Originally posted by gold49digger:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I think it will go down as an OK draft of so-so talent. A lot of guys around the same level but with some very different skills. GMs will really be able to pick their poison. Do you like a QB who is very accurate? Or a big gamer who throws a lot of interceptions? Will be fascinating to watch over the next few years.
The worst year for QB may be 2011, other than Newton.
First Rounders:
1 Newton
8 Locker
10 Gabbert
12 Ponder
Naw you still have:
2010
1.Sam Bradford
25. Tim Tebow
48. Jimmy Clausen
85. Colt McCoy
2007
1. JaMarcus Russell
22. Brady Quinn
36. Kevin Kolb
40. John Beck
43. Drew Stanton
92. Trent Edwards
2006
3.Vince Young
10. Matt Leinart
11. Jay Cutler
49. Kellen Clemens
64. Tarvaris Jackson
81. Charlie Whitehurst
85. Brodie Croyle
1999
1. Tim Couch
2. Donovan McNabb
3, Akili Smith
11. Daunte Culpepper
12. Cade McNown
50. Shaun King
77. Brock Huard
Man this is sad. When no one in a QB class is actually good. 1999 was lucky to have McNabb and 06 is pretty bad for a hyped up class. 07 was so epic outside the qbs. Willis, Megatron, and Lynch in the first round.
This is just pointing out that it's difficult to judge a QB class and one should not say this is the weakest QB class when there are so many late first/early second guys who might be really good under the right tutelage. What I see happening is fans are looking for a Luck every year, a guy who is almost NFL ready coming out of college. That doesn't happen often and it's no guarantee of success even then. Everyone is thrilled with Prescott but look at his line, RB, WRs and TE. Many QBs would look much better with those team mates.
Who is this year's Prescott? Will it be Mahomes? Or is he jumping up too much? Maybe Peterman? Evans? Kelly?
I'd rather see the niners use a vet bridge QB and build the lines and other positions first...like perhaps a first rate WR! That's why I like the idea of drafting two QBs after the first round. Right now it looks like Mahomes is listed in the 2nd or 3rd round and Peterman is 4th round on CBS's board. That would be fantastic. I wouldn't even mind seeing Gabbert return with Shanahan. He could be much better in this offense. Kaepernick might stay which could be good or bad...no idea. Many are saying he doesn't fit Shanahan's offense, but what does Shanahan say? That's all that matters.