There are 849 users in the forums
2017 QB draft class
Dec 14, 2016 at 1:05 AM
- FutureGM
- Member
- Posts: 167
Mason Rudolph is rising.
Dec 14, 2016 at 1:26 AM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
Originally posted by FutureGM:
Those site actually aren't very accurate year in and year out. Especially their WR rankings. I don't know who ranks the players on those website but from my knowledge they are always way off come draft day. Falk is clearly a top QB prospect if you watch tape correctly. He doesn't have many weapons. Marks his number 1 target is a number 3 Wr in the NFL at best. Their defense has no NFL talent on it, yet he managed to win them some games they wouldn't have been in if it wasn't for his quick accuracy. They have no run game to throw on top of all of that. He's not fast but he manipulates the pocket very well and handles pressure above average at the college level.
We have a number of guys on this board who put in the work to inform themselves and I enjoy reading their breakdowns near the draft. Maddog, Jason, and others. I'm not going to criticize guys who spend a great deal more time than I do for their boards and/or sites, or rankings. No one is accurate at this time of year but you can see the players begin to shake out. The as the draft nears QBs will rise and underclassmen will announce giving the boards a bit more reality.
Dec 14, 2016 at 6:15 AM
- DaveWilcox
- Veteran
- Posts: 3,718
Originally posted by FutureGM:Originally posted by dtg_9er:Originally posted by NinerSickness:These sites aren't staffed by football experts. They're staffed by part-time nerds who probably wait tables on the side.
I'm not going to call myself an expert either, but I definitely like what I've seen from Mitch & somewhat like what I've seen from Falk.
I think Falk is at least a rich man's Sam Bradford. If not better.
Well...those part time nerds are probably similar to the more respected draft guys on this site so...
I like Falk but he has not risen up the board. Might he closer to the draft? Sure, it's possible. It's also possible that the QBs will go in the currently projected order--Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Kaaya...etc. If you don't like those guys...OK.
Those site actually aren't very accurate year in and year out. Especially their WR rankings. I don't know who ranks the players on those website but from my knowledge they are always way off come draft day. Falk is clearly a top QB prospect if you watch tape correctly. He doesn't have many weapons. Marks his number 1 target is a number 3 Wr in the NFL at best. Their defense has no NFL talent on it, yet he managed to win them some games they wouldn't have been in if it wasn't for his quick accuracy. They have no run game to throw on top of all of that. He's not fast but he manipulates the pocket very well and handles pressure above average at the college level.
Great points!!
Falk is the primary reason that WSU is relevant.
Put Falk in the right offense, with weapons and he is going be a good NFL QB. Better than anything we have now.
Dec 14, 2016 at 6:32 AM
- NYniner85
- Veteran
- Posts: 119,610
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Great points!!
Falk is the primary reason that WSU is relevant.
Put Falk in the right offense, with weapons and he is going be a good NFL QB. Better than anything we have now.
I just don't see the arm strength required to make the throws in the NFL...his velocity is sub par. I've seen quite a few loose spirals, floaters, and passes that would either get picked off or be incomplete at the next level. I have a issue with Air Raid QBs and how they will be at the next level (not a great track record).
He's accurate and seem pretty calm in the pocket, he has some good qualities....It's not really much of a complement saying he'd be better than anything we have now lol.
Dec 14, 2016 at 7:13 AM
- okdkid
- Veteran
- Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Great points!!
Falk is the primary reason that WSU is relevant.
Put Falk in the right offense, with weapons and he is going be a good NFL QB. Better than anything we have now.
I just don't see the arm strength required to make the throws in the NFL...his velocity is sub par. I've seen quite a few loose spirals, floaters, and passes that would either get picked off or be incomplete at the next level. I have a issue with Air Raid QBs and how they will be at the next level (not a great track record).
He's accurate and seem pretty calm in the pocket, he has some good qualities....It's not really much of a complement saying he'd be better than anything we have now lol.
You're being very nice. By "not a great track record" you mean "it's a complete s**t show".
Also -- there is a reason Falk does not get talked about as the top QB prospect with any regularity. It's because while he looks good against single coverage, he makes complete numbskull reads when the coverage is more complex. Regularly throwing into double and triple coverage. He has a very hard time reading safeties. That is a valid concern and regularly shows up on tape. He has the Carson Palmer gene -- like Jared Goff. Looks great when he has a full field available to him. Looks like crap when the defense makes him think.
The coaching staff at WSU did a great job of putting him in positions to be successful. But that's VERY hard to make happen in the same way at the pro level. He requires a massive projection and is a multi-year project. Simply, there are better, more ready options in this draft.
[ Edited by okdkid on Dec 14, 2016 at 7:15 AM ]
Dec 14, 2016 at 7:19 AM
- NYniner85
- Veteran
- Posts: 119,610
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Great points!!
Falk is the primary reason that WSU is relevant.
Put Falk in the right offense, with weapons and he is going be a good NFL QB. Better than anything we have now.
I just don't see the arm strength required to make the throws in the NFL...his velocity is sub par. I've seen quite a few loose spirals, floaters, and passes that would either get picked off or be incomplete at the next level. I have a issue with Air Raid QBs and how they will be at the next level (not a great track record).
He's accurate and seem pretty calm in the pocket, he has some good qualities....It's not really much of a complement saying he'd be better than anything we have now lol.
You're being very nice. By "not a great track record" you mean "it's a complete s**t show".
Also -- there is a reason Falk does not get talked about as the top QB prospect with any regularity. It's because while he looks good against single coverage, he makes complete numbskull reads when the coverage is more complex. Regularly throwing into double and triple coverage. He has a very hard time reading safeties. That is a valid concern and regularly shows up on tape. He has the Carson Palmer gene -- like Jared Goff. Looks great when he has a full field available to him. Looks like crap when the defense makes him think.
The coaching staff at WSU did a great job of putting him in positions to be successful. But that's VERY hard to make happen in the same way at the pro level. He requires a massive projection and is a multi-year project. Simply, there are better, more ready options in this draft.
yeah I was being nice lol...I agree with most of what you're saying. I don't really see the benefit of him staying in college another year especially running that offense. Like you said he should be on the bench learning in the NFL for a yr or two. We don't have time for that, his best fit would be somewhere like NE
Dec 14, 2016 at 7:27 AM
- okdkid
- Veteran
- Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Great points!!
Falk is the primary reason that WSU is relevant.
Put Falk in the right offense, with weapons and he is going be a good NFL QB. Better than anything we have now.
I just don't see the arm strength required to make the throws in the NFL...his velocity is sub par. I've seen quite a few loose spirals, floaters, and passes that would either get picked off or be incomplete at the next level. I have a issue with Air Raid QBs and how they will be at the next level (not a great track record).
He's accurate and seem pretty calm in the pocket, he has some good qualities....It's not really much of a complement saying he'd be better than anything we have now lol.
You're being very nice. By "not a great track record" you mean "it's a complete s**t show".
Also -- there is a reason Falk does not get talked about as the top QB prospect with any regularity. It's because while he looks good against single coverage, he makes complete numbskull reads when the coverage is more complex. Regularly throwing into double and triple coverage. He has a very hard time reading safeties. That is a valid concern and regularly shows up on tape. He has the Carson Palmer gene -- like Jared Goff. Looks great when he has a full field available to him. Looks like crap when the defense makes him think.
The coaching staff at WSU did a great job of putting him in positions to be successful. But that's VERY hard to make happen in the same way at the pro level. He requires a massive projection and is a multi-year project. Simply, there are better, more ready options in this draft.
yeah I was being nice lol...I agree with most of what you're saying. I don't really see the benefit of him staying in college another year especially running that offense. Like you said he should be on the bench learning in the NFL for a yr or two. We don't have time for that, his best fit would be somewhere like NE
Agree. To be clear -- I think when you look at the QB class as a whole, Falk is a good prospect. My issue is that people are putting him on a tier that simply isn't justified by his play. That's why phrases like "just have a feeling" are used to justify any hype. He kills it in single coverage and the rest is just a complete mystery. The same stuff was used on Goff last year. If it requires burning a 1st round pick on Luke Falk, I'd pass. He becomes a more appetizing risk in round 2.
Dec 14, 2016 at 7:36 AM
- NYniner85
- Veteran
- Posts: 119,610
Originally posted by okdkid:
Agree. To be clear -- I think when you look at the QB class as a whole, Falk is a good prospect. My issue is that people are putting him on a tier that simply isn't justified by his play. That's why phrases like "just have a feeling" are used to justify any hype. He kills it in single coverage and the rest is just a complete mystery. The same stuff was used on Goff last year. If it requires burning a 1st round pick on Luke Falk, I'd pass. He becomes a more appetizing risk in round 2.
and I don't think he'd be a 1st rd pick at all...I wouldn't waste a high 2nd on him either. Much much better players at other positions of need, we aren't getting everything done this yr.
Dec 14, 2016 at 8:33 PM
- Phoenix49ers
- Veteran
- Posts: 132,944
Greg Gabriel @greggabe McShay has no QB's in his top 10 in mid Dec. mock. That will change. Will be at least 2 by Combine mocks
Dec 14, 2016 at 10:26 PM
- NinerSickness
- Member
- Posts: 8,897
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Greg Gabriel @greggabe McShay has no QB's in his top 10 in mid Dec. mock. That will change. Will be at least 2 by Combine mocks
.
Dec 15, 2016 at 8:16 AM
- harryj
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,002
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Greg Gabriel @greggabe McShay has no QB's in his top 10 in mid Dec. mock. That will change. Will be at least 2 by Combine mocks
i dont get it either
browns 49ers bears jets cardinals and texans
all those teams apart from maybe bears cardinals and texans will activly looking for a qb
i think 3 qbs gone in top 20
Dec 15, 2016 at 8:49 AM
- gold49digger
- Veteran
- Posts: 17,882
Originally posted by harryj:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Greg Gabriel @greggabe McShay has no QB's in his top 10 in mid Dec. mock. That will change. Will be at least 2 by Combine mocks
i dont get it either
browns 49ers bears jets cardinals and texans
all those teams apart from maybe bears cardinals and texans will activly looking for a qb
i think 3 qbs gone in top 20
yeah it will only happen if the qb class is terrible, which it really isnt (unlike the geno smith class) and if no teams in the top 10 need a qb.
Dec 15, 2016 at 9:01 AM
- dtg_9er
- Veteran
- Posts: 33,204
CBS has three QBs going in the top fifteen--Trubisky #4, Kizer #9 and Watson at #13. Falk is listed as coming out in 2018, as is Mahomes.
Edit: this seems much more realistic than mocks with no QBs in the top ten. I would also put Falk and Mahomes ahead of Kizer...maybe Watson.
Edit: this seems much more realistic than mocks with no QBs in the top ten. I would also put Falk and Mahomes ahead of Kizer...maybe Watson.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Dec 15, 2016 at 9:05 AM ]
Dec 16, 2016 at 6:23 PM
- Jcool
- Veteran
- Posts: 44,549
Here's a player to remember as we head toward the postseason portion of the evaluation process: Tiffin University (Ohio) QB Antonio Pipkin. The Division II standout earned an invitation to the Reese's Senior Bowl and has Midwest area scouts scrambling for Tiffin game film. He wasn't really on the radar for most NFL teams heading into the season, but he had an outstanding season, and a few scouts started rolling into Tiffin to see what he looked like in person and on tape. He passed the eye test. While undersized, scouts measured him at 6-feet and 5/8 and he weighed 214 pounds. He has a live arm and outstanding mobility. I'm working on getting game tape for myself, but in the meantime, I stumbled upon his junior season highlights on Hudl.
A couple things stood out: 1) He is very sudden and elusive when he decides to take off and run. 2) He has enough arm strength to make every throw.
It's never a good idea to base an evaluation off a 12-minute highlight reel. However, you can eliminate players if they fail to peak your interest after watching their very best plays. That wasn't the case with Pipkin. His highlights left me wanting to know more about him and study his game tape. I'm on an Antonio Pipkin mission! -- Daniel Jeremiah
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000757364/article/move-the-sticks-notes-will-qb-be-worth-no-1-pick-in-2017-draft?campaign=tw-articleshare
Dec 17, 2016 at 4:51 PM
- Judge82Dredd
- Veteran
- Posts: 1,149
I dont think that Falk has a weak arm.
Border line arm by NFL standards is 52 mph.Very few QBs in NFL have an arm below that mark.
Falk might be in 54/55 range!Nothing wrong with that.
Still i agree that he is not a 1st round guy.
Maybe none of the QBs in 2017 are right now...
Border line arm by NFL standards is 52 mph.Very few QBs in NFL have an arm below that mark.
Falk might be in 54/55 range!Nothing wrong with that.
Still i agree that he is not a 1st round guy.
Maybe none of the QBs in 2017 are right now...
