-
Silky
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 15,911
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
He can't make all the throws consistently. Had 2 almost picks yesterday. The Smith coolaid around here is laughable.

oh man I was about to go off! Until I scrolled down
-
valrod33
- Hall of Small
-
- Posts: 138,122
It hates sacks way too much. At first I like this new rating system now not so much
-
MaliCali
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 3,400
Dat feels good to be right feeling.
We've all had our 'god f**king dammit Alex' moments... but fistpounds all around to my fellow bro's who also knew his downfalls were more situational than skill/abilities...
...I'll remain grounded in my satisfaction, but one has to be optimistic now through 5 games. In fact he has a 99.8 passer rating and 15td/2int statline over the last 10 games...
-
49ersalldaway126
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 14,549
I hated it after Alex got. A 28.7 after the eagles game last week
-
AllTimeGreat
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 19,094
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
I hated it after Alex got. A 28.7 after the eagles game last week
Lol. How does bringing your team back from 20 points down only get you a 28.7?
-
communist
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 12,482
Originally posted by mkmsn0:
Right, but if you look here http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/7081061/nfl-week-5-total-qbr-season-leaders at the QBR for the SEASON so far, it has Smith as 16th, which is garbage.
Vick is rated higher with 7 INTs to 8 TDs.
Hasselback is rated #3, and has led his team to a 2-3 record.
Hell, Chad Henne is rated higher than Smith at #7, and Henne has 4 INTs to 4 TD.
Jason Campbell, #12, 6 TDs 4 INTs.
Alex Smith - 7 TDs to 1 INT, 65.9% accuracy (#6 in NFL).
That's why the QBR is garbage. It takes into account the OL play (Sacks), Penalties for some reason, and apparently fumbles in excess of 1 weigh super heavily on the rating for only QBs on the 49ers (Hasselback has 3, Romo has 3, Rivers has 4, Roethlisberger has 4, Cassel has 2, Ryan has 3...). It doesn't take into account a good run game and most importantly, A WIN.

That is a joke, isnt it?
-
Whomeam
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,371
Yep, glad they gave Smith a good rating this week but it's still garbage. Last week proved it.
-
NinerFan408
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 747
Originally posted by AllTimeGreat:
Lol. How does bringing your team back from 20 points down only get you a 28.7?
isnt "clutchness" factored into QBR?
-
Jakemall
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 21,807
I don't buy this rating. This has Alex ranked as a middle of the road QB for the season. He hasn't been middle of the road in a single game this season. Even his worst game was better (albiet slightly) than average imo.
-
dj43
- Moderator
-
- Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by valrod33:
It hates sacks way too much. At first I like this new rating system now not so much
That is my major complaint as well. It is true a QB can and should be responsible for avoiding some sacks but I believe they need to adjust the sack value.
-
fastforward
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,756
Originally posted by mkmsn0:
Right, but if you look here http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/7081061/nfl-week-5-total-qbr-season-leaders at the QBR for the SEASON so far, it has Smith as 16th, which is garbage.
Vick is rated higher with 7 INTs to 8 TDs.
Hasselback is rated #3, and has led his team to a 2-3 record.
Hell, Chad Henne is rated higher than Smith at #7, and Henne has 4 INTs to 4 TD.
Jason Campbell, #12, 6 TDs 4 INTs.
Alex Smith - 7 TDs to 1 INT, 65.9% accuracy (#6 in NFL).
That's why the QBR is garbage. It takes into account the OL play (Sacks), Penalties for some reason, and apparently fumbles in excess of 1 weigh super heavily on the rating for only QBs on the 49ers (Hasselback has 3, Romo has 3, Rivers has 4, Roethlisberger has 4, Cassel has 2, Ryan has 3...). It doesn't take into account a good run game and most importantly, A WIN.
I think it also biases toward early TDs. That's why Smith ranks so high in the weekend's performance, and was "piss-poor" last week.
-
Sunshine
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 3,508
QBR is garbage to me because it's not a stat.
Traditional NFL passer rating is a stat. You plug numbers in and get a statistically based rating that generally does a good job of measuring passing efficiency.
QBR is just opinion. Some guy weighs what numbers to plug in for this formula and so numbers will be biased based on his perceptions of different QB's (example: Had Vick, Brady, Rodgers, or Romo played a game identical to Alex's last week they would have received much higher marks).
-
crabman82
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 17,024
QBR is still garbage, just cus it shows alex in a positive light for 1 week isnt changing my opinion, its a manufactured stat that the espn hype machine is promoting,never hear anyone outside of espn talk about it
-
NineFourNiner
- Hall of Fame
-
- Posts: 78,967
Originally posted by crabman82:
QBR is still garbage, just cus it shows alex in a positive light for 1 week isnt changing my opinion, its a manufactured stat that the espn hype machine is promoting,never hear anyone outside of espn talk about it
This. I think it is silly.
-
fryet
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 3,393
What would you do in the following scenario?
49ers get into the playoffs with a 11-5 record and reach the title game where they meet Green Bay. They lose to Green Bay 30-21. In that game, Alex had 2 TD, 0 interceptions, and about 225 passing yards. Aaron Rodgers in the same game had 3 TD, 0 Int, and 350 passing yards. In the off season, Alex is now the hottest commodity by all QB needy teams. He let's the 49ers know that his preference would be to sign with them, but he wants to be highly paid, and he wants a long term deal. If the 49ers agree, they are making a decision that Colin will not be their starting QB for the forseeable future. Colin, in theory, may have a higher ceiling than Alex Smith, and be able to generate the same level of offense as Green Bay, however he is also an unproven player. Do you stick with Alex, or do you roll the dice and gamble on Colin?