49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 497 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
Both Watson and RGIII ran spread offenses.

Both have extreme dificulties in going through progressions and in seeing the field

The plus in Watson is that he does not have the egomaniac personality of RGIII

The next fools gold is Lamar Jackson.

Another scum QB in the making...

What kind of progressions does a QB in a spread offense really go through Dak came from a spread offense and people quoted the same thing about him.

Great question! I believe coaching is all over the place on this and some spread QBs read multiple DBs and some read one, whether based on their ability or the coaches desire for simplicity. You can be a one read WCO QB but it's sure not going to look as good as a great QB.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Read a bleacher report about him going to the senior bowl...really hope SF doesn't get cute go after someone like this as the "answer" at QB

edit: it's the one you quoted lol

Never know. Carson Wentz Senior Bowl performance got him a top half round one projection. Not saying he is a round one talent. But could be an intriguing mid round prospect.

Here is a nice breakdown: http://insidethepylon.com/nfl/2017-nfl-draft/2016/12/08/antonio-pipkin-feel/
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
Both Watson and RGIII ran spread offenses.

Both have extreme dificulties in going through progressions and in seeing the field

The plus in Watson is that he does not have the egomaniac personality of RGIII

The next fools gold is Lamar Jackson.

Another scum QB in the making...

What kind of progressions does a QB in a spread offense really go through Dak came from a spread offense and people quoted the same thing about him.

Great question! I believe coaching is all over the place on this and some spread QBs read multiple DBs and some read one, whether based on their ability or the coaches desire for simplicity. You can be a one read WCO QB but it's sure not going to look as good as a great QB.

Right...I mean a QB can only play in the system provided to him.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
Both Watson and RGIII ran spread offenses.

Both have extreme dificulties in going through progressions and in seeing the field

The plus in Watson is that he does not have the egomaniac personality of RGIII

The next fools gold is Lamar Jackson.

Another scum QB in the making...

What kind of progressions does a QB in a spread offense really go through Dak came from a spread offense and people quoted the same thing about him.

Great question! I believe coaching is all over the place on this and some spread QBs read multiple DBs and some read one, whether based on their ability or the coaches desire for simplicity. You can be a one read WCO QB but it's sure not going to look as good as a great QB.

Right...I mean a QB can only play in the system provided to him.


I would take Lamar Jackson in a heart beat! He is the most productive college QB of all time!

He can run, throw, and he is a leader!
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by Judge82Dredd:
Both Watson and RGIII ran spread offenses.

Both have extreme dificulties in going through progressions and in seeing the field

The plus in Watson is that he does not have the egomaniac personality of RGIII

The next fools gold is Lamar Jackson.

Another scum QB in the making...

What kind of progressions does a QB in a spread offense really go through Dak came from a spread offense and people quoted the same thing about him.

Great question! I believe coaching is all over the place on this and some spread QBs read multiple DBs and some read one, whether based on their ability or the coaches desire for simplicity. You can be a one read WCO QB but it's sure not going to look as good as a great QB.

Right...I mean a QB can only play in the system provided to him.


I would take Lamar Jackson in a heart beat! He is the most productive college QB of all time!

He can run, throw, and he is a leader!

i would perfer rosen only because he is going to come in nfl ready

but jackson has so much upside and is smart - he does need a good qb coach though and kelly can be that guy
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Read a bleacher report about him going to the senior bowl...really hope SF doesn't get cute go after someone like this as the "answer" at QB

edit: it's the one you quoted lol

Never know. Carson Wentz Senior Bowl performance got him a top half round one projection. Not saying he is a round one talent. But could be an intriguing mid round prospect.

Here is a nice breakdown: http://insidethepylon.com/nfl/2017-nfl-draft/2016/12/08/antonio-pipkin-feel/

yeah I know nothing about him so I can't say anything good or bad lol. Wentz was looked at as a 2nd round pick before the Senior bowl IMO I'm all for drafting two QBs if we can.

One in the early rounds and one later (maybe this kid ) Cooper Rush, Nathan Peterman, and Brady Gustafson are guys to check out late in the draft as well (as a backup developmental guy).
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I would take Lamar Jackson in a heart beat! He is the most productive college QB of all time!

He can run, throw, and he is a leader!

He can throw dude completed like 57% of his passes in a easy spread offense. IF people are complaining about Watson then this guy shouldn't even be talked about. He's 200 lbs soaking wet and can't throw the ball anywhere close to the level of Watson or Turbisky

FYI you know who was one of the most productive college QBs before him Tim Tebow
[ Edited by NYniner85 on Dec 9, 2016 at 1:51 PM ]
  • 9moon
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 22,400
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I would take Lamar Jackson in a heart beat! He is the most productive college QB of all time!

He can run, throw, and he is a leader!

He can throw dude completed like 57% of his passes in a easy spread offense. IF people are complaining about Watson then this guy shouldn't even be talked about. He's 200 lbs soaking wet and can't throw the ball anywhere close to the level of Watson or Turbisky
Even if Lamar can do all those, he would be more expensive than VINCE YOUNG !!

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
I would take Lamar Jackson in a heart beat! He is the most productive college QB of all time!

He can run, throw, and he is a leader!

He can throw dude completed like 57% of his passes in a easy spread offense. IF people are complaining about Watson then this guy shouldn't even be talked about. He's 200 lbs soaking wet and can't throw the ball anywhere close to the level of Watson or Turbisky

He threw for 3390 yards with 30 TD's and ran for 21 more THIS YEAR! The name of the game is to get the ball in the end-zone, and there is no one better at doing that than LJ. I don care if he completed 12% of his passes, with numbers like that the kid is great!
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by NYniner85:
yeah I know nothing about him so I can't say anything good or bad lol. Wentz was looked at as a 2nd round pick before the Senior bowl IMO I'm all for drafting two QBs if we can.

One in the early rounds and one later (maybe this kid ) Cooper Rush, Nathan Peterman, and Brady Gustafson are guys to check out late in the draft as well (as a backup developmental guy).

Yeah because the hype train started earlier on Wentz. I mean his page got created here on Sep 30th (2015). Who knows if he will be able to do anything at the Senior Bowl & like you i just heard of him today. But i like that he has all the physical attributes needed to play QB in the NFL, has 1105 career passing attempts, played in 44 consecutive games (41 straight starts) & got his team to the first winning season in the GLIAC since they joined in 2007.
[ Edited by Jcool on Dec 9, 2016 at 2:05 PM ]
Could someone please tell me as to why they are against the 49ers drafting Desean Watson? At times, he stares down read #1 but that's part of the offense he runs in college. An offseason with an NFL team will fix that quick. I think drafting him would be the best case scenario for not only the niners, but also Watson himself. Kelly runs a QB friendly system, proven more effective with mobile QB's. Watson would be walking into a dream. Personally, I am all for us drafting this kid. He's achieved everything besides a natty (slight chance this year but nobody will beat Bama) that you could ask for in college. He's won against top talent, great arm, winner + leader, he's a pocket QB FIRST with running escapability (not a running QB first like Kap). He's got the most experience out of all other QB's in this draft class... Am I missing something here?
Originally posted by glorydayz:
He threw for 3390 yards with 30 TD's and ran for 21 more THIS YEAR! The name of the game is to get the ball in the end-zone, and there is no one better at doing that than LJ. I don care if he completed 12% of his passes, with numbers like that the kid is great!

The way he plays football will not translate to the NFL never has...no team in the NFL run a offense like that at Louisville, dude will get killed if he thinks he can run around like that lol.

coaches care if he has a problem completing passes lol, if your gonna run a easy offense like they do with simple reads and players in space you'd better be competing AT LEAST 60% and he hasn't and didn't last yr either.

He's got a whole yr to improve on that, but if he can't show people he can't actually throw the football inside the pocket, he'd bette bulk up to be a RB or learn to run routes like Terrel Pryor did.
Originally posted by mv49erfan:
Could someone please tell me as to why they are against the 49ers drafting Desean Watson? At times, he stares down read #1 but that's part of the offense he runs in college. An offseason with an NFL team will fix that quick. I think drafting him would be the best case scenario for not only the niners, but also Watson himself. Kelly runs a QB friendly system, proven more effective with mobile QB's. Watson would be walking into a dream. Personally, I am all for us drafting this kid. He's achieved everything besides a natty (slight chance this year but nobody will beat Bama) that you could ask for in college. He's won against top talent, great arm, winner + leader, he's a pocket QB FIRST with running escapability (not a running QB first like Kap). He's got the most experience out of all other QB's in this draft class... Am I missing something here?

I agree I do like Trubisky game a little more but I wouldn't have a problem with getting Watson at all...
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by glorydayz:
He threw for 3390 yards with 30 TD's and ran for 21 more THIS YEAR! The name of the game is to get the ball in the end-zone, and there is no one better at doing that than LJ. I don care if he completed 12% of his passes, with numbers like that the kid is great!

The way he plays football will not translate to the NFL never has...no team in the NFL run a offense like that at Louisville, dude will get killed if he thinks he can run around like that lol.

coaches care if he has a problem completing passes lol, if your gonna run a easy offense like they do with simple reads and players in space you'd better be competing AT LEAST 60% and he hasn't and didn't last yr either.

He's got a whole yr to improve on that, but if he can't show people he can't actually throw the football inside the pocket, he'd bette bulk up to be a RB or learn to run routes like Terrel Pryor did.

Same thing they said about Vick and R. Wilson.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by glorydayz:
Same thing they said about Vick and R. Wilson.

Vick's game never translated to the NFL that well. Was he exciting? For a few seasons. Did that lead to wins? Not really. He only won 10+ games as a starter once (2004). Wilson's only issue was height. As a senior he completed 72% of his passes and had 33 TDs. He ran less then 80 times that year.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone