Originally posted by BHulman:He is not. But it wont take him 6 years either.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:So then Alex can be replaced easily then right? Since we don't need a QB to throw for over 200 yards and we still win, then Keapernick should be able to replace Alex easily correct? (after this year) It's not like Alex is putting up even decent numbers in the air . ALEX IS NFL ..................................... "NOT FOR LONG"
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by susweel:
He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.
I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?
haha exactly.
even tho we've only played six games we'd be 10-0 already. I'm so tired of the passing yards argument. Hell, it's not even an argument. It's BS.
If Kaepernick is ready to throw 8 T.D. passes to every 2 interceptions, or better yet 16 T.D. passes for every three 3 interceptions (which is what Alex has done his last 12 games) than maybe.
There are 1,205 users in the forums
Alex Smith Thread
Oct 21, 2011 at 6:56 PM
- 1stAndGoal49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 392
Oct 21, 2011 at 6:58 PM
- OnTheClock
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 38,766
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:So then Alex can be replaced easily then right? Since we don't need a QB to throw for over 200 yards and we still win, then Keapernick should be able to replace Alex easily correct? (after this year) It's not like Alex is putting up even decent numbers in the air . ALEX IS NFL ..................................... "NOT FOR LONG"Originally posted by AXEGRINDER:Originally posted by BHulman:Originally posted by susweel:He's not even throwing for 200 yards a game.
I wonder what the team's record would be if he was?
haha exactly.
even tho we've only played six games we'd be 10-0 already. I'm so tired of the passing yards argument. Hell, it's not even an argument. It's BS.
LOL, Horrible argument. Peyton Manning's yardage was replaced. Oh gee. They're winless. You can replace almost ANY QB's yardage -- it's the other things... like WINS, and the plays they make to get them, that are much more difficult to replace.
LMAO at "Smith is easy to replace because he doesn't throw for 200-300+ constantly."
Ridiculous, and total BS.
[ Edited by OnTheClock on Oct 21, 2011 at 7:00 PM ]
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:00 PM
- taney71
- Veteran
- Posts: 18,642
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
He is not. But it wont take him 6 years either.
Maybe not. But Kaep will not have to deal with having no talent around him and a revolving door at the HC and OC positions. The 49ers organization of 2011 is a much different world to walk into as a QB than the one in 2005. And the 49ers offense is much different in 2011 than it had been from 2004-2010.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:23 PM
- 1stAndGoal49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 392
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:27 PM
- BHulman
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,338
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Leading three come from behind victories in Cincinnati, Philadelphia and Detroit is not special? Before this year the Niners were 3-35 in the Eastern Time Zone. Everyone of those teams is a playoff contender.
[ Edited by BHulman on Oct 21, 2011 at 7:29 PM ]
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:29 PM
- 1stAndGoal49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 392
Originally posted by BHulman:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:31 PM
- AXEGRINDER
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,685
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
read the bolded. I'll ask you yet again.
HOW DO YOU KNOW THIS?
you'll probably find a way to sidestep the question again. Past is past. Now is different. Your argument is invalrod.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:32 PM
- AXEGRINDER
- Veteran
- Posts: 25,685
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.Originally posted by BHulman:Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
I am now convinced that you don't watch actual 49er games.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:33 PM
- father49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 7,522
Originally posted by BHulman:Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Leading three come from behind victories in Cincinnati, Philadelphia and Detroit is not special? Before this year the Niners were 3-35 in the Eastern Time Zone. Everyone of those teams is a playoff contender.
Yeah. If Harbaugh didn't trust Alex then why did he call pass plays on 3rd and 4th downs of the winning drive? I guess that winning pass to Delaney was another dump off.
Give the guy some slack. He's contributing to our wins.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:35 PM
- BHulman
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,338
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
82 of Smith's completions have been to wide-receivers or tight-ends. 12 have gones to Gore, 5 to Miller and 4 to Hunter. What is this majority you speak of? Craig and Rathman were catching a higher pecentage back in the day. What game are you watching? Just saying.
[ Edited by BHulman on Oct 21, 2011 at 7:39 PM ]
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:41 PM
- 1stAndGoal49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 392
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:41 PM
- aTx49er
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,662
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? In the past we've had RB/FBs that were in the top 10 in receptions. And 18% of passes to the RBs is not a majority. I'm just saying.
[ Edited by aTx49er on Oct 21, 2011 at 7:42 PM ]
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:48 PM
- 1stAndGoal49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 392
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
82 of Smith's completions have been to wide-receivers or tight-ends. 12 have gones to Gore, 5 to Miller and 4 to Hunter. What is this majority you speak of? Craig and Rathman were catching a higher pecentage back in the day. What game are you watching? Just saying.
Originally posted by aTx49er:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.
I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? In the past we've had RB/FBs that were in the top 10 in receptions. And 18% of passes to the RBs is not a majority. I'm just saying.
I would love to know how many of Alex Smith passes have been dumped off on the FB and RB this year. Im going to guess it's more then 18%.
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:51 PM
- BHulman
- Veteran
- Posts: 4,338
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I would love to know how many of Alex Smith passes have been dumped off on the FB and RB this year. Im going to guess it's more then 18%.
Look up the stats. It is what I did. If you want to talk about incompetions I can't help you there. But since those "dump-offs" are so high percentage my guess is they do not account for a very large percentage of the incompletions.
[ Edited by BHulman on Oct 21, 2011 at 7:52 PM ]
Oct 21, 2011 at 7:57 PM
- kidash98
- Hall of Fame
- Posts: 26,671
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.
Some might call it managing the game or some might call it coaching. It has been said that he needs to learn his play book in order to succeed. He finally have a coach that can guide him whereas all the successful QB's o the past have had them from the get go.
I will say that I still have doubts with the guy BUT I believe that he will prove me wrong. Let the kid play and let him show doubters wrong.
Unlike the past, he ain't to shabby at this point. 5-1 does that to yah.
- 98