49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 502 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
Could someone please tell me as to why they are against the 49ers drafting Desean Watson? At times, he stares down read #1 but that's part of the offense he runs in college. An offseason with an NFL team will fix that quick. I think drafting him would be the best case scenario for not only the niners, but also Watson himself. Kelly runs a QB friendly system, proven more effective with mobile QB's. Watson would be walking into a dream. Personally, I am all for us drafting this kid. He's achieved everything besides a natty (slight chance this year but nobody will beat Bama) that you could ask for in college. He's won against top talent, great arm, winner + leader, he's a pocket QB FIRST with running escapability (not a running QB first like Kap). He's got the most experience out of all other QB's in this draft class... Am I missing something here?

Good question! I'm not opposed to drafting him but I have other guys I like more--Trubisky, Falk, maybe Mahomes. Not sure my eyes are accurate enough to make the judgement, which is why I'm fine with anyone Kelly picks. He has more interceptions (15) compared to other top QBs (Trubisky and Rudolph--4) which is one of my least favorite QB traits.
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Same thing they said about Vick and R. Wilson.

Yeah and Vick did what in the NFL? Wilson completed 70% off his passes his last yr in college and did played in a pro offense

Here that Mel and mcShay say about Jackson transiting to the NFL

http://insider.espn.com/nfl/draft2017/insider/story/_/id/18236599/how-five-heisman-finalists-project-nfl-prospects-2016
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 9, 2016 at 3:17 PM ]
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Some of his answers:

What is your name? Antonio Pipkin

What is your Height/Weight? 6'3 225lbs

What is your position? QB

Where do you play college football? Tiffin University

Did you play any other sports growing up? Basketball and Baseball

Did you play any other positions in football? No

At your position, what separates you from others? Work ethic in the film room and understanding defenses. Taking pride in being a student of the game

When you are breaking down film, what do you look for? Tendencies, coverage, signals, player body language, who plays hard, defensive effort, etc

If you could compare your play to one player in the NFL who would it be and why? Russell Wilson, he is an athletic guy that takes pride in being a true quarterback and not relying on athletic ability. Leadership skills are above average

What was the biggest obstacle in your life you had to overcome, and how did you overcome it? High school family issue, put my all into my college education and football and trust God's Plan

Do you have any pre-game rituals? Pray

What is your biggest strength? IQ

What is your biggest weakness? Stay vertical when running

If I were a GM and gave you a second to sell yourself, what would you say? Anything that needs to be done will be done and completed the right way, I bust my tail, am a leader, great teammate and competitor

Who was your favorite player and/or NFL team growing up? Peyton Manning, he was just phenomenal as a Colt and hearing of how much he studied the game to be great was amazing

http://www.nfldraftdiamonds.com/antonio-pipkin-qb-tiffin-university/
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Same thing they said about Vick and R. Wilson.

Since when is Vick this tremendous success? Like Kaepernick he had a few good years early on, ran wild on the NFL, then the rest of the league caught up to him, then he went to jail, then he came back and he still couldn't consistently beat teams with his arm and that is why he was never a great QB.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Yeah and Vick did what in the NFL? Wilson completed 70% off his passes his last yr in college and did played in a pro offense

Here that Mel and mcShay say about Jackson transiting to the NFL

http://insider.espn.com/nfl/draft2017/insider/story/_/id/18236599/how-five-heisman-finalists-project-nfl-prospects-2016


Pretty much how I feel about him. He's more athlete than quarterback at this point.


Kiper: Let's get this out of the way: I don't view Jackson as an NFL quarterback prospect at this point. He's an athlete -- a phenomenal one at that -- playing quarterback, but I haven't seen consistent NFL-level passing skills. Jackson has completed only 57.6 percent of his passes this season (54.7 in 2015), and that's a huge red flag for NFL teams. If he can't complete 65 percent of his passes in the ACC, what optimism is there for completing 65 percent of his passes in the NFL?
Still all in on Falk with the 2nd pick.

He had a couple tough games against Colorado and UW, both teams with excellent defenses and secondaries in particular. Both teams with DBs that will be in the NFL.

He looked really good against Colorado and there several balls dropped by his WRs.

Against UW, the lack of weapons hurt. They took away Marks and Falk really didnt have much to throw to.

Falk is still my draft crush
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Still all in on Falk with the 2nd pick.

He had a couple tough games against Colorado and UW, both teams with excellent defenses and secondaries in particular. Both teams with DBs that will be in the NFL.

He looked really good against Colorado and there several balls dropped by his WRs.

Against UW, the lack of weapons hurt. They took away Marks and Falk really didnt have much to throw to.

Falk is still my draft crush

Wait, you mean the #2 pick overall for Falk?
I'm intrigued by Walter Football's recent mock picks for the niners--
  1. Garrett
  2. Smith-Schuster
  3. Mahomes

Not sure about drafting a WR from USC...been there, done that...but have to get over my bias! 6'2" 220 would be a nice addition. Of course, CBS has Smith-Schuster going in the first round so...
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Still all in on Falk with the 2nd pick.

He had a couple tough games against Colorado and UW, both teams with excellent defenses and secondaries in particular. Both teams with DBs that will be in the NFL.

He looked really good against Colorado and there several balls dropped by his WRs.

Against UW, the lack of weapons hurt. They took away Marks and Falk really didnt have much to throw to.

Falk is still my draft crush

You me the number two overall pick??

Falk needs at least a yr to sit and he just doesn't have the velocity to make all the throws in the NFL....If he's sitting there in the 3rd rd sure, but I think he's staying another year in a air raid offense that doesn't do much to prepare you for the NFL.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm intrigued by Walter Football's recent mock picks for the niners--
  1. Garrett
  2. Smith-Schuster
  3. Mahomes
Not sure about drafting a WR from USC...been there, done that...but have to get over my bias! 6'2" 220 would be a nice addition. Of course, CBS has Smith-Schuster going in the first round so...

At his point I don't see Garrett dropping especially with the Browns having possibly two top 10 picks.

Thoughts...say they take Myles (which most likely happens) and they really want Mitch do you trade down to 10 and take both their 2nds and their 3rd?
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Alfienator:
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Still all in on Falk with the 2nd pick.

He had a couple tough games against Colorado and UW, both teams with excellent defenses and secondaries in particular. Both teams with DBs that will be in the NFL.

He looked really good against Colorado and there several balls dropped by his WRs.

Against UW, the lack of weapons hurt. They took away Marks and Falk really didnt have much to throw to.

Falk is still my draft crush

Wait, you mean the #2 pick overall for Falk?

49ers 2nd pick = 2nd round pick. But yes, I'm all in with Luke Falk if he declares which he should IMO. It would be a dream to have and see Luke Falk as a 49er. Too bad the 49ers will go in another direction and probably pick a QB with a laser rocket arm that can run like the wind.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
I'm intrigued by Walter Football's recent mock picks for the niners--
  1. Garrett
  2. Smith-Schuster
  3. Mahomes
Not sure about drafting a WR from USC...been there, done that...but have to get over my bias! 6'2" 220 would be a nice addition. Of course, CBS has Smith-Schuster going in the first round so...

At his point I don't see Garrett dropping especially with the Browns having possibly two top 10 picks.

Thoughts...say they take Myles (which most likely happens) and they really want Mitch do you trade down to 10 and take both their 2nds and their 3rd?

If Cleveland takes Garrett this trade would be a very nice draft haul. Then you'd have to figure whether a QB in the 10th spot would be equal to the QB available at #2. Not sure I see Cleveland making this trade though as they have as many needs as the 9ers do.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Alfienator:
Originally posted by DaveWilcox:
Still all in on Falk with the 2nd pick.

He had a couple tough games against Colorado and UW, both teams with excellent defenses and secondaries in particular. Both teams with DBs that will be in the NFL.

He looked really good against Colorado and there several balls dropped by his WRs.

Against UW, the lack of weapons hurt. They took away Marks and Falk really didnt have much to throw to.

Falk is still my draft crush

Wait, you mean the #2 pick overall for Falk?

49ers 2nd pick = 2nd round pick. But yes, I'm all in with Luke Falk if he declares which he should IMO. It would be a dream to have and see Luke Falk as a 49er. Too bad the 49ers will go in another direction and probably pick a QB with a laser rocket arm that can run like the wind.

Yep, I meant our 2nd rounder.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
At his point I don't see Garrett dropping especially with the Browns having possibly two top 10 picks.

Thoughts...say they take Myles (which most likely happens) and they really want Mitch do you trade down to 10 and take both their 2nds and their 3rd?

Hell yes you do!
Originally posted by illinois9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
At his point I don't see Garrett dropping especially with the Browns having possibly two top 10 picks.

Thoughts...say they take Myles (which most likely happens) and they really want Mitch do you trade down to 10 and take both their 2nds and their 3rd?

Hell yes you do!

Who's gonna be the QB though?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone