49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 1,106 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.

I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.

82 of Smith's completions have been to wide-receivers or tight-ends. 12 have gones to Gore, 5 to Miller and 4 to Hunter. What is this majority you speak of? Craig and Rathman were catching a higher pecentage back in the day. What game are you watching? Just saying.


Originally posted by aTx49er:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
What Alex is doing right now is nothing special. Look at the numbers.
Now those who support Alex will tell me and you "Alex has not thrown all that many interceptions compared to completions in the last so many games ". And Ill tell them it's because Harbaugh and even Singletary didn't trust him to throw the ball. Most of Alex's passes were and still are high percentage DUMP OFFS. Short passes to Gore. ? It's because Alex is not trusted to make a real NFL QB decision. It's why Gore is considered a threat catching out of the backfield. It's really that simple.

I think high-percentage short passes are a trademark of the West Coast Offense.
Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? It's never been about dumping the majority of the QB's passes off to a RB. Im just saying.

Do you know anything about the West Coast Offense? In the past we've had RB/FBs that were in the top 10 in receptions. And 18% of passes to the RBs is not a majority. I'm just saying.

I would love to know how many of Alex Smith passes have been dumped off on the FB and RB this year. Im going to guess it's more then 18%.

Let's take a look at how many receptions Craig had over the five prime years of his career: 71 in 1984, 92 in 1985, 81 in 1986, 66 (he missed two games) in 1987 and 76 in 1988. Then in 89 Rathman catches 73 balls and Craig chips in with 49. By comparison, Gores numbers over the last five complete seasons are 61, 53, 43, 52 and 46. But the West Coast has never been about throwing the ball to a back. By the way, at the current smoldering pace Gore should have about 30 this year. To be fair, Hunter is on pace for about 10.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.

thats great that you've watched games for 30 years and you feel pain ect., ect, ect.

But what i'm wondering is.......have you watched any this year? If so, have you been paying attention? It's pretty obvious that Alex has not been dumping it off to Gore nearly as much as you say. He's been spreading it around pretty efficiently. And FYI the westcoast offense is built around short high percentage passes, or dump offs as you call them. Alex is doing fine with this offense. It has nothing to do with Harbaugh not trusting him, and everything to do with him executing a game plan. And he's doing a fine job of it.

I'm not trying to get on your back. Just give credit where credit is due. You're trying to cite every stat but the one that truly matters. Wins. You keep up this attitude you're going to end up with egg all over your face.
Originally posted by KDTMDSFC:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.

Some might call it managing the game or some might call it coaching. It has been said that he needs to learn his play book in order to succeed. He finally have a coach that can guide him whereas all the successful QB's o the past have had them from the get go.

I will say that I still have doubts with the guy BUT I believe that he will prove me wrong. Let the kid play and let him show doubters wrong.

Unlike the past, he ain't to shabby at this point. 5-1 does that to yah.

- 98

I want egg on my face. It means Alex is winning and so are my 49ers.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
I want egg on my face. It means Alex is winning and so are my 49ers.

Nice web site.
How is anyone not enjoying the success so far of the team after 6-7 years of crap is beyond me. That's what I'm taking from all this critical complaint of Smith. After contributing his part in getting the team to 5-1, 3-0 on the road (all come from behind wins), I would have to think even if one is an ardent Smith opponent, that at the very least, there would be a feeling of pleasant surprise that Smith and the team is having success. And the support for him is equal to any player that wear the uniform.

Unless, Smith in this year so far, is proving his critics of the last 7 years that they are very wrong. And that he is actually a very good player with the right support and situation. To enjoy the success would be to give in to this and that would be too much for his critics.

To each his own.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
How is anyone not enjoying the success so far of the team after 6-7 years of crap is beyond me. That's what I'm taking from all this critical complaint of Smith. After contributing his part in getting the team to 5-1, 3-0 on the road (all come from behind wins), I would have to think even if one is an ardent Smith opponent, that at the very least, there would be a feeling of pleasant surprise that Smith and the team is having success. And the support for him is equal to any player that wear the uniform.

Unless, Smith in this year so far, is proving his critics of the last 7 years that they are very wrong. And that he is actually a very good player with the right support and situation. To enjoy the success would be to give in to this and that would be too much for his critics.

To each his own.

I honestly think, deep down, there are zoners that would rather be 2-4 with Kaep/Tolzien/anyone else throwing 300-400 yard games. Not trying to stir s**t up but their posts dont lie. On my phone so can't look it up but there are posts where some zoners straight out say "yeah id rather lose knowing my QB can make all the throws/put up yards/etc then have a guy who manages the game and barely wins."

It is what it is. People just need to be happy. Who cares about all the minor things. Enjoy your teams success.
Perhaps some people are afraid this is a mirage and will disappear any game now. Some may want to tweak the zone and others really do not believe Smith is capable of improving--facts of the matter be damned.

I agree with both of you (Lamda and qnnhan7) and am enjoying this season as no other in recent history! Last game was worrisome as the 9ers had not beaten a true top team but now they have and it should be obvious that Harbaugh has changed the team and created a winner. Now we can expect victory each week (sadly not this one) and the biggest games will be in the playoffs--with any luck.

Thanks to you two and all who contribute in a positive manner!
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 22, 2011 at 6:43 AM ]
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
AXEGRINDER ....I have watched this team for over 30 years and when I see a QB who is not allowed to "do his thing" I question it. Alex is "MANAGING THE GAME" Just like Trent Dilfer did. This is what I see. Sorry! Im a 49er fan that feels more pain when they lose then most of you will ever feel..get off my back :) I'm just expressing my opinion on a web page.

So have I ('watched the team since 76). I watched Joe take the team to the Championship, his third year working with Walsh. Just as Harbaugh's guiding Alex, Walsh was in Montana's ear constantly. These past six games I saw Smith read progressions, defenses, adlib and also make mistakes, so did Joe (this coming from the memory and eyes of a fourteen year old). Your asking for immediate satisfaction (don't worry it's common in this generation), but can't see that through each game the Kid has progressed, improved and yes made a few mistakes, this off of ten weeks of work. I have absolutely no idea if Alex will become the next Deberg, but there will never be another Joe in my eyes. But I believe that this young man has the heart and is willing to do what our past greats have done, absolutely everything. So before you develop an ulcer, let this season play out, watch this team and stop being so biased.
I think if you really watch the games a lot of our offenses stats and Alex's stats are affected by our great field position that both the defense and special teams have afforded us in these games.
[ Edited by firehouse538 on Oct 23, 2011 at 8:26 AM ]
Alex is playing very efficent, but I dont know that if something happened to him, he couldn't be replaced. Harbaugh seems to have the ability to really mold a QB and bring them along in a way that ensures success. To Alex credit, he has taken advantage of this opportunity. With Alex's personality, I think the more he wins, the better he will be. I'd expect him to get better as the season progresses. With that said, I wouldn't be suprised to see his stats go down, but his playmaking increase.
Originally posted by firehouse538:
I think if you really watch the games a lot of our offenses stats and Alex's stats are affected by our great field position that both the defense and special teams have afforded us in these games.


Very important point! Another equally important point are the number of offensive penalties on first downs, particularly early in games. If the team has 80 yards to go and you get two false starts, it is now likely Harbaugh chooses to go for field position using conservative plays and punting. When the team has the ball on the 50 due to great special teams Harbaugh is more open and the offense has a short field, reducing the chance for gaudy yardage stats.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by firehouse538:
I think if you really watch the games a lot of our offenses stats and Alex's stats are affected by our great field position that both the defense and special teams have afforded us in these games.


Very important point! Another equally important point are the number of offensive penalties on first downs, particularly early in games. If the team has 80 yards to go and you get two false starts, it is now likely Harbaugh chooses to go for field position using conservative plays and punting. When the team has the ball on the 50 due to great special teams Harbaugh is more open and the offense has a short field, reducing the chance for gaudy yardage stats.

There are alot reasons why Alex doesn't have a lot of yards in the stat Column.

1. Great field position like FireHouse538 mentioned. (Due to special teams and turnovers)
2. Harbaugh wants a balanced team to keep the Defense guessing. (That's why Alex's pass attempts are low compared to other QB's in the league.)
3. Offensive system is WCO, relying on short passes to set up runs and play-action passes. (Unfortunately the receivers are not getting to much YAC)
4. No real deep threat to scare the defense. (Crabtree is quick but not fast, maybe Braylon can be that guy when he gets back and healthy)
5. Drops and penalties see Dtg_9er's post! (This is a huge factor, not only does it effects the QB stats but also kills drives)
6. Being in the lead or keeping the score close. (Not needing to throw to get back into the game)
7. O-line not allowing routes to develop and giving QB a clean pocket to set his feet (Needs more reps at pass-blocking, due to pass years as a so-call power run team)
8. Alex taking the safer play vs the high risk high reward play. (Alex playing smart and not forcing things, in other words taking what the defense gives him)
[ Edited by TT49ers on Oct 23, 2011 at 11:15 AM ]
if you watched the Stanford game last night, you saw the ideal version of Harbaugh's offense. Overwhelming power running game. 400 yards rushing.

...And Andrew Luck, the "most sure-fire NFL ready college QB ever," the king of QB Hype, completed 16 of 21 passes for 169 yards, 2 TD's, no INTs.

Why does that stat line look familiar?
Originally posted by TT49ers:
There are alot reasons why Alex doesn't have a lot of yards in the stat Column.

1. Great field position like FireHouse538 mentioned. (Due to special teams and turnovers)
2. Harbaugh wants a balanced team to keep the Defense guessing. (That's why Alex's pass attempts are low compared to other QB's in the league.)
3. Offensive system is WCO, relying on short passes to set up runs and play-action passes. (Unfortunately the receivers are not getting to much YAC)
4. No real deep threat to scare the defense. (Crabtree is quick but not fast, maybe Braylon can be that guy when he gets back and healthy)
5. Drops and penalties see Dtg_9er's post! (This is a huge factor, not only does it effects the QB stats but also kills drives)
6. Being in the lead or keeping the score close. (Not needing to throw to get back into the game)
7. O-line not allowing routes to develop and giving QB a clean pocket to set his feet (Needs more reps at pass-blocking, due to pass years as a so-call power run team)
8. Alex taking the safer play vs the high risk high reward play. (Alex playing smart and not forcing things, in other words taking what the defense gives him)

Great post...and not just because you agree with me!
Originally posted by HessianDud:
if you watched the Stanford game last night, you saw the ideal version of Harbaugh's offense. Overwhelming power running game. 400 yards rushing.

...And Andrew Luck, the "most sure-fire NFL ready college QB ever," the king of QB Hype, completed 16 of 21 passes for 169 yards, 2 TD's, no INTs.

Why does that stat line look familiar?

Hmm...does seem familiar, wonder where I've seen that before? What a game that was, for a Stanford fan anyway.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone