Originally posted by RDB4216:
Originally posted by bigmur49:
Originally posted by JBatta49erfansince81:
How about we give Carolina their First round pick back for next year for Peppers. Or give Oakland a First and 3rd for Nandi.
Isn't Peppers oldish and playing badly??? 1st rounders are for superstars. We could probably get Peppers for a 3rd or 4th. Is he really an upgrade though?
Um there is NO way we could get Peppers for a 3rd or a 4th. Since he's a franchise player, it would actually take two 1st rounds in a trade - although Carolina could take less if they chose. Oakland gave up a 1st for Richard Seymour, so Carolina could certainly expect the same for Peppers. He really isn't "oldish", and the only reason he is playing badly - is because he isn't really playing. He's mad he got franchised and stuck another year in Carolina, so is just riding out the season.
wrong, thats only if we decided to sign him with the franchise tag put on him.
he can be traded for whatever, a 7th round a 1st rounder whatever the panthers wanted they could trade him for. hes like any other player on the roster now. now if he was unsigned and the niners signed him, the niners would owe the panthers 2 1st rounders.
anyone catch adam schefter on espn saying that the niners SHOULD trade a first rounder back to carolina back but this trade most likely wont happen.
i would do this under one condition, that peppers sign a long term contract with us. he is an absolute beast and would definately give our defense a kick in the bum in the pass rush. singletary would keep him in line and keep his whiny side in check.
honestly i would give them a conditional 2nd and if he signs a long term deal with us it goes up to our 1st rounder. i believe peppers has not lost a step and still has 4-5 good years left in him. looks at justin smith (who is a year older)
but I'd give our 1st rounder since it's probably going to be a later one 
don't see that happening though. We would have to give up a lot and swallow that fat contract.
).
why?