-
Phoenix49ers
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 132,944
Originally posted by jersey49er:
What round do you think Mahomes will go in..?
Anywhere from the late 1st to the mid 3rd IMO.
-
LifelongNiner
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 25,012
What is the difference between the top tier QBs (guys expected to go top 10) the next tier (11 - 32), and the guys that will go in the 2nd round?
-
Sims19849ers
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 5,419
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
What is the difference between the top tier QBs (guys expected to go top 10) the next tier (11 - 32), and the guys that will go in the 2nd round?
Not much, if anything at all. Talent wise, there isn't much of a difference between any of the projected first rounders and guys like Kelly and Falk.
-
Mertonschickendance
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 4,492
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
What is the difference between the top tier QBs (guys expected to go top 10) the next tier (11 - 32), and the guys that will go in the 2nd round?
Not much, if anything at all. Talent wise, there isn't much of a difference between any of the projected first rounders and guys like Kelly and Falk.
If that's the case should take a QB w/ their second pick (even if that means moving back into first round) while getting a bonafied defensive player w/ their top 3 week…hopefully its not that safety from Michigan (we need pass rushers/ILB)
-
mayo49
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 65,216
Bad year to be looking for a franchise Qb.
-
dj43
- Moderator
-
- Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by cjsmoove:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
I just need Trubisky to fall to the mid teams. We take Myles Garrett at #2 and then trade our 2nd and 3rd into the teens to get Trubisky. That alone makes my draft. Anyone after that is a bonus.
This would be nice.... Get a NT n WR via FA
Only trouble with that is the price will be very high to convince any decent player to come here. They will be looking only at the promise that a couple of good rookies will turn up. If I were Alshon Jeffrey I wouldn't come here for $20million/yr. He will be faced with waiting for a rookie to develop or dealing with Ponder as QB.
-
Knowledge
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 14,709
Originally posted by mayo49:
Bad year to be looking for a franchise Qb.
So was last year and then Wentz and Dak emerged. You'll never know until they play in the NFL
-
DonnieDarko
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 67,094
Originally posted by Knowledge:
Originally posted by mayo49:
Bad year to be looking for a franchise Qb.
So was last year and then Wentz and Dak emerged. You'll never know until they play in the NFL
add
derek carr 2nd round in 2014
russell wilson 3rd round in 2012
-
D0PEMAN
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 5,132
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Originally posted by Knowledge:
Originally posted by mayo49:
Bad year to be looking for a franchise Qb.
So was last year and then Wentz and Dak emerged. You'll never know until they play in the NFL
add
derek carr 2nd round in 2014
russell wilson 3rd round in 2012
Won't matter for us as long as Trent is making the picks.
-
frankieuc68
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 6,022
Originally posted by Sims19849ers:
Originally posted by LifelongNiner:
What is the difference between the top tier QBs (guys expected to go top 10) the next tier (11 - 32), and the guys that will go in the 2nd round?
Not much, if anything at all. Talent wise, there isn't much of a difference between any of the projected first rounders and guys like Kelly and Falk.
I agree. If the QB group is fairly close I would also like the highest rated defensive player if Garrett is gone and take a QB in the second. I also wouldn't mind trading down if there is a team that really loves a specific player and get a bounty of picks like the Browns had this past draft. Let's say we get a couple of mid/late first round picks and extra picks. If we come away with highest rated defensive player(OLB), QB Falk, WR Core Davis in the first 2 rounds, TE in the third,ILB in the fourth. Sign DE Kawan Short, WR Kendal Wright, QB Foles(bridge), LB,NT thru free agency....
I know i know so many what ifs and games to be played still. I just want our team to be a playoff contender. These last 2 seasons..
[ Edited by frankieuc68 on Nov 1, 2016 at 12:14 AM ]
-
Jcool
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 44,549
Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
Won't matter for us as long as Trent is making the picks. 
Last QB Baalke wanted... Andy Dalton.
-
LondonNiner
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 216
I think is a really good year to be picking a QB in the early rounds (2nd-3rd), the talent of the top 4-5 prospects is reasonably similar, and there just aren't that many teams that need a QB desperately other than us.
Browns (Proven they can't draft a QB to save their lives)
Jets (1 first round QB pick in the last 15 years; Mark Sanchez).
Texans
Bears
They are not all drafting a QB in round 1, so some of the top guys will fall quite far. Teams like the Giants, Cardinals and Dolphins I don't expect to see take a QB for the future in round 1 either.
-
SunDevilNiner79
- Hall of Fame
-
- Posts: 61,802
Alright, finished reviewing and ranking about 25 QBs. How I have them broken down right now:
Top 10 Pick Worthy
None as of now
First Round
1. Patrick Mahomes*, Texas Tech - The physical tools a GM dreams of
2. Deshaun Watson*, Clemson - A ton of things to like but one red flag to scare you, hasn't shown the ability to go through progressions or read defensive coverage.
3. Mitch Tribusky*, North Carolina - A well rounded prospect that does many things well, but nothing great. Needs to clean up his mechanics.
Second-Third Round
4. Luke Falk*, Wash St - It would not be a surprise if he finds his way into the 1st. His best strength is has ability to make a wide variety of throws. Biggest concern is the offensive system he comes from.
5. Greg Ward Jr., Houston - Note: I didn't see his last game. Biggest concern is he is very undersized and raw. But he may have the best deep ball throw in the draft. I see him as a late 3rd or early 4th round pick
Fourth-Fifth Round
6. Baker Mayfield*, Oklahoma - Love the arm and accuracy, hate the release and feet.
7. Davis Webb, Cal - Good arm and accuracy, from an air raid offense. A rhythm QB that is fortunate that Hanson has made some Sports Center grabs.
6th-7th Round
8. Chad Kelly, Ole Miss - Probably a good chance he ends up in the 5th. But when watching him play it really amazing he doesn't have 15 picks on the year. The WR group in Ole Miss is impressive and won a lot of contested throws.
8. J.T. Barrett*, Ohio State - Needs to clean up his mechanics and improve accuracy on mid-range throws, but a lot to keep an eye on. Should stay another year.
9. DeShone Kizer*, Notre Dame - Most puzzling love for any QB prospect. He has ideal size and a great arm. But his ball placement and decision making are scary bad. I can certainly understand him getting benched. Should stay another year as he has the tools to shoot up the draft board.
10. Brad Kaaya*, Miami - Another prospect I'm a bit puzzled by people liking. The only positives I have is he takes snaps under center, is tall, and a quick decision maker. He is also 75lbs and one hit from dying, and rarely makes an NFL quality throw.
11. Nathan Peterman, Pittsburgh - Quick release, strong arm, great ball placement. But its hard to really judge him in the offense he is in. He looks to me like an ideal game manager at the next level.
UDFA Waivers to keep in mind: Logan Woodside, Toledo. Ryan Higgins, LA Tech. Zach Terrell, Western Michigan.
To be reviewed: Cooper Rush, Central Michigan. C.J. Beathard, Iowa. Seth Russell, Baylor.