There are 315 users in the forums
Originally posted by Furlow:
Well the question is if we did that, would we even get to the playoffs? Seems like we'd have to endure a lot of mistakes or win ugly, based on the way Kyle felt he had to call the games that Trey played in. Agreed about Purdy, as I've said a few times, he really exposed Jimmy and Trey's weaknesses. He seems to fit perfectly with Kyle and they look unstoppable together.
Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Well the question is if we did that, would we even get to the playoffs? Seems like we'd have to endure a lot of mistakes or win ugly, based on the way Kyle felt he had to call the games that Trey played in. Agreed about Purdy, as I've said a few times, he really exposed Jimmy and Trey's weaknesses. He seems to fit perfectly with Kyle and they look unstoppable together.
Unstoppable until he didn't step up into the pocket
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Well the question is if we did that, would we even get to the playoffs? Seems like we'd have to endure a lot of mistakes or win ugly, based on the way Kyle felt he had to call the games that Trey played in. Agreed about Purdy, as I've said a few times, he really exposed Jimmy and Trey's weaknesses. He seems to fit perfectly with Kyle and they look unstoppable together.
Unstoppable until he didn't step up into the pocket
Or maybe we shouldn't have had a backup TE trying to go one on one versus one of the NFL's best pass rushers?
Originally posted by Furlow:
Well the question is if we did that, would we even get to the playoffs? Seems like we'd have to endure a lot of mistakes or win ugly, based on the way Kyle felt he had to call the games that Trey played in. Agreed about Purdy, as I've said a few times, he really exposed Jimmy and Trey's weaknesses. He seems to fit perfectly with Kyle and they look unstoppable together.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
This, of course. It was a poor play call if you expected that to work out.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
This, of course. It was a poor play call if you expected that to work out.
Brock definitely failed to help himself there. He was extremely good in terms of awareness, especially for a rookie, but that play was an example of the opposite. It's ok, even if the result was devastating. It was just bad luck it resulted in a serious injury.
There's no comparison between his awareness and our backups at this juncture.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
With McGlinchy and Kroft both whiffing immediately on their assignments there wasn't much time to do anything to help himself. I don't think he can teleport and he didn't have much room to step up. About all he could've done was Tom Brady it and flop. Which he should've done. He's gonna have to learn to play smarter in those situations.
Originally posted by Hysterikal:
I don't think we will trade him until we've done everything we can to improve his trade value.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I would love to know what Trey Lance's perceived value is among actual football people in front offices. I know in this thread the loud posters believe that he has no value. But I have to assume that most people who get paid to do this for a living have a fundamental understanding that its stupid to place judgment on a young QB after 4 games.
I'd be willing to bet his value is substantially higher among NFL front offices than it seems to be in this thread. What that value is, I dont know.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Originally posted by eric_anthony:
Originally posted by Furlow:
Well the question is if we did that, would we even get to the playoffs? Seems like we'd have to endure a lot of mistakes or win ugly, based on the way Kyle felt he had to call the games that Trey played in. Agreed about Purdy, as I've said a few times, he really exposed Jimmy and Trey's weaknesses. He seems to fit perfectly with Kyle and they look unstoppable together.
Unstoppable until he didn't step up into the pocket
Or maybe we shouldn't have had a backup TE trying to go one on one versus one of the NFL's best pass rushers?
This, of course. It was a poor play call if you expected that to work out.
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
This, of course. It was a poor play call if you expected that to work out.
Brock definitely failed to help himself there. He was extremely good in terms of awareness, especially for a rookie, but that play was an example of the opposite. It's ok, even if the result was devastating. It was just bad luck it resulted in a serious injury.
There's no comparison between his awareness and our backups at this juncture.
With McGlinchy and Kroft both whiffing immediately on their assignments there wasn't much time to do anything to help himself. I don't think he can teleport and he didn't have much room to step up. About all he could've done was Tom Brady it and flop. Which he should've done. He's gonna have to learn to play smarter in those situations.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Maybe if Brock Purdy had a little more experience he would've gotten rid of the ball faster or changed things up pre-snap. I do think things might've been different if Kittle was blocking Reddick.
Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I would love to know what Trey Lance's perceived value is among actual football people in front offices. I know in this thread the loud posters believe that he has no value. But I have to assume that most people who get paid to do this for a living have a fundamental understanding that its stupid to place judgment on a young QB after 4 games.
I'd be willing to bet his value is substantially higher among NFL front offices than it seems to be in this thread. What that value is, I dont know.
Your premise for why some think his trade value might be lower than expected is flawed. It's not simply about passing judgement on Trey Lance after 4 regular season starts, and people who are paid to do this for a living certainly understand this.
My opinion is that the vast majority of people here probably estimate his trade value higher than it actually is… and I think I was one of them, at least prior to the past draft.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Your opinion is flawed just the same since we have no idea what Trey's actual trade value is ATM.