49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 767 users in the forums

2017 QB draft class

Browse 49ers books and videos
Originally posted by jb49ers80:
Has anybody heard whether Trubisky is likely to declare? My guess is no considering his lack of college starts, but if he keeps playing like he has, he might be a 1st round pick.

I think he does. If he keeps up his level of play he becomes a first rounder and there's no way he passes on that. He will lose some of his top receivers in Switzer, Bug Howard, and Mack Collins if he stays and that could really affect his numbers
Originally posted by saniner:
I think he does. If he keeps up his level of play he becomes a first rounder and there's no way he passes on that. He will lose some of his top receivers in Switzer, Bug Howard, and Mack Collins if he stays and that could really affect his numbers

Yeah, and I just saw in his thread that he should finish this year with more passing attempts than Wentz had coming out.
Greg Ward Jr. is only 5'11, but I'm pretty high on him as a mid-round prospect.

His deep ball touch and accuracy is extremely good. His stats would be a whole lot better if he had a better group of WRs. He should get invited to the Senior Bowl.
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Greg Ward Jr. is only 5'11, but I'm pretty high on him as a mid-round prospect.

His deep ball touch and accuracy is extremely good. His stats would be a whole lot better if he had a better group of WRs. He should get invited to the Senior Bowl.

How did Luke Falk play against your Arizona State?
Me too..
Originally posted by Kolohe:
I've made up my mind and will stand by my pick, and Luke Falk is my top choice. The kid just continues to impress me and stay poised, he's very coachable and I should transition well to the NFL.

Myles Garrett in the 1st, trade back up into the 1st round or take Falk in the 2nd if he's there too.

Me too. Like I said last year, that Falk is just one of those players that makes everyone around him better. He, not McCaffery should have been the PAC 12 player of the year. WSU was 8-4, (should have been 9-3) last season and would have been 4-8 without him. Falk walked on and instantly made the Cougs good. Without Falk, the Cougs are irrelevant.

I also know from reliable sources in Pullman that Falk is just a great kid, everyone loves Luke. He is also known as the CEO of WSU football by his teammates

My concern is that some other QB desperate team will grab him before our 2nd rounder. QBs are way over valued. If the new GM wants both Garrett and Falk he will need to be prepared to trade up.

Go Cougs
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Greg Ward Jr. is only 5'11, but I'm pretty high on him as a mid-round prospect.

His deep ball touch and accuracy is extremely good. His stats would be a whole lot better if he had a better group of WRs. He should get invited to the Senior Bowl.

How did Luke Falk play against your Arizona State?

Not that impressive TBPH. He wasn't able to score a TD until the end of the 2nd half. Against ASU's D, that's pretty bad!

I know people will look at the stat line and say he threw for 390 and scratch their heads, but keep in mind a lower division school, NAU, threw for 370 against us. Webb threw for 480, Mahomes threw for 540. Add in the fact our defense is much worse at the moment with multiple injuries.

He threw a pretty TD pass to Gabe Marks thought with the game on the line.

I think Falk is a good QB and good prospect. Is he a 1st rounder? I'm doubtful. I looked at him so more and then hit the years of past drafts to help me estimate his value. My comparison is Kevin Kolb, who was drafted in the 2nd.
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Not that impressive TBPH. He wasn't able to score a TD until the end of the 2nd half. Against ASU's D, that's pretty bad!

I know people will look at the stat line and say he threw for 390 and scratch their heads, but keep in mind a lower division school, NAU, threw for 370 against us. Webb threw for 480, Mahomes threw for 540. Add in the fact our defense is much worse at the moment with multiple injuries.

He threw a pretty TD pass to Gabe Marks thought with the game on the line.

I think Falk is a good QB and good prospect. Is he a 1st rounder? I'm doubtful. I looked at him so more and then hit the years of past drafts to help me estimate his value. My comparison is Kevin Kolb, who was drafted in the 2nd.

Sounds like a fair assessment...I still haven't been able to sit down and watch a game, all I've seen is highlights.
  • jimrat
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 24,000
Where is Baker Mayfield projected to go, he a little small but dude makes things happen out there.
Originally posted by jimrat:
Where is Baker Mayfield projected to go, he a little small but dude makes things happen out there.

I have him as a 4th-5th round pick. But I think most other pundits would have him higher.
I feel like I'm alone on this one, but I don't believe ANY of the QBs in this draft class are worth a 1st round pick. (Of course that won't stop teams from picking them)
Originally posted by DarkShinobiX:
I feel like I'm alone on this one, but I don't believe ANY of the QBs in this draft class are worth a 1st round pick. (Of course that won't stop teams from picking them)

Sounds exactly like what people were saying about last year's QBs. Todd McShay has your back though, don't worry.
The reality is some over drafting will happen because of the position. However, if you get a starter that can hold the position for 10 years, where they werr drafted doesn't matter. Alex Smith may not have been the best player or the best QB in 2005, but a lot of teams would probably take that now if it meant consitent playoff appearances and the stability ge offers, in spite of his limitations.

Whether there is a homerun pick or not at QB is out of the 4ers control. I just want a quarterback that has a high football IQ, is consistently accurate, can manuever well around the pocket, and can play in any system.

Having a canon for an arm, the ability to run around, Vick or Wilson like quickness, or Kaepernick speed are all bonuses, but not what I need first.

If a player fits the description in the second paragraph, I say use our first pick on him. Trading dowh in risky business. We saw last years teams are finally getting it and will make moves to ensure they get a guy.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Sounds like a fair assessment...I still haven't been able to sit down and watch a game, all I've seen is highlights.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:
Not that impressive TBPH. He wasn't able to score a TD until the end of the 2nd half. Against ASU's D, that's pretty bad!

I know people will look at the stat line and say he threw for 390 and scratch their heads, but keep in mind a lower division school, NAU, threw for 370 against us. Webb threw for 480, Mahomes threw for 540. Add in the fact our defense is much worse at the moment with multiple injuries.

He threw a pretty TD pass to Gabe Marks thought with the game on the line.

I think Falk is a good QB and good prospect. Is he a 1st rounder? I'm doubtful. I looked at him so more and then hit the years of past drafts to help me estimate his value. My comparison is Kevin Kolb, who was drafted in the 2nd.

Sounds like a fair assessment...I still haven't been able to sit down and watch a game, all I've seen is highlights.

The ASU game last weekend wasn't Falk at his best, the OL took the night off and allowed 7 sacks.
In my opinion, Chad Kelly is the most gifted QB in this class and from an on-field attribute perspective, he is a top-10 pick. He would be a very good fit for Chip's offense. He is tough as nails, has enough athleticism to run the read option, but most importantly, is a pass-first, pocket passer, who can attach all levels of the field with touch and arm strength. He is comfortable throwing to covered receivers and he progresses through his reads quite naturally. The question is whether teams are comfortable with him off the field and whether he has matured. I would love to grab Garrett with our first pick and to trade back into round 1 for Chad Kelly.

As for the flavor of the month, Trubinsky, he looks like a very nice player. However, with so few starts and having faced little adversity, i would have a hard time investing a high first-round pick in a guy with just good tools, who I don't see make a lot of NFL throws on a per-game basis. That's not to say, he doesn't have good enough arm strength and accuracy, I just have no idea how he operates in a muddled pocket and a lot of his completions in the intermediate to deep range are to wide open receivers. I would need to see another year from him before investing a high 1st round pick. People compare him to Wentz and Cam Newton who had few starts in college, but those guys had top-10 physical tools. Trubinsky does not.
Originally posted by Prometheus2001:
In my opinion, Chad Kelly is the most gifted QB in this class and from an on-field attribute perspective, he is a top-10 pick. He would be a very good fit for Chip's offense. He is tough as nails, has enough athleticism to run the read option, but most importantly, is a pass-first, pocket passer, who can attach all levels of the field with touch and arm strength. He is comfortable throwing to covered receivers and he progresses through his reads quite naturally. The question is whether teams are comfortable with him off the field and whether he has matured.

Chad Kelly is a headcase. If there is a position that you need stability at, it is QB. Kelly has shown that he is anything but mentally and emotionally stable.


would love to grab Garrett with our first pick and to trade back into round 1 for Chad Kelly.

Kelly isnt touching the first round or close. His performance has regressed this season, his accuracy has suffered. When he is good, he is REALLY good, when he is bad he is absolutely horrible. Lack of consistency+off the field questions means he will drop down the boards quite a bit.

As for the flavor of the month, Trubinsky, he looks like a very nice player.

Trubisky.


However, with so few starts and having faced little adversity, i would have a hard time investing a high first-round pick in a guy with just good tools, who I don't see make a lot of NFL throws on a per-game basis. That's not to say, he doesn't have good enough arm strength and accuracy, I just have no idea how he operates in a muddled pocket and a lot of his completions in the intermediate to deep range are to wide open receivers. I would need to see another year from him before investing a high 1st round pick. People compare him to Wentz and Cam Newton who had few starts in college, but those guys had top-10 physical tools. Trubinsky does not.


He has one of the highest completion rates against pressure in college football. Yes he has a limited resume but he has shown he can make a variety of throws, generally has very good ball placement, had made a lot of clutch plays late in games and plays with poise and confidence that you cant teach. Nothing fazes him and he exudes a level of calm that you love seeing from a QB. No moment feels too big for him. He was known for making clutch plays for the Tar Heels before he ever became a starter for them, having come into games and delivered in critical situations.

You can call him the 'flavor of the month', I say he's an excellent quarterback who is getting the opportunity to fully show off his talent. He has the traits and skillset of a quarterback that can do very well in the NFL with some development time and certainly will be drafted a lot higher than Kelly.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Oct 28, 2016 at 8:09 AM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone