Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 836 users in the forums

Jumping back into round 2!

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,331
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by 9moon:
what you're ignoring is the fact that Falk is running the MIKE LEACH offense, and since when did his "pure stats" QBs (include the ones from Texas Tech) gone HIGH in the NFL??

So just because he runs a Mike Leach offense the rest of his skillsets go away? Chip Kelly doesn't exactly run a prototypical NFL offense either.

Goff came from a similar offense and went #1 overall with the Rams giving up a crapload to get him.

If Falk can continue to improve, show NFL teams his ability to make NFL level throws, make proper pre-snap reads, not crumble under pressure then he'll go in the first and possibly top 10 just like Goff.

Connor Cook ran a pro style offense and look what that got him. Whether these guys run a spread offense or not it's about skills which translate to the NFL. Accuracy, good footwork & mechanics, pocket awareness & poise go a long way.

I remember when being a Jeff Tedford coached QB was the stamp of death...then came Aaron Rodgers.

Not all of the players are the same. This kid is rigorous about his approach to the position and hasn't had anything handed to him. I'd put money on him improving his draft position rather than being just another guy.


But again, you're wishing upon a star..

why wait for that to happen when we can FIX the problem now..

again, if we like players who are still there in the 2nd round, I'm all for trading our 1st next year in order to get those guys..

Imagine if we're able to land MYLES and NOAH with the 43rd and 45th, when we wont even know til next year what spot we gonna be on anyhow..

just like last year, I wanted us to move up when DE/DT Leonard Williams fell to the JETS...

would you NOW say that we are better off with BUCKNER because we didn't trade our 1st, or Williams woulda been the better player for us??
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by fan49:
he is inclined if his job is on the line. you think he cares about next years gm if the temas sucks again lol

If he was worried about his job for next year he'd have spent a lot more money in FA. I don't think he is worried and knows he is safe assuming he doesn't screw up the draft which thus far does not appear to be the case.

This
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by SFBuckeye:
I would give up the rest of our picks to get up to get Jack or Spence. We have enough backups! Jack is going to miss 7 months at sometime within the next 10 seasons. I will take 9 good seasons with him. Baalke has missed on thirds as much as he's hit. Why not take a chance on a potential probowler.

Yeah..we've all seen your mock drafts.

No thanks.

LMAO!! 😂😂😂
Originally posted by 9moon:
But again, you're wishing upon a star..

why wait for that to happen when we can FIX the problem now..

again, if we like players who are still there in the 2nd round, I'm all for trading our 1st next year in order to get those guys..

Imagine if we're able to land MYLES and NOAH with the 43rd and 45th, when we wont even know til next year what spot we gonna be on anyhow..

just like last year, I wanted us to move up when DE/DT Leonard Williams fell to the JETS...

would you NOW say that we are better off with BUCKNER because we didn't trade our 1st, or Williams woulda been the better player for us??

I agree with you. These guys guareenting us a top 10 pick next year. We could be picking in the 20s if we add Spence and Jack to our defense. What's the chances of us getting players better than those with our picks. Next year could be like 2012 the worst draft in history. We need guys that can turn into starters and probowlers. We have 2 the chances are low them 5th and 6th round picks are going to turn into all pros. We're not talking about trading multiple 1st round picks to get one player just getting a pick a year early.
Originally posted by SFBuckeye:
Originally posted by 9moon:
But again, you're wishing upon a star..

why wait for that to happen when we can FIX the problem now..

again, if we like players who are still there in the 2nd round, I'm all for trading our 1st next year in order to get those guys..

Imagine if we're able to land MYLES and NOAH with the 43rd and 45th, when we wont even know til next year what spot we gonna be on anyhow..

just like last year, I wanted us to move up when DE/DT Leonard Williams fell to the JETS...

would you NOW say that we are better off with BUCKNER because we didn't trade our 1st, or Williams woulda been the better player for us??

I agree with you. These guys guareenting us a top 10 pick next year. We could be picking in the 20s if we add Spence and Jack to our defense. What's the chances of us getting players better than those with our picks. Next year could be like 2012 the worst draft in history. We need guys that can turn into starters and probowlers. We have 2 the chances are low them 5th and 6th round picks are going to turn into all pros. We're not talking about trading multiple 1st round picks to get one player just getting a pick a year early.

Jack has major question marks regardless of him dunking a basketball. I like spence too but he has off field concerns.
Originally posted by a49erfan77:
Trading into the 2nd would be too costly. Would likely have to give up our 3rd and at least a 2nd next year to do it.

They need to keep next year's picks to trade up for a QB.
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by WildBill:
Where do these fans come from? Must be kids or people who think they pro football but know nothing about football.

1) Trade Gabbert-then who is going to play QB, plus Kaep is no sure thing.
2) Plus more important what makes you think they are going to give up a forth or fifth for any of these players? Because you say so and want it? Buwahahaha...idiots.
3) Get a third round for Kaep? We couldn't even do that with the Broncos because of his salary, some teams wanted to give a forth at the time now it is a dead issue. You think they are going to give a pick for Gab that is the same as Kaep-dream on. Look at what we got Gabbert for. Unless he is coming off a season like Foles when he was at the Eagles-no way.

Bethea is a starter, always good to keep depth and experience. Tank has not panned out yet, but it may be because he was misused. He might break out this year as a situational pass rusher at a light weight. A lesson to those who want to draft a player because of name and don't take into account scheme.

Patton, Devey, and Pears has warranted nothing for teams to want them and give a pick, not even a seventh on draft day. Maybe during TC just b-4 the season and only due to injuries and sudden retirements, like what happened to the niners last season.

The biggest thing is - there is no guarantee that the player you draft, even the first rounders will be any better than what you have of even pan out. Before everyone turned on Tank, Brandon Thomas and Martin, majority of the board here had high hopes and singing there praises, although those who are b***hing about them now won't admit it.

im pretty sure tartt will start over bathea
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by Butter:
They need to keep next year's picks to trade up for a QB.

We all know that and that probably is the best option for the team. But if baalkes job is truly on the line he might trade next years picks, beacause he could care less what the next gm would have. If he used a first to get 2 seconds and aced the draft the 49ers and him would be fine. If he stays pat and we suck he might lose his job. But him on the hot seat is hearsay. Shoot if he turned 2 2nd round picks in and they both started, with our first two picks being starters. We would be in great shape, and he would save his job
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by SFBuckeye:
Originally posted by 9moon:
But again, you're wishing upon a star..

why wait for that to happen when we can FIX the problem now..

again, if we like players who are still there in the 2nd round, I'm all for trading our 1st next year in order to get those guys..

Imagine if we're able to land MYLES and NOAH with the 43rd and 45th, when we wont even know til next year what spot we gonna be on anyhow..

just like last year, I wanted us to move up when DE/DT Leonard Williams fell to the JETS...

would you NOW say that we are better off with BUCKNER because we didn't trade our 1st, or Williams woulda been the better player for us??

I agree with you. These guys guareenting us a top 10 pick next year. We could be picking in the 20s if we add Spence and Jack to our defense. What's the chances of us getting players better than those with our picks. Next year could be like 2012 the worst draft in history. We need guys that can turn into starters and probowlers. We have 2 the chances are low them 5th and 6th round picks are going to turn into all pros. We're not talking about trading multiple 1st round picks to get one player just getting a pick a year early.

I honestly would hope for the best if he trades first next year for 2 2nds, and drafts starters, and maybe a starter in the 3rd. I could care less about next years draft. If we hadd 4 starters to the team, and do well adding a few free agents with all the money we will have from carryover is a win win
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone