Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 356 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:
I'm not completely sold on any of the QB's, but it would be nice for our front office to have their pick of QB's if that's the direction they decide to go. Don't sleep on picking earlier in every subsequent round even if we end up with a solid player in the first round - picking #2 overall could net us a good QB with our 2nd round pick or make it easier to trade back up into the first.

Yep, like a Mack/Carr scenario. Laid some major groundwork for the Raiders success. Getting Gabe Jackson in round 3 was the cherry on top.
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
People are all hoping we lose out to ensure we get one of the top QBs. The only thing losing out gets us is a chance at Myles Garrett. Outside of that, we can win 4 games and still have a shot at a top QB. The 4 best players in this draft are Garrett, Fournette, Allen and Peppers. That means we can realistically drop to 5 and STILL get a QB or one of the top 4 players in this draft. We nor our GM will be able to mess this up unless we win out and that ain't happening. We will add one of the following players:

Garrett
Fournette
Allen
Peppers
Trubisky
Watson
Kizer

I'll take any of them

No Reuben Foster on this list?
I see 3-4 future starters from this class. I know it sounds ridiculous when you look at the list of players, because nobody looks like a sure thing. However, there are a really big number of physically talented QBs from this list, which have some NFL qualities to them. The question, however, is who will emerge as the best of this group? Just like this year, you might end up hitting on a guy in the middle rounds who is better than a first rounder.
MD, or anyone else, what are your thoughts on Baker Mayfield? Super accurate, but small. Has he got the goods? No one really talks about him much, but 70% accuracy and almost 11 yards per attempt are a good combination.
Originally posted by Murphys1:
MD, or anyone else, what are your thoughts on Baker Mayfield? Super accurate, but small. Has he got the goods? No one really talks about him much, but 70% accuracy and almost 11 yards per attempt are a good combination.


Backyard football type. Don't see him having much success in the NFL where teams will force him to play from the pocket. I wouldnt be mad if the 49ers usee a later pick on him as the 2nd QB they choose. He has a lot of confidence and is a true playmaker but his freewheeling style of play will get him into trouble in the NFL.


Russell Wilson gets away with it because Wilson is a freak in every sense. Mayfield is nowhere near that level.
Right now it looks possible that the Bears or Jets would trade up for Watson or another QB especially it Garrett comes off #1
Nobody outside of Trubisky really excites me, and I do not want any part of Watson or Kizer in the first 3 rounds. I don't know enough about Mahomes or Falk to have an opinion, but Falks numbers look good.
Originally posted by LondonNiner:
Nobody outside of Trubisky really excites me, and I do not want any part of Watson or Kizer in the first 3 rounds. I don't know enough about Mahomes or Falk to have an opinion, but Falks numbers look good.

What you hate about Watson?
Originally posted by NYniner85:
What you hate about Watson?

1) I keep reading that he does not go through his progressions, this is all we heard during Kaepernicks fall from favor and that doesn't seem to be something that is an easy fix.

2) People have suggested he has accuracy issues and his completing % is respectable because of the amount of screens the Clemson offense runs.

3) Plays with the best WR in College football, not so much a knock on Watson, but it makes you wonder...

4) Slight build and has a history of injuries, broken hand, missed some time with a knee sprain and then tore his ACL.
From what I've seen I like Kizer, Watson, Trubisky, and Falk in no particular order. Ideally we don't pick any of them at #2 but if we don't have a QB going into the draft then we will be reaching for one on draft day.
Originally posted by LondonNiner:
Originally posted by NYniner85:
What you hate about Watson?

1) I keep reading that he does not go through his progressions, this is all we heard during Kaepernicks fall from favor and that doesn't seem to be something that is an easy fix.

2) People have suggested he has accuracy issues and his completing % is respectable because of the amount of screens the Clemson offense runs.

3) Plays with the best WR in College football, not so much a knock on Watson, but it makes you wonder...

4) Slight build and has a history of injuries, broken hand, missed some time with a knee sprain and then tore his ACL.

1-from what you read?....do you watch him play at all? He most certainly does go through progressions and he does what that offense scheme asks him to do (there aren't a ton of progressions to begin with).

2- Once again watch him play instead of relying on what everyone says look at what our current offense runs and what he does...it's near identical. He's avg 8 YPA which indicates it's more than screens.

3-He played without Williams all last yr and threw for 4,000+ yards and 35TDs

4-He's 6-3 and it's been reported he's over 220lbs now...He's broke his finger back in 2014 same with the ACL.

Yeah he hasn't played near identical to last yr but those numbers are crazy....end of the day he finds ways to win.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
1-from what you read?....do you watch him play at all? He most certainly does go through progressions and he does what that offense scheme asks him to do (there aren't a ton of progressions to begin with).

2- Once again watch him play instead of relying on what everyone says look at what our current offense runs and what he does...it's near identical. He's avg 8 YPA which indicates it's more than screens.

3-He played without Williams all last yr and threw for 4,000+ yards and 35TDs

4-He's 6-3 and it's been reported he's over 220lbs now...He's broke his finger back in 2014 same with the ACL.

Yeah he hasn't played near identical to last yr but those numbers are crazy....end of the day he finds ways to win.

I think I've managed to watch maybe 5-6 Clemson games in the last 2 years, so your obviously in a much better position to judge. Coverage of College football over here is terrible.
Ian Wharton ‏@NFLFilmStudy Nov 15 Bombshell from @LanceZierlein- he hasn't heard one NFL person who thinks Deshaun Watson goes in the first-round this spring.

Originally posted by LondonNiner:
I think I've managed to watch maybe 5-6 Clemson games in the last 2 years, so your obviously in a much better position to judge. Coverage of College football over here is terrible.

Word...from what I've seen Watson can make all he throws and has put on the lbs this season.

Last yr he was playing on a whole other level and yes the offensive system is part of it...I'd have no problem having this kid be our FQB.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Ian Wharton ‏@NFLFilmStudy Nov 15 Bombshell from @LanceZierlein- he hasn't heard one NFL person who thinks Deshaun Watson goes in the first-round this spring.

Could be just smokescreen, but then again I've never believed the hype either.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone