Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 821 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Originally posted by wailers15:
Yeah I would rather have Trubisky.

I don't give a shat about Kizers upside. The dude can not complete a pass. Notre Dame plays a cush schedule and his completion % was crap. So bad he got benched.
I just don't understand all this talk about Kizer.

He has a strong arm and he plays for Notre Dame.
Not a fan of him at #2, but ND's strength of schedule is not "cush".
Originally posted by NorthBay49er:
IDGAF if we draft a QB at 2

Every year people say "lets just wait until next year when "OMG AMAZING QB!!!" declares for the draft only to s**t on him when he declares.

No ones ever good enough. Still have to draft 1 before they run out.

LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.


I think lots of people like the thought of drafting a faceless, nameless QB but once you get around to a specific individual, they start looking for reasons why the team should NOT draft the guy since at best youre talking about a 50/50 proposition.


A lot of fans like the idea of drafting a QB off on the future but once people start nit-picking the heck out of every QB and realize that there is a possibility of failure, the attitude shifts to "meh, wait until next year" as none of those guys have been yet nitpicked like crazy. Next year....rinse and repeat. Paralysis by analysis.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.


I think lots of people like the thought of drafting a faceless, nameless QB but once you get around to a specific individual, they start looking for reasons why the team should NOT draft the guy since at best youre talking about a 50/50 proposition.

A lot of fans like the idea of drafting a QB off on the future but once people start nit-picking the heck out of every QB and realize that there is a possibility of failure, the attitude shifts to "meh, wait until next year" as none of those guys have been yet nitpicked like crazy. Next year....rinse and repeat. Paralysis by analysis.

This. You just hope your team has accurately assessed the traits they determine to be vital, scout those traits, go get the guy that has the best set of those traits, and coach/develop him.
  • TheNef77
  • Q46 Draft 3rd place
  • Posts: 1,489
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.


I think lots of people like the thought of drafting a faceless, nameless QB but once you get around to a specific individual, they start looking for reasons why the team should NOT draft the guy since at best youre talking about a 50/50 proposition.

A lot of fans like the idea of drafting a QB off on the future but once people start nit-picking the heck out of every QB and realize that there is a possibility of failure, the attitude shifts to "meh, wait until next year" as none of those guys have been yet nitpicked like crazy. Next year....rinse and repeat. Paralysis by analysis.

Truth.

Anyways, the best thing about whatever QB suits up for us next year...Kyle Shanahan will be his coach.
Originally posted by ltrain:
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Originally posted by wailers15:
Yeah I would rather have Trubisky.

I don't give a shat about Kizers upside. The dude can not complete a pass. Notre Dame plays a cush schedule and his completion % was crap. So bad he got benched.
I just don't understand all this talk about Kizer.

He has a strong arm and he plays for Notre Dame.
Not a fan of him at #2, but ND's strength of schedule is not "cush".

Notre Dame's schedule wasn't as tough as Clemson's or North Carolina's, but he also had far less talent than Watson or Trubisky had around them.

ND had 3360 passing yards in 2015. They lost 2904 of that due to players graduating, being drafted, or missing the season due to injury (starting TE Alizee Jones and starting WR Corey Robinson didn't play a snap in 2016).

Returning players had a combined 456 receiving yards in 2015. Torii Hunter Jr had 363 of those yards and he ended up getting hurt in 2016 and only played in 8 games. Everyone talking about Kizer's accuracy concerns is zeroing in on his completion percentage, but a lot of that was due to being forced to throw to bad receivers who he hasn't had time to develop chemistry with. Kevin Stepherson was his #3 WR for most of the year and the #2 WR when Hunter got hurt. He's a true freshman 3 star recruit. Compare that to Deshaun Watson who is throwing to Mike Williams, Deon Cain, Artavis Scott, and Jordan Leggett who are all NFL prospects (Williams will likely be a top 15 pick and Cain could be a first rounder next year).

Even with an awful supporting cast at the receiver position, Kizer had a passer rating of 152.8 when you take out the NC State hurricane game which is better than Watson's passer rating of 151.1. His completion percentage was 60.6% which is on the lower end, but understandable considering he was forced to play with a bunch of guys who should not have been starting. The things that bother me with Kizer are inconsistent footwork (should be correctable) and a tendency to hold onto the ball for too long which I think he developed in 2015 when he had a great offensive line. It's also tough to get rid of the ball quickly when no one is open and you don't have a Mike Williams or Jordan Leggett who can bail you out on jump balls.
[ Edited by eastcoast49ersfan on Mar 2, 2017 at 4:59 PM ]
Does anyone watch or read any of Matt Waldman's RSP stuff ? They are pretty in depth and I find very interesting. I read them to familiarize myself with different prospects. What do you think of his evaluations? From what I've read, watched and listened he seems a little higher on Mahomes than Trubisky. And, even higher on C Kelly, putting him 2nd on his rankings, which won't come out til April 1st.
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.


I think lots of people like the thought of drafting a faceless, nameless QB but once you get around to a specific individual, they start looking for reasons why the team should NOT draft the guy since at best youre talking about a 50/50 proposition.

A lot of fans like the idea of drafting a QB off on the future but once people start nit-picking the heck out of every QB and realize that there is a possibility of failure, the attitude shifts to "meh, wait until next year" as none of those guys have been yet nitpicked like crazy. Next year....rinse and repeat. Paralysis by analysis.

This. You just hope your team has accurately assessed the traits they determine to be vital, scout those traits, go get the guy that has the best set of those traits, and coach/develop him.

I'm just elated that Shanahan is the HC and is the guy who will be evaluating QBs.
The 2017 NFL Combine continues on Thursday with quarterbacks and wide receivers getting measured. One of the big questions heading into Thursday was how tall Mitch Trubisky is. There had been some early reports he would measure in under 6'2, but he ended up measuring in at 6'2 1/8, with 9 1/2 inch hands.

The difference between 6'1 and 6'2 is not a lot, but for a quarterback, teams will see a problem with a "shorter" quarterback. There are some shorter quarterbacks that have succeeded, but they are viewed as the exception not the rule. There are always concerns about a quarterback being able to sufficiently see down the field to find passing lanes.

Trubisky already has one red flag in only having one year of starting experience. Adding in not having optimal height might have been enough to drop him at least a little bit. I think teams would likely still roll the dice on him, but the height would have been a question.

Some other notable measurements on Thursday:

DeShaun Watson: 6'2 1/2, 9 3/4" hands
Pat Mahomes: 6'2, 9 1/4"
DeShone Kizer: 6'4 1/4, 9 7/8"
Brad Kaaya: 6'3 7/8 (not finding hand size yet)
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.

This. People want darnold but I bet by this time next year people will be skeptical of him. It's rare when you get an Andrew Luck type prospect. We probably won't have that for a while.
Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by WRATHman44:
LOL, this. A year ago, everyone hoped we'd have a shot at Watson. Luck is pretty much the only guy since Manning who was crowned the clear #1 a year early and stayed there.

This. People want darnold but I bet by this time next year people will be skeptical of him. It's rare when you get an Andrew Luck type prospect. We probably won't have that for a while.

I have to say that just watching a game and making a snap judgement about guys who command the field, Darnold, Mahomes, Falk and Trubisky have all impressed me. Watson's final game was really a great showing and has likely raised his stock. Being a gamer is so important in any sport.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by Jcool:

What exactly does that mean?
I'm gonna be stunned but very happy if we go QB at two.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by Jcool:

What exactly does that mean?

I think it means that you're far more likely to draft a dud than a stud.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone