Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Originally posted by jcashen87:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
It doesn't matter, if CK starts one more game, it's too late to go back to Smith.
I think if CK starts in the playoffs, our chance at getting to a Super Bowl is about 5-10 percent. Just getting there.
What do you feel the chance is if Alex starts the playoffs?
Honest question
I think it could be up to 50-50 (Remember, this is just making it there -- not getting into whether we win it or not). Only because Smith is incredibly smart and if he had to face the Giants again I believe he would have a far better game, showing he learned from the one poor showing. Smith is a guy who gets better and better as the season goes along.
I feel like the chances of Kaepernick making too many mistakes is higher than Smith, and that's ultimately why I'd feel more comfortable with Alex in the playoffs right now. Next year, in CK's third year, all bets are off though.
Smith has already faced the Giants again and had his worst game of the season. I think CK can counter the Giants D which blitzes and stays close to the line stopping the run and the short passing game. CK could back that D off some and make them play honest.