49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 927 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
I feel like the past two games define Alex's career. The dude is extremely talented, smart and gutsy, but he is not elite IMO. He, more than the other great QBs in the league, really needs his team to play well for him to produce. His OL has to block, his receivers have to get open, etc.

Understand I'm not criticizing him, as there are only a couple truly elite QBs IMO (Brady, Manning, Rogers, Brees) and I think he will only get better and better as this team grows up and improves. Once everyone else is executing there jobs perfectly, Alex will play like the best QB in the league. This past sunday in Detroit things didn't go perfect. The OL couldn't handle the noise, the players were all making silly penalties and so on. As a result Alex Smith's play and the whole offense suffered. Last week when the team was playing really well, Alex flourished.

His career will follow a path like this IMO. He'll function as well as those around him. One other thing though that I have to give him credit for is he's extremely clutch. He's always played best when the team needs it the most, so even when he plays a dud of a game he has a chance to pull it out for a win.

This is exactly who Alex Smith is up to this point. If you think he's any more than this at this point, you're projecting. If you think he's less then this you're disregarding.

Spot on post.

Agreed.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Absolute BS and just a vehement opinion that is greatly debatable. This is disgusting watching people try to make Cam Newton look god-like by saying he has a "**** team" -- BS. He has Pro Bowl OL, two 1000 yard rushers, Pro Bowl WR, and two good TEs in Shockey and Olsen. BULL CRAP he has a bad team. No he doesn't. The Panthers have lacked a good QB for a long time. Newton has finally given them a good one for the future. He's remarkable without question, but stop the nonsense.

Alex Smith, #1 Overall Pick - Started on a terrible team with no talent around him and horrendous coaching.
Cam Newton, #1 Overall Pick - Started on an already very talented team with good coaching.

Newton is by and far the more athletic player with more upside and if they had been in the same draft, he'd have gone first, but you're trying to pump up Newton way too much right now -- not to make him look better really, but to make Alex look worse. I'm sorry, but last I checked, Alex is ranking in the top 10 in the league right now for a number of statistically categories, not just wins.

Alex, finally having that coaching and talent around him, aside from a Pro Bowl OL, is playing like one of the best QBs in the NFL right now. It's not ludicrous to believe there's a correlation between his sudden success and the new coaching, compared to the terrible talent/coaching and mediocrity from the past.



somebody pissed off OTC

Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
He, more than the other great QBs in the league, really needs his team to play well for him to produce. His OL has to block, his receivers have to get open, etc.

The 49ers do not need a QB that needs everyone to produce perfectly around him to win games. That's not logical.The 49ers need a QB who can make things happen when the play breaks down, the 49ers need a QB who allows his HC to open up the play book and allow the receivers around him to prosper. You ever think that Davis and Crabtree's names are not being called as much this year because Harbaugh just does not trust Alex to make the play?
Their is a reason why everyone is saying Alex is a "game manager". Is Brees called a game manager ? Does Rodgers or Manning or little Manning manage the game like Alex ? NO! They are trusted by their HC and they produce. Alex is not the QB for the 49ers as long as he handcuffs the playbook.

Im just saying.

Love my 49ers more then I love Alex Smith.
[ Edited by 1stAndGoal49ers on Oct 17, 2011 at 8:54 PM ]
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Absolute BS and just a vehement opinion that is greatly debatable. This is disgusting watching people try to make Cam Newton look god-like by saying he has a "**** team" -- BS. He has Pro Bowl OL, two 1000 yard rushers, Pro Bowl WR, and two good TEs in Shockey and Olsen. BULL CRAP he has a bad team. No he doesn't. The Panthers have lacked a good QB for a long time. Newton has finally given them a good one for the future. He's remarkable without question, but stop the nonsense.

Alex Smith, #1 Overall Pick - Started on a terrible team with no talent around him and horrendous coaching.
Cam Newton, #1 Overall Pick - Started on an already very talented team with good coaching.

Newton is by and far the more athletic player with more upside and if they had been in the same draft, he'd have gone first, but you're trying to pump up Newton way too much right now -- not to make him look better really, but to make Alex look worse. I'm sorry, but last I checked, Alex is ranking in the top 10 in the league right now for a number of statistically categories, not just wins.

Alex, finally having that coaching and talent around him, aside from a Pro Bowl OL, is playing like one of the best QBs in the NFL right now. It's not ludicrous to believe there's a correlation between his sudden success and the new coaching, compared to the terrible talent/coaching and mediocrity from the past.



somebody pissed off OTC


But unlike most 'zoners, his anger brings forth great logic.

GREAT JOB ALEX!!!!!!! KEEP IT UP.
I'm rooting so hard for this guy, I hope he wins like this for the rest of his career.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Absolute BS and just a vehement opinion that is greatly debatable. This is disgusting watching people try to make Cam Newton look god-like by saying he has a "**** team" -- BS. He has Pro Bowl OL, two 1000 yard rushers, Pro Bowl WR, and two good TEs in Shockey and Olsen. BULL CRAP he has a bad team. No he doesn't. The Panthers have lacked a good QB for a long time. Newton has finally given them a good one for the future. He's remarkable without question, but stop the nonsense.

Alex Smith, #1 Overall Pick - Started on a terrible team with no talent around him and horrendous coaching.
Cam Newton, #1 Overall Pick - Started on an already very talented team with good coaching.

Newton is by and far the more athletic player with more upside and if they had been in the same draft, he'd have gone first, but you're trying to pump up Newton way too much right now -- not to make him look better really, but to make Alex look worse. I'm sorry, but last I checked, Alex is ranking in the top 10 in the league right now for a number of statistically categories, not just wins.

Alex, finally having that coaching and talent around him, aside from a Pro Bowl OL, is playing like one of the best QBs in the NFL right now. It's not ludicrous to believe there's a correlation between his sudden success and the new coaching, compared to the terrible talent/coaching and mediocrity from the past.


Good post and I would add that we could make the same comparisons to Joe Montana. He isn't/wasn't nearly as gifted as Newton but I think his career speaks for itself. It's lucky for Montana that there is more to being a QB than throwing the ball down the field and running.

There were guys with more talent than Montana. Dan Marino had a quicker release and a stronger arm but Montana had better control over game situations than Marino - IOW, he managed the game better.

I have written on here many times that more than anything else, poor coaching was hindering Alex Smith. Yes, he came to a team with no talent and that slowed the progress a lot but it was the lack of a position coach that had ever played the position that hurt him the most.

All the different OC were problematic but not having anyone in his ear that understood the pressures that are unique to the QB was even greater than the OC issue. I kept track of QB coaches on other teams and over a four year time frame, only one other team had a QB coach who had not played the position. Only one.

Now with a HC who has played it, and a QB coach who has a history of success with the position, we are seeing the emergence of the player we hoped for when he was first drafted.

Finally, I saw every game Joe Montana played as a 49er. Most of them were in the good to very good to great categories. However, there were some stinkers as well. The thing that was different about Montana was that he could be having a poor game but when the chips were down, he could make a play. That was Smith yesterday.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by Method:
Just really f**king weird when EVERY throw to a WR is high. Just never seen anything like it before, please get this fixed during this bye week; for both parties.

There were some flashback moments there to poor games in the past. However, against an aggressive pass rush, the tendency is to throw it high to get it over the DL's hands. It looked like that was the case in a couple of throws, not all of them.

Also, I still don't think he timing between Smith and Crabtree is where it needs to be. Hopefully the time over the bye week will allow them to settle in better.
Originally posted by dj43:
Now with a HC who has played it, and a QB coach who has a history of success with the position, we are seeing the emergence of the player we hoped for when he was first drafted.

Finally, I saw every game Joe Montana played as a 49er. Most of them were in the good to very good to great categories. However, there were some stinkers as well. The thing that was different about Montana was that he could be having a poor game but when the chips were down, he could make a play. That was Smith yesterday.

Agree with you and have always wondered how good Smith could be with all the ingredients necessary for success and now we are seeing exactly (or close) to that. The line still needs to improve and WR need to get and stay healthy but the rest is there. And you are so correct that he is showing Montana-like qualities.

When considering Smith I kept coming back to his redzone success. One of the most difficult areas for QBs to master but he has always been very successful. Why? Because he could rely more on his instincts rather than a bad coaches plan, shorten the field so team mates could be more consistent in routes, and he is calm in the face of adversity. Anti-Smith people have repeatedly misrepresented these traits as weaknesses, which is my reason for being so doggedly supportive. I hate people jumping on a player as a scape goat. People even called him a coach killer! As if Nolan and Singletary had any business being HCs. His first two OCs became HCs so he really must be a coach maker...that's as logical.

He still has so much room to grow and improve that I am really enjoying this year. The 9ers winning and the players finally filling out their potential.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by dj43:
Now with a HC who has played it, and a QB coach who has a history of success with the position, we are seeing the emergence of the player we hoped for when he was first drafted.

Finally, I saw every game Joe Montana played as a 49er. Most of them were in the good to very good to great categories. However, there were some stinkers as well. The thing that was different about Montana was that he could be having a poor game but when the chips were down, he could make a play. That was Smith yesterday.

Agree with you and have always wondered how good Smith could be with all the ingredients necessary for success and now we are seeing exactly (or close) to that. The line still needs to improve and WR need to get and stay healthy but the rest is there. And you are so correct that he is showing Montana-like qualities.

When considering Smith I kept coming back to his redzone success. One of the most difficult areas for QBs to master but he has always been very successful. Why? Because he could rely more on his instincts rather than a bad coaches plan, shorten the field so team mates could be more consistent in routes, and he is calm in the face of adversity. Anti-Smith people have repeatedly misrepresented these traits as weaknesses, which is my reason for being so doggedly supportive. I hate people jumping on a player as a scape goat. People even called him a coach killer! As if Nolan and Singletary had any business being HCs. His first two OCs became HCs so he really must be a coach maker...that's as logical.

He still has so much room to grow and improve that I am really enjoying this year. The 9ers winning and the players finally filling out their potential.

I am glad to see the team doing well. I am also delighted to see Smith have success. The guy has been such a class act the entire time he has been here. He deserves every accolade that can come his way. Let's just hope he continues to show the improvement as the season goes on.
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
He, more than the other great QBs in the league, really needs his team to play well for him to produce. His OL has to block, his receivers have to get open, etc.

The 49ers do not need a QB that needs everyone to produce perfectly around him to win games. That's not logical.The 49ers need a QB who can make things happen when the play breaks down, the 49ers need a QB who allows his HC to open up the play book and allow the receivers around him to prosper. You ever think that Davis and Crabtree's names are not being called as much this year because Harbaugh just does not trust Alex to make the play?
Their is a reason why everyone is saying Alex is a "game manager". Is Brees called a game manager ? Does Rodgers or Manning or little Manning manage the game like Alex ? NO! They are trusted by their HC and they produce. Alex is not the QB for the 49ers as long as he handcuffs the playbook.

Im just saying.

Love my 49ers more then I love Alex Smith.

You are jumping all over the OP's choice of word here. No one can play a perfect game in the NFL (although I think Montana and Rice came the closest ) Smith like most qb needs his receivers and offensive players around him to play well to succeed in most games. And he also has shown he can succeed on occasion when things go bad to pull out a win. Just like in the Lions' game.

And if trust is in question. Letting Smith run a pass play on a 4th and goal without calling a time out to talk it over, that's a lot of trust from Harbaugh.
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,636
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
He, more than the other great QBs in the league, really needs his team to play well for him to produce. His OL has to block, his receivers have to get open, etc.

The 49ers do not need a QB that needs everyone to produce perfectly around him to win games. That's not logical.The 49ers need a QB who can make things happen when the play breaks down, the 49ers need a QB who allows his HC to open up the play book and allow the receivers around him to prosper. You ever think that Davis and Crabtree's names are not being called as much this year because Harbaugh just does not trust Alex to make the play?
Their is a reason why everyone is saying Alex is a "game manager". Is Brees called a game manager ? Does Rodgers or Manning or little Manning manage the game like Alex ? NO! They are trusted by their HC and they produce. Alex is not the QB for the 49ers as long as he handcuffs the playbook.

Im just saying.

Love my 49ers more then I love Alex Smith.

You are jumping all over the OP's choice of word here. No one can play a perfect game in the NFL (although I think Montana and Rice came the closest ) Smith like most qb needs his receivers and offensive players around him to play well to succeed in most games. And he also has shown he can succeed on occasion when things go bad to pull out a win. Just like in the Lions' game.

And if trust is in question. Letting Smith run a pass play on a 4th and goal without calling a time out to talk it over, that's a lot of trust from Harbaugh.
Excellent point. I don't know if anyone has mentioned that but even the announcers were saying Harbaugh should call timeout and talk it over. Obviously Harbaugh had full confidence in Alex to run the play correctly...and he did. CLUTCH!!!
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
Originally posted by Baugh_Area:
He, more than the other great QBs in the league, really needs his team to play well for him to produce. His OL has to block, his receivers have to get open, etc.

The 49ers do not need a QB that needs everyone to produce perfectly around him to win games. That's not logical.The 49ers need a QB who can make things happen when the play breaks down, the 49ers need a QB who allows his HC to open up the play book and allow the receivers around him to prosper. You ever think that Davis and Crabtree's names are not being called as much this year because Harbaugh just does not trust Alex to make the play?
Their is a reason why everyone is saying Alex is a "game manager". Is Brees called a game manager ? Does Rodgers or Manning or little Manning manage the game like Alex ? NO! They are trusted by their HC and they produce. Alex is not the QB for the 49ers as long as he handcuffs the playbook.

Im just saying.

Love my 49ers more then I love Alex Smith.

You are jumping all over the OP's choice of word here. No one can play a perfect game in the NFL (although I think Montana and Rice came the closest ) Smith like most qb needs his receivers and offensive players around him to play well to succeed in most games. And he also has shown he can succeed on occasion when things go bad to pull out a win. Just like in the Lions' game.

And if trust is in question. Letting Smith run a pass play on a 4th and goal without calling a time out to talk it over, that's a lot of trust from Harbaugh.
Excellent point. I don't know if anyone has mentioned that but even the announcers were saying Harbaugh should call timeout and talk it over. Obviously Harbaugh had full confidence in Alex to run the play correctly...and he did. CLUTCH!!!

Yes yes yes.

IMO the talk of the coaching staff not trusting Alex is way overblown. Alex is just about the last player they have to worry about, give him some time and call a good play and he'll produce. He does his job incredibly well. The other offensive members, namely the line are the ones being inched along on training wheels.

And B.S. to the "Alex can't do ANYTHING if a play breaks down" he's proven he can improvise countless times this year and I think it's what Harbaugh has improved the most in Smith. Though Alex can make a play out of a broken one and is a great QB he doesn't have the skill to transcend poor offensive play around him. Alex Smith is not an elite QB but he is much better than average and ranks favorably with some franchise QBs who are given much more credit than Alex will ever get (Ryan, Cutler, Flacco, Big Ben, Schaub, eli, Etc.)
don't want to start a new thread on this stat, but i thought maybe i should mention this:

on the murph and mac show, while talking to harbaugh today, they pointed out that alex smith has 3 come from behind wins on the road. this has not been done since 1990, by joe montana. wowza!
Originally posted by 1stAndGoal49ers:
The 49ers do not need a QB that needs everyone to produce perfectly around him to win games. That's not logical.The 49ers need a QB who can make things happen when the play breaks down, the 49ers need a QB who allows his HC to open up the play book and allow the receivers around him to prosper. You ever think that Davis and Crabtree's names are not being called as much this year because Harbaugh just does not trust Alex to make the play?
Their is a reason why everyone is saying Alex is a "game manager". Is Brees called a game manager ? Does Rodgers or Manning or little Manning manage the game like Alex ? NO! They are trusted by their HC and they produce. Alex is not the QB for the 49ers as long as he handcuffs the playbook.

Im just saying.

Love my 49ers more then I love Alex Smith.

Me too. I am glad he made the throw at the end of the game. The previous 58 minutes of the game was horrible. I never thought I would see the day when the rest of the team is good enough to win despite Smith at QB. Crabs made some great catches throughout the game.

I do believe smith is playing as well as he can possibly play. Hopefully this is good enough for the niners to keep winning.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone