Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Absolute BS and just a vehement opinion that is greatly debatable. This is disgusting watching people try to make Cam Newton look god-like by saying he has a "**** team" -- BS. He has Pro Bowl OL, two 1000 yard rushers, Pro Bowl WR, and two good TEs in Shockey and Olsen. BULL CRAP he has a bad team. No he doesn't. The Panthers have lacked a good QB for a long time. Newton has finally given them a good one for the future. He's remarkable without question, but stop the nonsense.
Alex Smith, #1 Overall Pick - Started on a terrible team with no talent around him and horrendous coaching.
Cam Newton, #1 Overall Pick - Started on an already very talented team with good coaching.
Newton is by and far the more athletic player with more upside and if they had been in the same draft, he'd have gone first, but you're trying to pump up Newton way too much right now -- not to make him look better really, but to make Alex look worse. I'm sorry, but last I checked, Alex is ranking in the top 10 in the league right now for a number of statistically categories, not just wins.
Alex, finally having that coaching and talent around him, aside from a Pro Bowl OL, is playing like one of the best QBs in the NFL right now. It's not ludicrous to believe there's a correlation between his sudden success and the new coaching, compared to the terrible talent/coaching and mediocrity from the past.
Good post and I would add that we could make the same comparisons to Joe Montana. He isn't/wasn't nearly as gifted as Newton but I think his career speaks for itself. It's lucky for Montana that there is more to being a QB than throwing the ball down the field and running.
There were guys with more talent than Montana. Dan Marino had a quicker release and a stronger arm but Montana had better control over game situations than Marino - IOW, he managed the game better.
I have written on here many times that more than anything else, poor coaching was hindering Alex Smith. Yes, he came to a team with no talent and that slowed the progress a lot but it was the lack of a position coach that had ever played the position that hurt him the most.
All the different OC were problematic but not having anyone in his ear that understood the pressures that are unique to the QB was even greater than the OC issue. I kept track of QB coaches on other teams and over a four year time frame, only one other team had a QB coach who had not played the position. Only one.
Now with a HC who has played it, and a QB coach who has a history of success with the position, we are seeing the emergence of the player we hoped for when he was first drafted.
Finally, I saw every game Joe Montana played as a 49er. Most of them were in the good to very good to great categories. However, there were some stinkers as well. The thing that was different about Montana was that he could be having a poor game but when the chips were down, he could make a play. That was Smith yesterday.