49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 799 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by Prometheus2001:
In my opinion, Chad Kelly is the most gifted QB in this class and from an on-field attribute perspective, he is a top-10 pick. He would be a very good fit for Chip's offense. He is tough as nails, has enough athleticism to run the read option, but most importantly, is a pass-first, pocket passer, who can attach all levels of the field with touch and arm strength. He is comfortable throwing to covered receivers and he progresses through his reads quite naturally. The question is whether teams are comfortable with him off the field and whether he has matured. I would love to grab Garrett with our first pick and to trade back into round 1 for Chad Kelly.

As for the flavor of the month, Trubinsky, he looks like a very nice player. However, with so few starts and having faced little adversity, i would have a hard time investing a high first-round pick in a guy with just good tools, who I don't see make a lot of NFL throws on a per-game basis. That's not to say, he doesn't have good enough arm strength and accuracy, I just have no idea how he operates in a muddled pocket and a lot of his completions in the intermediate to deep range are to wide open receivers. I would need to see another year from him before investing a high 1st round pick. People compare him to Wentz and Cam Newton who had few starts in college, but those guys had top-10 physical tools. Trubinsky does not.

Can Chad Kelly be trusted, especially if you take him in the 1st or 2nd round?? Will his emotions get the best of him if teams play dirty (cause they will). Kelly has been in trouble not once, but three times, his attitude stinks and if I were a NFL GM I wouldn't take him till the 4th round.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by Prometheus2001:
In my opinion, Chad Kelly is the most gifted QB in this class and from an on-field attribute perspective, he is a top-10 pick. He would be a very good fit for Chip's offense. He is tough as nails, has enough athleticism to run the read option, but most importantly, is a pass-first, pocket passer, who can attach all levels of the field with touch and arm strength. He is comfortable throwing to covered receivers and he progresses through his reads quite naturally. The question is whether teams are comfortable with him off the field and whether he has matured. I would love to grab Garrett with our first pick and to trade back into round 1 for Chad Kelly.

As for the flavor of the month, Trubinsky, he looks like a very nice player. However, with so few starts and having faced little adversity, i would have a hard time investing a high first-round pick in a guy with just good tools, who I don't see make a lot of NFL throws on a per-game basis. That's not to say, he doesn't have good enough arm strength and accuracy, I just have no idea how he operates in a muddled pocket and a lot of his completions in the intermediate to deep range are to wide open receivers. I would need to see another year from him before investing a high 1st round pick. People compare him to Wentz and Cam Newton who had few starts in college, but those guys had top-10 physical tools. Trubinsky does not.

Can Chad Kelly be trusted, especially if you take him in the 1st or 2nd round?? Will his emotions get the best of him if teams play dirty (cause they will). Kelly has been in trouble not once, but three times, his attitude stinks and if I were a NFL GM I wouldn't take him till the 4th round.

This. Kelly is great, but the risk is too high. I actually wouldn't mind if the 49ers took two QBs, similar yo the Redskins in 2012. We need a long term starter and a backup.
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
This. Kelly is great, but the risk is too high. I actually wouldn't mind if the 49ers took two QBs, similar yo the Redskins in 2012. We need a long term starter and a backup.

Is Kelly great? Seems way to Jay Cutler on the field, for me to think he is a long term answer at QB.
Chad Kelly screams bad idea to me. How many of the top QBs have that douche swagger?

Rivers may be the only guy kind of like that and he never actually had any issues off the field or with his temper.

There's a difference in passion for the game and being a hot head off the field.
  • Tman
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,801
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
This. Kelly is great, but the risk is too high. I actually wouldn't mind if the 49ers took two QBs, similar yo the Redskins in 2012. We need a long term starter and a backup.

Is Kelly great? Seems way to Jay Cutler on the field, for me to think he is a long term answer at QB.

Yea I can see that Cutler comparison

Now if we drafted him super late cause he fell due to off the field, like 5th round or so, i would be all for it. Could bring some good competition with the qb we get early.
Originally posted by genus49:
Chad Kelly screams bad idea to me. How many of the top QBs have that douche swagger?

Rivers may be the only guy kind of like that and he never actually had any issues off the field or with his temper.

There's a difference in passion for the game and being a hot head off the field.



"Can a team trust you to stay out of trouble?"


Chad Kelly:"I think so"


Kizer and Kaaya on today at 3:30
Kizer
Watson
Trubisky
Falk


Talk about options! I'd be happy with any of these guys. Mahomes is a maybe.
Originally posted by ninerAxe:
Kizer
Watson
Trubisky
Falk


Talk about options! I'd be happy with any of these guys. Mahomes is a maybe.

sounds exciting….odds are all but 1-2 will be busts
Originally posted by jreff22:
Kizer and Kaaya on today at 3:30

So far in 1st quarter the QB's are engaged in a pick a thon ... i should be nicer than that, the accuracy is not the best
[ Edited by ChaunceyGardner on Oct 29, 2016 at 1:19 PM ]
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
So far in 1st quarter the QB's are engaged in a pick a thon ... i should be nicer than that, the accuracy is not the best

what are you talking about kizer has 2 Tds
Originally posted by harryj:
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
So far in 1st quarter the QB's are engaged in a pick a thon ... i should be nicer than that, the accuracy is not the best

what are you talking about kizer has 2 Tds

1 sided pick-a-thon. Kizer looks good so far. Feel bad for Kaaya - Miami is trying to establish the run but getting nothing so they're stuck in 3rd and long every series.
Kizer does look better than Kaaya for sure.
Originally posted by ChaunceyGardner:
Kizer does look better than Kaaya for sure.

Not even comparable. Kaaya goes down if someone blows on him in the pocket, has no mobility, and doesn't have a ton of arm strength. Kizer was strong enough to throw it if someone was open while wrapped up by a linebacker. Took like 4 seconds for the linebacker to wrestle him to the ground.

6'4.5 235 and athletic vs. 6'3 210 and an awful athlete. Kizer had been pretty accurate this game too. Kaaya won't have any success in the NFL unless he goes to a team with a good offensive line.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone