1st Round Pick (7th and FINAL Poll, No Trades) | Page 2

NinerBuff · 2018-04-11T07:37:09-07:00

Dec. 23, 2017: I think it's likely that we'll be either 4-12 or 5-11, and picking 5-7th overall. NOTE: I've eliminated QB, DT, S, and OT from the list as I don't see how we would select one of these positions. Results (141 total votes): Quentin Nelson - 33% Bradley Chubb - 17% Saquon Barkley - 15% Roquan Smith - 13% Minkah Fitzpatrick - 9% Harold Landry - 7% Calvin Ridley - 4% Courtland Sutton - 3% Arden Key - 1% Jan. 5, 2018: Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD). NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT from the list, but added back in OT and S. I've also eliminated Bradley Chubb and Saquon Barkley as they are widely considered top-5 selections. Results (168 total votes): Quentin Nelson - 39% Harold Landry - 16% Joshua Jackson - 13% Roquan Smith - 11% Calvin Ridley - 8% Arden Key - 5% Minkah Fitzpatrick - 4% Mike McGlinchey - 2% Courtland Sutton - 1% Clelin Ferrell - 1% Jan. 23, 2018: Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD). NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT. I'm adding Bradley Chubb back into the fray, but keeping Saquon Barkley off, and eliminating Clelin Ferrell as he's going back to school. The list now includes names from previous polls and recent mock drafts. Results (97 total votes): Quentin Nelson - 39% Roquan Smith - 18% Bradley Chubb - 13% Joshua Jackson - 10% Minkah Fitzpatrick - 7% Marcus Davenport - 3% Tremaine Edmunds - 2% Courtland Sutton - 2% Derwin James - 2% Denzel Ward - 2% Harold Landry - 1% Feb. 14, 2018: Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD). NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT. I'm adding Saquon Barkley back into the poll. Results (62 total votes): Quentin Nelson - 37% Bradley Chubb - 15% Joshua Jackson - 11% Roquan Smith - 10% Saquon Barkley - 10% Harold Landry - 5% Denzel Ward - 3% Tremaine Edmunds - 3% Derwin James - 2% Calvin Ridley - 2% Marcus Davenport - 2% Mike McGlinchey - 2% Mar. 6, 2018: Niners will be picking 9th. Combine performances are now taken into consideration. Big news regarding Reuben Foster since the last poll. NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT from the list. Since the combine, I've eliminated Bradley Chubb and Saquon Barkley again. They both appear to be top-5 picks and this poll is not considering trade-up scenarios. I've also dropped Arden Key and Orlando Brown from consideration. Results (61 total votes): Harold Landry - 33% Quentin Nelson - 30% Roquan Smith - 13% Tremaine Edmunds - 11% Derwin James - 5% Calvin Ridley - 3% Denzel Ward - 3% Minkah Fitzpartrick - 3% Mar. 19, 2018: Niners will be picking 9th. Free Agency signings are now taken into consideration. NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT from the list. I've dropped Mike McGlinchey from consideration. Results (61 total votes): Harold Landry - 34% Quentin Nelson - 28% Roquan Smith - 14% Tremaine Edmunds - 8% Derwin James - 6% Denzel Ward - 3% Marcus Davenport - 3% Calvin Ridley - 2%Apr. 11, 2018: No substantial changes since last poll, now that FA frenzy has died down, this will be the last poll. COM - Combine PV - Private Visit

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:29 PM

#16

TheNef77
Q46 Draft 3rd place
Posts: 1,489

Originally posted by Heroism:
BTW, Kyle confirmed that his QB coach Rich Scangarello met with CJ at the combine. They just didn't bring him in for a private visit.

Kyle Shanahan did not meet with CJ Beathard at the combine. QB coach Rich Scangarello did.
— Jennifer Lee Chan (@jenniferleechan) April 29, 2017

That's all day one and day two players accounted for in some capacity.

Tweet came out after he was picked. How do we not know that a Niners rep met with QN at the ND pro day? You guys are counting all these unlisted meetings last year but not this year. C'Mon guy

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:36 PM

#17

Heroism
Veteran
Posts: 26,433

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Tweet came out after he was picked. How do we not know that a Niners rep met with QN at the ND pro day? You guys are counting all these unlisted meetings last year but not this year. C'Mon guy

And you're using the exception to prove a point.

The fact is that it was public knowledge that the majority of the players drafted by the 49ers on day one and day two had met with the team. Are there visits and meetings that go unreported? Absolutely. Are visits the be all and end all? No. But there is unequivocal correlation there.

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:45 PM

#18

TheNef77
Q46 Draft 3rd place
Posts: 1,489

Originally posted by Heroism:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Tweet came out after he was picked. How do we not know that a Niners rep met with QN at the ND pro day? You guys are counting all these unlisted meetings last year but not this year. C'Mon guy

And you're using the exception to prove a point.

The fact is that it was public knowledge that the majority of the players drafted by the 49ers on day one and day two had met with the team. Are there visits and meetings that go unreported? Absolutely. Are visits the be all and end all? No. But there is unequivocal correlation there.

Exception? Remember when you arrogantly said that the Niners met with Garrett multiple times, and that you had your ish down, and then it turned out that they later canceled the visit but I guess we're still counting it you make you look right anyways? You mean like that exception?

Fact is that 2 of 4 day 1 and 2 picks had "official" visits. You can go 4 of 4 with "exceptions" all you want. Fact is, you don't for sure know if a Niner rep met with QN at the pro day or the combine nor do you know the rest of the unpublished meetings we've had with prospects.

My real original point was that QN can play Guard in this scheme as well as ANY INSIDE LINEMAN in the draft since Travis Frederick.

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:48 PM

#19

Heroism
Veteran
Posts: 26,433

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Exception? Remember when you arrogantly said that the Niners met with Garrett multiple times, and that you had your ish down, and then it turned out that they later canceled the visit but I guess we're still counting it you make you look right anyways? You mean like that exception?

Fact is that 2 of 4 day 1 and 2 picks had "official" visits. You can go 4 of 4 with "exceptions" all you want. Fact is, you don't for sure know if a Niner rep met with QN at the pro day or the combine nor do you know the rest of the unpublished meetings we've had with prospects.

My real original point was that QN can play Guard in this scheme as well as ANY INSIDE LINEMAN in the draft since Travis Frederick.

Uh, I never mentioned one thing about Quenton Nelson in this thread...

Which brings me to another point: Don't smoke crack, kids.

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:51 PM

#20

TheNef77
Q46 Draft 3rd place
Posts: 1,489

Originally posted by Heroism:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Exception? Remember when you arrogantly said that the Niners met with Garrett multiple times, and that you had your ish down, and then it turned out that they later canceled the visit but I guess we're still counting it you make you look right anyways? You mean like that exception?

Fact is that 2 of 4 day 1 and 2 picks had "official" visits. You can go 4 of 4 with "exceptions" all you want. Fact is, you don't for sure know if a Niner rep met with QN at the pro day or the combine nor do you know the rest of the unpublished meetings we've had with prospects.

My real original point was that QN can play Guard in this scheme as well as ANY INSIDE LINEMAN in the draft since Travis Frederick.

Uh, I never mentioned one thing about Quenton Nelson in this thread...

Which brings me to another point: Don't smoke crack, kids.

Another point, follow the replies that you tried to jump in...and then use the crack joke to downplay it again.

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:54 PM

#21

Heroism
Veteran
Posts: 26,433

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Another point, follow the replies that you tried to jump in...and then use the crack joke to downplay it again.

Except my original post was merely a response to the topic of the thread. Notice how there's no quote in my post?

Lol, not a single post of mine in this thread has the words Quenton Nelson...

[ Edited by Heroism on Apr 11, 2018 at 3:57 PM ]

Apr 11, 2018 at 3:58 PM

#22

TheNef77
Q46 Draft 3rd place
Posts: 1,489

Originally posted by Heroism:

Originally posted by TheNef77:
Another point, follow the replies that you tried to jump in...and then use the crack joke to downplay it again.

Except my original post was merely a response to the topic of the thread. Notice how there's no quote in my post?

Lol

Notice how we still kept the whole topic without quoting the whole thread? Same format with an exception I guess.

Lol

Apr 11, 2018 at 4:52 PM

#23