Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 849 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
If Cleveland takes Garrett this trade would be a very nice draft haul. Then you'd have to figure whether a QB in the 10th spot would be equal to the QB available at #2. Not sure I see Cleveland making this trade though as they have as many needs as the 9ers do.

I agree, according to the draft value chart we'd still should be asking for a little more lol.

If they love Trubisky they could do it...I don't see him lasting until the 10th and I think that goes for both qbs all said and done. Kizer would probably be there but IMO he's not on the same level as the other two.

If we pulled that trade off I wouldn't know who'd be the qb though...at this point I think that has to be priority #1 (would love Myles just don't see him dropping).
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Who's gonna be the QB though?

With having the first two picks to open the second round you could have a lot of options there be it moving back to the bottom of the first to get a QB that drops to benefit having the 5th year option, drafting one at #10 like Kizer or Watson or using the acquired 2nd to go after some like Jimmy G
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I agree, according to the draft value chart we'd still should be asking for a little more lol.

If they love Trubisky they could do it...I don't see him lasting until the 10th and I think that goes for both qbs all said and done. Kizer would probably be there but IMO he's not on the same level as the other two.

If we pulled that trade off I wouldn't know who'd be the qb though...at this point I think that has to be priority #1 (would love Myles just don't see him dropping).

The 9ers can't really lose if their choices are Garrett and Trubisky. The only question I would have is whether other QBs are as good as Trubisky? If they can get Falk in the 3rd and he's equal to Trubisky in Kelly's estimation...win-win. Make a trade back, take a WR, OLB, ILB and QB in the first three rounds.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
I agree, according to the draft value chart we'd still should be asking for a little more lol.

If they love Trubisky they could do it...I don't see him lasting until the 10th and I think that goes for both qbs all said and done. Kizer would probably be there but IMO he's not on the same level as the other two.

If we pulled that trade off I wouldn't know who'd be the qb though...at this point I think that has to be priority #1 (would love Myles just don't see him dropping).

The 9ers can't really lose if their choices are Garrett and Trubisky. The only question I would have is whether other QBs are as good as Trubisky? If they can get Falk in the 3rd and he's equal to Trubisky in Kelly's estimation...win-win. Make a trade back, take a WR, OLB, ILB and QB in the first three rounds.

The QB decision should not be Kelly's. I don't expect him to be around come draft time, but even if he somehow survives, we would want a scheme diverse QB, not a Kelly guy

Given the scarcity of QBs and the number of needy teams, Falk won't last to the 3rd round assuming he comes out.
Originally posted by illinois9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Who's gonna be the QB though?

With having the first two picks to open the second round you could have a lot of options there be it moving back to the bottom of the first to get a QB that drops to benefit having the 5th year option, drafting one at #10 like Kizer or Watson or using the acquired 2nd to go after some like Jimmy G

I'm down for Jimmy G just not sure at this pt what NE wants...I want no part of kizer at all. He needs to go to a team that has a vet qb there.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
The 9ers can't really lose if their choices are Garrett and Trubisky. The only question I would have is whether other QBs are as good as Trubisky? If they can get Falk in the 3rd and he's equal to Trubisky in Kelly's estimation...win-win. Make a trade back, take a WR, OLB, ILB and QB in the first three rounds.

I don't think Falk is going into the draft? Mitch IMO would be the way to go but that would be a haul and hard go pass up.
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
The QB decision should not be Kelly's. I don't expect him to be around come draft time, but even if he somehow survives, we would want a scheme diverse QB, not a Kelly guy

Given the scarcity of QBs and the number of needy teams, Falk won't last to the 3rd round assuming he comes out.

I always use the most likely member of the draft team to understand QBs. If not Kelly, then whoever is most likely to be able to evaluate QBs. I would not put it in Baalke's hands because he has shown an aversion to picking offensive skill players. Without knowing who will be HC or GM next year, Kelly is as good a placeholder as any.

Edit: looking at CBS's prospect list Falk would be the sixth best QB if he came out this year. So I'm not sure where he actually stands.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Dec 13, 2016 at 4:01 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Edit: looking at CBS's prospect list Falk would be the sixth best QB if he came out this year. So I'm not sure where he actually stands.

That's a silly list. Falk is the 2nd-best prospect in this draft behind Trubisky.
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
That's a silly list. Falk is the 2nd-best prospect in this draft behind Trubisky.

I don't consider my judgement to be above all the experts...and I don't see many who rate Falk that high.

Edit: Any site have him above the fifth QB on a board?
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Dec 13, 2016 at 7:34 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I don't consider my judgement to be above all the experts.

These sites aren't staffed by football experts. They're staffed by part-time nerds who probably wait tables on the side.

I'm not going to call myself an expert either, but I definitely like what I've seen from Mitch & somewhat like what I've seen from Falk.

I think Falk is at least a rich man's Sam Bradford. If not better.
[ Edited by NinerSickness on Dec 13, 2016 at 9:25 PM ]
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
These sites aren't staffed by football experts. They're staffed by part-time nerds who probably wait tables on the side.

I'm not going to call myself an expert either, but I definitely like what I've seen from Mitch & somewhat like what I've seen from Falk.

I think Falk is at least a rich man's Sam Bradford. If not better.

Well...those part time nerds are probably similar to the more respected draft guys on this site so...
I like Falk but he has not risen up the board. Might he closer to the draft? Sure, it's possible. It's also possible that the QBs will go in the currently projected order--Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Kaaya...etc. If you don't like those guys...OK.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Well...those part time nerds are probably similar to the more respected draft guys on this site so...
I like Falk but he has not risen up the board. Might he closer to the draft? Sure, it's possible. It's also possible that the QBs will go in the currently projected order--Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Kaaya...etc. If you don't like those guys...OK.

1. That proves my point. These guys are just posting an opinion like anyone else.
2. F*** the boards. Don't let people talk you out of seeing what you can see with your own 2 eyes. Falk is about as fundamentally sound as they come. The only things he lacks are arm strength & a sturdy frame. But I think he's better suited for the NFL than Bradford was. That said, he's not a great prospect. Trubisky is the only great prospect in this draft, and Kizer is the wildcard. Watson is ok IMO.
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
1. That proves my point. These guys are just posting an opinion like anyone else.
2. F*** the boards. Don't let people talk you out of seeing what you can see with your own 2 eyes. Falk is about as fundamentally sound as they come. The only things he lacks are arm strength & a sturdy frame. But I think he's better suited for the NFL than Bradford was. That said, he's not a great prospect. Trubisky is the only great prospect in this draft, and Kizer is the wildcard. Watson is ok IMO.

Just as I won't let you influence my opinion. I like Trubisky. Everyone else is way back behind...just my opinion.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Just as I won't let you influence my opinion. I like Trubisky. Everyone else is way back behind...just my opinion.

That's a good stance to take; always check for yourself.

Nonetheless, I think I've had a pretty decent record on QBs on whom I had a strong opinion.

Loved:

Trubisky
Connor Cook
Luck
Stafford
Eli
Pennington

Liked (thought had potential)

Goff
Mariota
Petty
Tannehill
Cutler
Kizer (still up in the air on that one)
Chad Henne
Sanchez
Aaron Rodgers

Hated:

Winston
Wentz
Lynch
Bortles
Bridgewater
Manziel
Geno
RGIII
Cam Newton
Gabbert
Ponder
KAEPERNICK!!!
Bradford
Tebow
Clausen
Josh Freeman
Matt Ryan
Jamarcus Russell
Vince Young
Matt Leinart
Jason Campbell
Joey Harrington

Didn't Watch: Rivers, Roethlisberger
[ Edited by NinerSickness on Dec 13, 2016 at 11:02 PM ]
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NinerSickness:
These sites aren't staffed by football experts. They're staffed by part-time nerds who probably wait tables on the side.

I'm not going to call myself an expert either, but I definitely like what I've seen from Mitch & somewhat like what I've seen from Falk.

I think Falk is at least a rich man's Sam Bradford. If not better.

Well...those part time nerds are probably similar to the more respected draft guys on this site so...
I like Falk but he has not risen up the board. Might he closer to the draft? Sure, it's possible. It's also possible that the QBs will go in the currently projected order--Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Kaaya...etc. If you don't like those guys...OK.

Those site actually aren't very accurate year in and year out. Especially their WR rankings. I don't know who ranks the players on those website but from my knowledge they are always way off come draft day. Falk is clearly a top QB prospect if you watch tape correctly. He doesn't have many weapons. Marks his number 1 target is a number 3 Wr in the NFL at best. Their defense has no NFL talent on it, yet he managed to win them some games they wouldn't have been in if it wasn't for his quick accuracy. They have no run game to throw on top of all of that. He's not fast but he manipulates the pocket very well and handles pressure above average at the college level.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone