Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 675 users in the forums

Draft Experts Wanted!

Browse 49ers books and videos
  • All22
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,914
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by Quest4six:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Picks have been determined:

Draft Round - Targets:
1 (15) - OLB/DE
2 (14) - WR
3 (15) - ILB/LG/RB
4 (14) To Buffalo for Stevie Johnson
4 (27) From Denver - RB/CB/FS
4 (33) Compensatory pick - LT/RT
5 (15) - NT
6 (14) - QB
7 (29) From Indianapolis for Cam Johnson - PK/P
7 (37) Compensatory pick - TE/H-Back

WR in the second round?

DGB, Strong? We have to remember that this is Boldin's last year and we'll need a big-bodied WCO WR in his mold to groom THIS year.

What would you do?

DEANDRE SMELTER, All-ACL team. 6'2, 226. 11 inch hands.

STRENGTHS:
Big receiver with physicality to match. On hitch routes, showed shake to make first defender miss and also showed he can punish defenders with a stiff-arm. Talented after the catch. His football intelligence really stands out. Has understanding of leverage within his routes and will adjust his route to counter the defender's actions. Able to create separation underneath by pushing cornerbacks with good route speed. Consistently worked back to quarterback when plays got off schedule. Uses wide frame to box out cornerbacks on back-shoulder throws near the boundary. Wins when ball is in the air with physicality, body control, well-timed leaps and strong hands. Capable run blocker. Great competitor with mature background.
Originally posted by All22:
DEANDRE SMELTER, All-ACL team. 6'2, 226. 11 inch hands.

STRENGTHS:
Big receiver with physicality to match. On hitch routes, showed shake to make first defender miss and also showed he can punish defenders with a stiff-arm. Talented after the catch. His football intelligence really stands out. Has understanding of leverage within his routes and will adjust his route to counter the defender's actions. Able to create separation underneath by pushing cornerbacks with good route speed. Consistently worked back to quarterback when plays got off schedule. Uses wide frame to box out cornerbacks on back-shoulder throws near the boundary. Wins when ball is in the air with physicality, body control, well-timed leaps and strong hands. Capable run blocker. Great competitor with mature background.

You all are fantastic. Each year, I really lean on you draft experts...my mind is 100% focused on players once they become 9ers...so this helps a ton. Thanks!
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by communist:
you tried that already?

You talking to me?
yes?
I'm no draft expert, but I did stay at a holiday inn last night.

1) DL
2) ILB
3) RB
4) WR
4) OG
5) CB
6) TE
7) OT
7) WR KR
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
I'm no draft expert, but I did stay at a holiday inn last night.

1) DL
2) ILB
3) RB
4) WR
4) OG
5) CB
6) TE
7) OT
7) WR KR

I would definitely go cb before rb. and dl in first if someone is avail. The is a gap in talent from like 2 guys to the 3rd round. and most first round talents are not 3-4 de talent. they are defensive tackles.
  • All22
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,914
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
I'm no draft expert, but I did stay at a holiday inn last night.

1) DL
2) ILB
3) RB
4) WR
4) OG
5) CB
6) TE
7) OT
7) WR KR

Now is the perfect time to change to a 4-3.
  • All22
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,914
Originally posted by fan49:
Originally posted by Big_Daddy:
I'm no draft expert, but I did stay at a holiday inn last night.

1) DL
2) ILB
3) RB
4) WR
4) OG
5) CB
6) TE
7) OT
7) WR KR

I would definitely go cb before rb. and dl in first if someone is avail. The is a gap in talent from like 2 guys to the 3rd round. and most first round talents are not 3-4 de talent. they are defensive tackles.

The problem at CB is that anyone likely to be around in the 3rd has a very good chance of getting buried in the depth chart for years. Hell, most of the second round guys might not start either.
Originally posted by communist:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by communist:
you tried that already?

You talking to me?
yes?

Are you asking if I've already put my picks together for this year uisng this "team needs" approach? Not yet!

Last year I did and by using this approach, I was able to pick Ward correctly...and a few others (and I know nothing about college ball). Another key resource is to identify all the players we had visits with. IIRC, 50% of the picks came from that list. Great boards to use are our own MadDog, OTC, etc...bunch of really good ones in this forum; should give you a really good idea where players "should" fall.

I find this approach way more rewarding vs. what "I" would want ideally and then being disappointed!
Originally posted by NCommand:
Are you asking if I've already put my picks together for this year uisng this "team needs" approach? Not yet!

Last year I did and by using this approach, I was able to pick Ward correctly...and a few others (and I know nothing about college ball). Another key resource is to identify all the players we had visits with. IIRC, 50% of the picks came from that list. Great boards to use are our own MadDog, OTC, etc...bunch of really good ones in this forum; should give you a really good idea where players "should" fall.

I find this approach way more rewarding vs. what "I" would want ideally and then being disappointed!
No, Im asking whether you tried to predict Baalke's approach before the preceding drafts already. You answered the question.

I don't get the last paragraph. Why do you even ask for our favorites if you don't even take a wishlist-approach seriously???
Originally posted by communist:
Originally posted by NCommand:
Are you asking if I've already put my picks together for this year uisng this "team needs" approach? Not yet!

Last year I did and by using this approach, I was able to pick Ward correctly...and a few others (and I know nothing about college ball). Another key resource is to identify all the players we had visits with. IIRC, 50% of the picks came from that list. Great boards to use are our own MadDog, OTC, etc...bunch of really good ones in this forum; should give you a really good idea where players "should" fall.

I find this approach way more rewarding vs. what "I" would want ideally and then being disappointed!
No, Im asking whether you tried to predict Baalke's approach before the preceding drafts already. You answered the question.

I don't get the last paragraph. Why do you even ask for our favorites if you don't even take a wishlist-approach seriously???



I take it all into consideration...some times the wishlist matches up with Baalke's wishlist too. I usually make one for what "I" would do (like I know anything) and another mock draft on what I think Baalke will do based on team needs, visits, you guys, etc.
Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by CorvaNinerFan:
DL should be the top priority...if Justin Smith retires, that's a huge amount of experience lost between him and Ray Mac. Dockett was a good signing, but it still means Tank has to step up big. Now's the time to draft a Goldman, Malcolm Brown or even go with the big NT from OK, Phillips.

Pass rusher's fine...no guarantees on Aldon.

OT's the OL priority...fine to take an OG as well, but not in 1st or 2nd rd as I've seen in plenty of mocks. There's little behind Staley & AD.

A position seemingly forgotten in many mocks is TE...Vernon's in his contract year, no guarantees he'll be back in 2016. I know Baalke likes Walford (he's kind of beastly).

ILB need could be addressed a bit later if Baalke signs Erin Henderson. This dude could be a real baller if his troubles are behind him.

Of course, CB's a priority...can't have too many. Would love to see Baalke grab Peters...dude's tough and skilled...our secondary could use that.

I hate "formula" drafts...and am pretty certain Baalke doesn't draft that way. He believes in BPA and when that's also a need, it's draft nirvana.

I believe Baalke does both...BPA at the position of needs is his #1 priority. However, if there is a significantly higher graded BPA at a non-position of need, he'll go that route over a BPA at a position of need. If the BPA at a position of need is just a slight grade lower than the BPA of a non-position of need, he'll go with that BPA at the position of need instead. If that makes any sense...

Agree! Baalke will go after a guy if he thinks the value is there--Reid--or take the best player--three guys who were listed by some as best at their positions: M Martin, Borland, and Hyde. Were they absolute needs at the time? No, but they turned out to be significant. If Borland hadn't retired it's likely that all three would start this year. As it is Martin and Hyde are almost certain to start.

As much as I've criticized Baalke for the Jenkins pick, I believe it possible that no one was willing to trade for the niners pick and Baalke took a flier...envelop or no envelop!
This is the mock I just did on fanspeak.com Trades were included

22 - R1P22 DT DANNY SHELTON WASHINGTON
51 - R2P19 WR DORIAL GREEN-BECKHAM MISSOURI
56 - R2P24 DE TREY FLOWERS ARKANSAS
79 - R3P15 CB IFO EKPRE-OLOMU OREGON
116 - R4P17 TE BLAKE BELL OKLAHOMA
121 - R4P22 RB JEREMY LANGFORD MICHIGAN STATE
126 - R4P27 G ARIE KOUANDJIO ALABAMA
132 - R4P33 ILB MIKE HULL PENN STATE
151 - R5P15 QB GARRETT GRAYSON COLORADO STATE
189 - R6P14 P TREVOR PARDULA KANSAS
246 - R7P29 OLB SAGE HAROLD JAMES MADISON
254 - R7P37 CB LADARIUS GUNTER MIAMI FL
Originally posted by BARnova:
This is the mock I just did on fanspeak.com Trades were included

22 - R1P22 DT DANNY SHELTON WASHINGTON
51 - R2P19 WR DORIAL GREEN-BECKHAM MISSOURI
56 - R2P24 DE TREY FLOWERS ARKANSAS
79 - R3P15 CB IFO EKPRE-OLOMU OREGON
116 - R4P17 TE BLAKE BELL OKLAHOMA
121 - R4P22 RB JEREMY LANGFORD MICHIGAN STATE
126 - R4P27 G ARIE KOUANDJIO ALABAMA
132 - R4P33 ILB MIKE HULL PENN STATE
151 - R5P15 QB GARRETT GRAYSON COLORADO STATE
189 - R6P14 P TREVOR PARDULA KANSAS
246 - R7P29 OLB SAGE HAROLD JAMES MADISON
254 - R7P37 CB LADARIUS GUNTER MIAMI FL

I was sold after the first two!

1 (15) - OLB/DE
2 (14) - WR
3 (15) - ILB/LG/RB
4 (27) From Denver - CB/FS
4 (33) Compensatory pick - LT/RT
5 (15) - NT
6 (14) - QB
7 (29) From Indianapolis for Cam Johnson - PK/P
7 (37) Compensatory pick - TE/H-Back

So in terms of need, you only missed out on a true FS to back up Reid, a swing T and PK. Well done!
  • GEEK
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 19,435
When I look at the roster today, I see immediate needs at DL, ILB, and DB. I see depth needs at RB (Bush and Hunter health concerns) and S (Reid's health). Then I see future needs at WR, OL, DE/OLB, DL, and ILB. Perhaps a K/P if there's a good player at the right value. So you factor all of that in...here's where my head is at...

*49ers trade down for Panthers 1st and 3rd round picks - CAR trades up to select OL*

R1: Eddie Goldman - NT/DE - Florida State (via CAR)
*Beef up to be a 2 gap NT or slim down and be a powerful 3-4 DE. Plays both roles in his rookie year. Played alongside Carradine.
*Projected to go in the late teens to end of the 1st. Not a reach.
*Addresses immediate need.

R2: Denzel Perryman - ILB - Miami
*Replacement for Willis and Borland, prototypical skills for a 3-4 ILB.
*Projected to go late 2nd, early 3rd. Slight reach.
*Addresses immediate need.

R3: Trey Flowers - DE/OLB/DT - Arkansas
*Reminds me of Pernell McPhee, formerly of the Ravens. You can line him up at DT, DE, and OLB and he'll make an impact.
*Projected to go late 2nd to late 3rd. Not a reach.
*Addresses immediate and future need.

R3: Cedric Ogbuehi - OT/OG - Texas A&M (via CAR)
*Projected replacement for Boone in 2016 as he recovers from a torn ACL. 1st round talent in the late 3rd.
*Projected to go late 3rd to early 4th. Not a reach.
*Addresses future need.

R4: Javorius Allen - RB - USC (via DEN)
*Good size and skills to rotate with Hyde has the primary back. Insurance policy for Bush and Hunter.
*Projected to go mid-4th to mid-5th. Not a reach.
*Addresses depth need.

R4: Stefon Diggs - WR - Maryland (COMP)
*Reminds me a bit of Victor Cruz, Diggs can instantly contribute as a slot WR and ST.
*Projected to go in the late 4th to early 6th. Not a reach.
*Addresses future need.

R5: Justin Coleman - CB - Tennessee
*Strong, thick corner with good ballhawking skills. A bit too slow, but proper training and technique could make him a tangible #3.
*Projected to go in early 5th to early 7th. Not a reach.
*Addresses depth need.

R6: Hayes Pullard - ILB - USC
*Sideline to slideline speed and good at coverage. Competes with Moody and Skov for a roster spot.
*Projected to go in the late 5th to late 7th. Not a reach.
*Addresses depth need.

R7: Detrick Bonner - S - UVU
*ST ace with raw skills to develop into a solid backup.
*Projected to go in the early 7th to UDFA. Not a reach.
*Addresses future need.

R7: Gary Nova - QB - Rutgers (COMP)
*Camp body that will end up on the PS.

Depth Chart -

QB: Kaepernick/Gabbert
RB: Hyde/Bush/Hunter/Allen*
FB: Miller
TE: Davis/McDonald/Carrier/Millard

WR: Boldin/Patton
WR: Smith*/Ellington
WR: Simpson*/Diggs*

LT: Staley/Pears*
LG: Thomas/Looney
C: Kilgore/M. Martin
RG: Boone
RT: Davis

LE: Dockett*/Goldman*
NT: Dorsey/Williams
RE: Carradine/Dial

OLB: Smith/Flowers*/Lemonier
ILB: Bowman/Pullard*
ILB: Perryman*/Wilhoite
OLB: Brooks/Lynch

CB: Brock/Wright*/Reaser*
CB: Johnson/Acker*/Coleman*
FS: Reid/Ward
SS: Bethea/Dahl

ST: Dawson, Lee, Nelson

PUP: Ogbuehi
[ Edited by GEEK on Mar 24, 2015 at 8:05 PM ]
^^ Really like this draft Geek! The write up on Allen makes him sound like a Gore with longer legs (not a good thing, but not a deal breaker).

Goldman and Perryman would address the problems in the middle with smaller NTs and Willis retiring.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Mar 24, 2015 at 8:33 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone