Originally posted by Ninerjohn:
LOL This coming from the guy who was counting the Giants out last year by May. The Giants did not have their best player in 2011 which is why making that trade for Beltran made even less sense. If Posey had been healthy and the Giants were at full strength the trade would have made more sense. Either way though, it was fricking stupid .
We were in contention at the time we made the trade and if I recall correctly, we won 2 of the first 3 with Beltran @ Philly. We were 1st in the NL West and I think we may have been close to the top record in the NL as well. The team just went on a terrible slide after that.
I don't think it's fair to say we didn't have a shot in 2011 because even with Posey out, we were still winning...yes it didn't sustain but that was after the trade.
I was in favor of trying to get Beltran at the time, but even me, someone who doesn't pay attention to MiLB, had heard of how good Wheeler could be...so I didn't like giving him up.