Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by GNielsen:
Yeah, that's overstating his importance in the system. Walker is absolutely not "the reason we run our offense." There are at least two viable alternatives in the second round of the draft who have similar speed and are very tall (both are 6'6"). And Celek is also a good blocker who is already on the roster. And, I agree with SammyFrancisco above - either of those 6'6" guys are natural pass catchers with good hands and would give Kaepernick another advantage in the red zone.
And, I have to point this out - "cry about his drop rate"??!! Dude, he has the biggest drop rate for his position in the league. He's a receiver. When Kaepernick floats a perfect pass into his hands to win the Rams game, he's got to make that catch because HE'S A RECEIVER! I don't care how many blocks he throws - his main job is to catch the ball when it is thrown to him. Blocking is icing on the cake, but if it's a crappy tasting cake, the icing doesn't help that much.
He has the biggest drop rate in the NFL...period...and its not even close. Dropping 30% of your targets? That is insanely bad. For every 2 passes he catches, he drops one.....as a comparison, Jimmy Graham had about 3 or 4 more drops than Walker....but Graham also caught about 70 more passes.
Just want to point out, Vernon Davis had the 6th highest drop rate going into the 2012 season (the previous 3 seasons)... Both our TEs have issues holding onto the ball. Out of the 30% incompletion rate VD had this year, I'd like to know how many of those were drops.
Found it:
About 5-6%. His production dropped greatly, however, so I'm wondering if it would be higher if he were targeted more this year?
https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2012/12/06/sig-stat-snapshot-receiving-production-tight-ends/
Anyhow, if we draft his replacement, sure, let him go, but otherwise, it's not a necessity...
[ Edited by mkmasn on Mar 3, 2013 at 2:29 AM ]