Originally posted by 49erfaithful49:
Alex Smith is better than
whoever Tennessee is starting
The eagles could use a QB
this is true. idk if he's really that much better than Romo, but he Smith doesnt choke or create as many turnovers so thats what puts him ahead. Smith could thrive in a place like Dallas because they have a nice running game and some nice reciever with a probowl Tightend. Ball security is a big problem in Dallas but i dont cant see it happening.
I say Smith should stay but somehow we get him to re-structure his contract. Kap is good, but if he gets hurt(which could happen as much as he scrambles), Tolzien is our backup and we could end up like Pit, Chicago or Philly this year or KC last year. We currently have two "#1 Qbs" on our roster and the reason Kap gets the nod to play is because he has a cannon and can run. If it were any other team whose backup played starter level, there wouldnt be a "Qb controversy", the back up would be the back up and the starter would go back to starting. I like the whole competition thing, but not at the QB position. Let Smith actually lose his starting role, not have it taken away because of injury. My point is, keeping smith as a backup would be the smart thing to do if he's not the starter.
[ Edited by martysofresh on Nov 26, 2012 at 11:27 PM ]