Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 699 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.
  • okdkid
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,729
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.

This seems... premature.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.

This seems... premature.

Of course it is, well where Luke Falk is projected at anyway, Garrett at worse should be a top 3 pick unless a video of him hitting a bong surfaces.

But of course this could change if Falk doesn't declare.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by okdkid:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.

This seems... premature.

Of course it is, well where Luke Falk is projected at anyway, Garrett at worse should be a top 3 pick unless a video of him hitting a bong surfaces.

But of course this could change if Falk doesn't declare.

I wouldn't mind Falk. He may well end up like KC Alex Smith.

Currently, my favorites are Kelly and Falk.
Would love to see us take a QB in the first couple rounds and trade for a QB like Garapolo.

Long shot of happening I know, but we gotta fix this problem quick. First step is firing Baalke. I don't want him drafting our next QB.
  • TheNef77
  • Q46 Draft 3rd place
  • Posts: 1,489
Originally posted by DonnieDarko:
Would love to see us take a QB in the first couple rounds and trade for a QB like Garapolo.

Long shot of happening I know, but we gotta fix this problem quick. First step is firing Baalke. I don't want him drafting our next QB.

Please no. OCs and QBs from the Belichick system only work in the Belichick system. They've all struggled when they left. Cassel, Mallett, Wiess, Mangini, etc..
Originally posted by TheNef77:
Please no. OCs and QBs from the Belichick system only work in the Belichick system. They've all struggled when they left. Cassel, Mallett, Wiess, Mangini, etc..

Mallett sucked in NE too. Realistically you are resting your entire argument on Matt Cassel who was a 7th round pick that never started in college.


It could be argued that the coaching Cassel received made him a far better QB than he would have been otherwise. A 7th round pick a decade ago and still in the NFL.
  • TheNef77
  • Q46 Draft 3rd place
  • Posts: 1,489
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by TheNef77:
Please no. OCs and QBs from the Belichick system only work in the Belichick system. They've all struggled when they left. Cassel, Mallett, Wiess, Mangini, etc..

Mallett sucked in NE too. Realistically you are resting your entire argument on Matt Cassel who was a 7th round pick that never started in college.


It could be argued that the coaching Cassel received made him a far better QB than he would have been otherwise. A 7th round pick a decade ago and still in the NFL.

7th round pick or not, 11-5 as a belichick qb. The Belichick Offense is a collective scouting effort led by him. He gameplans heavily on the weakness of his opponents instead of applying his own strengths. Take Belichick out of the equation and you have lost OCs and QBs.

It's not like he created a singular offensive scheme that works on everyone. You just have OCs and QBs that can only feed off of a main source of info.
Aside from Watson and Kizer, there are a few 2nd-day options I like in this class.

Pat Mahomes, Texas Tech
J.T. Barrett, Ohio State
Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State
Luke Falk, Washington State

For a deep sleeper, I'll throw out Brady Gustafson from Montana. Kid is 6'7" and has some arm talent. I watched him beat Carson Wentz and NDSU in the 2015 opener and came away really impressed with his touch and placement. He made some big-time throws late in that game.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bcHpziyzQY
[ Edited by JamesGatz83 on Oct 17, 2016 at 3:28 PM ]
Originally posted by TheNef77:
7th round pick or not, 11-5 as a belichick qb.

Having Randy Moss, Wes Welker and more to throw to certainly didn't hurt. You're resting your argument on the notion that Cassel and Garoppolo are exactly the same, that because Cassel was successful but struggled elsewhere outside of one really good year in KC, that Garoppolo is bound to suffer the same fate and I just don't buy that whatsoever.

Garoppolo was a far, far better prospect than Cassel coming out in the draft. Playing in New England has certainly helped him out but I don't buy that his skills are all a result of the system. I think he's got the tools to play in pretty much any offense and has the prerequisite accuracy and quick decision-making to work out well in a Chip Kelly offense in particular.
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Aside from Watson and Kizer, there are a few 2nd-day options I like in this class.

Pat Mahomes, Texas Tech
J.T. Barrett, Ohio State
Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma State
Luke Falk, Washington State

For a deep sleeper, I'll throw out Brady Gustafson from Montana. Kid is 6'7" and has some arm talent. I watched him beat Carson Wentz and NDSU in the 2015 opener and came away really impressed with his touch and placement. He made some big-time throws late in that game.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-bcHpziyzQY

Seems to over throw a ton of balls. Big wind-up. Has a little bit of Kap syndrome., fires in short passes far too hard. Did make some real nice throws though.
[ Edited by WINiner on Oct 17, 2016 at 4:39 PM ]
Qb rankings through 7 weeks

https://www.profootballfocus.com/college-top-10-qbs-in-college-football-through-week-7/
Lol Watson goes 39-52 for 378 yards and 2 TDs and 39 yards rushing for 1 TD and they drop him a spot for Baker Mayfield who crumbles every time he plays a team with a pulse.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.

I second this.
Has anybody heard whether Trubisky is likely to declare? My guess is no considering his lack of college starts, but if he keeps playing like he has, he might be a 1st round pick.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone