originally posted by Ancient9r:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.

So have I ('watched the team since 76). I watched Joe take the team to the Championship, his third year working with Walsh. Just as Harbaugh's guiding Alex, Walsh was in Montana's ear constantly. These past six games I saw Smith read progressions, defenses, adlib and also make mistakes, so did Joe (this coming from the memory and eyes of a fourteen year old). Your asking for immediate satisfaction (don't worry it's common in this generation), but can't see that through each game the Kid has progressed, improved and yes made a few mistakes, this off of ten weeks of work. I have absolutely no idea if Alex will become the next Deberg, but there will never be another Joe in my eyes. But I believe that this young man has the heart and is willing to do what our past greats have done, absolutely everything. So before you develop an ulcer, let this season play out, watch this team and stop being so biased.

Fantastic post.
+1
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.
Originally posted by HessianDud:
if you watched the Stanford game last night, you saw the ideal version of Harbaugh's offense. Overwhelming power running game. 400 yards rushing.

...And Andrew Luck, the "most sure-fire NFL ready college QB ever," the king of QB Hype, completed 16 of 21 passes for 169 yards, 2 TD's, no INTs.

Why does that stat line look familiar?

Oh no it's logic in NT ahhhhhh the haters will not like this!
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.

I agree with most of your post, we really should have taken skill players in the 05 draft, the team wasn't ready for a qb with the dismal talent they had. That being said, I am glad to have Smith now, glad that we have a qb that leads by example and keeps his head up even when being booed by idiot fans while dismantling the Shehawks. The guy is a class act all the way and I think a Niner at heart. To win with him at qb makes this year even sweeter, if we go 12-4 or better, I think he should get comeback player of the year. What surprises me most is how clutch he has been so far. He has done what no one since Joe has done at qb for the Niners with three come from behind wins in early games on the east coast, pretty impressive. And before one of you dwindling number of haters even goes there, yes I compared Smith with Montana and no I don't think Smith is Montana, just pointing out an accomplishment they have in common.
[ Edited by Memphis9er on Oct 24, 2011 at 3:14 AM ]
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by AldonGood99:
The saga that has been Alex Smith has brought out different feelings as his career has progressed. I like to think that I'm an objective person. My overall opinion of Alex was he was above average quarterback on a horrendous team that had a severe personnel deficiency coupled with a management structure that was anything but stable. Too many negatives manifesting to ever think that one man alone could reverse the downward spiral the organization had been on. The coaching problems persisted and very slowly the overall talent level rose. But it was a rudderless ship. More so than anyother position, the QB's relationship with the coach needs to be built on granite. We finally have that and we finally have some results that aren't leading to screaming at the TV or midday drunkenness. Yeah, we don't have Aaron Rodgers and I saw him put on a clinic today against the Viks, but for 3 years all Aaron Rodgers had to worry about was learning an offense he wouldn't have to run on Sundays while watching the ol' Gunslinger throw his team out of the playoffs. Alex Smith had to balance the actual profession of learning an NFL offense and manage the responsibilities of being the "Savior" on a terrible team with none of the infrastructure that A-Rodge was afforded. The Niners still boned that draftpick, that is not the arguement. I just think that Alex has been through alot and has never acted in a way that reflected poorly on himself or the franchise. This slice of success he is having has been a treat to watch and I'm happy to witness this. This coming from someone who would have packed up his locker for him at the conclusion of last season. I guess I like a redemption story and watching AS have success has been rewarding. For the fans who think that someone else could be doing this for our team this year, I implore you not to watch Alex or his actions when he does good, but to notice the reactions of teammates and the staff. From "CLUTCH CLUTCH!" to Delanie giving every TD ball back to his QB, these guys are happy for him and more importantly they respect his type of leadership. It's been a great 8 weeks so far as a Niner fan and I can't remember the last time I've gone into a game excited because I know they are going to win and Alex is a part of that. Kudos to him for riding it out. We and he deserve this year! Lets enjoy it and here's to stomping the Browns on Sunday.

I agree with most of your post, we really should have taken skill players in the 05 draft, the team wasn't ready for a qb with the dismal talent they had. That being said, I am glad to have Smith now, glad that we have a qb that leads by example and keeps his head up even when being booed by idiot fans while dismantling the Shehawks. The guy is a class act all the way and I think a Niner at heart. To win with him at qb makes this year even sweeter, if we go 12-4 or better, I think he should get comeback player of the year. What surprises me most is how clutch he has been so far. He has done what no one since Joe has done at qb for the Niners with three come from behind wins in early games on the east coast, pretty impressive. And before one of you dwindling number of haters even goes there, yes I compared Smith with Montana and no I don't think Smith is Montana, just pointing out an accomplishment they have in common.

Guys: try paragraphs!
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team
Originally posted by ace130:
If the 49ers had an elite QB we'd be a top 3 team

If we have an elite receiver we would be a top 3 team
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone