Originally posted by NCommand:
Originally posted by sfninerfanMax:
A+ great players drafted, Boldin, McCoy and a 3rd round pick in 2014!
Exactly! All these picks PLUS Boldin, McCoy and a 3rd rounder for 2014 is beyond epic IMHO! I'd give it an A.
Actual Picks:
1 (18) Eric Reid (6'2" 212 4.49 40, 40.5" VL 29 WS), FS, LSU
2 (40) Cornellius Carradine (6'4" 276), RDE, Florida State
2 (55) Vance McDonald (6'5" 267), TE, Rice
3 (88) Corey Lemonier (6'4" 255), OLB, Auburn
4 (128) Quinton Patton (6'0" 204), WR, Louisiana Tech
4 (131) Marcus Lattimore (6'0" 232), RB, South Carolina
5 (157) Quinton Dial (6'6" 318), LDE Alabama
6 (180) Nick Moody (6'1" 236), ILB Florida State
7 (237) B.J. Daniels (6'0" 217), QB South Florida
7 (246) Carter Bykowski (6'7" 306), OT Iowa State
7 (252) Marcus Cooper (6'2" 192), CB Rutgers
UDFA Signings:
DE Lawrence Okoye (6'6" 300+), Oxford
DE Michael Percell (6'3" 305), Wyoming
OT Luke Marquardt (6'8" 315), Asuza-Pacific
QB/WR/TE MarQuies Gray (6'4" 240), Minnesota
OG Patrick Omameh (6'4" 306), Michigan
LS Kevin McDermott (6'5" 238), UCLA
Boy, are you the homer!
Thanks for putting all the results up. Makes it so much easier to comment on.
B+
One cannot really judge a draft without more hindsight, but as we're just playing around, my reasons:
1. Gave up too much for Eric Reid. I didn't think that he was the best FS out there and, even if he was, there wasn't enough separation betwwen him and the next few to warrant giving up a thrid that could have been used to shore up an position which IMO now becomes the team's greatest area of need: Cornerback. The team has a lot of short-timers/questionables manning those spots. Competition is needed there. If Reid is not an immediate plug-and-play this pick, as made, would get a failing grade in my book. I'm curious how he'll compare this season againtst, say, Cyprien. However a pressing need was met. So I'm giving it a C+
2. Honestly, I felt that pass rush help, both from the DL and OLB spot, was a greater critical need for the Niners than the safety spot. A good pass rush can make an average backfield look great. I think that the Niners were an example of this. So the drafting of Carradine and Lemonier were tantamount to hitting it out of the park. I think that both of these guys will be excellent. We'll see. I'd give these two an A+ but for the fact of Carradine's ACL tear (which is the only reason that the Niners got him where they did IMO). But still: A
3. McDonald is a project. Right now, he's not a reliable pass catcher. How frustrating was Delanie in this respect? But Vance has been versatile. Would have preferred that the Niners go CB at this spot. But I cannot fault Niner's for going TE. Interesting prospect. Given the alternatives, grade : B.
4. The fourth round was great. Who wouldn't prefer to have more speed at the wideout, but we're hoping that Jenkins and Lockette show up this year, aren't we? Lattimore has the ACL tears, but its well worth rolling the dice. And Patton! Grade : A
5. I really like the Dial and Bykowski picks (maybe throw in Moody also) primarily because of these guys' versatility and where there were picked. But the alternative, maybe picking up a better corner prospect (some decent rated ones were still available), has to be factored in in the grading here. Grade: B
6. Forget grading the rest. Pure crap shoot. Really wish they could ahve picked up Matt Scott as a developmental QB. My personal favorite.
As an aside: Obviiously Baalke did not have Carradine targetted in this draft, Tank just fell to him. They gambled by trading down from #34 when he it would have been perfectly acceptable to have taken Carradine there. I say the wasn't a priority in Baalke's eyes because one cannot crow about moving agressively in going after a player that "we have targetted" i.e., Reid in this draft, and then rolling the dice with another. Right?
Anyway's hope Tank recovers nicely from the ACL. Love the pick. My favorite pick in this draft