It doesnt make much sense to me to keep Cartwright over Dixon. Many say Cartwright is this so called "special teams ace," but yet I dont see much upgrade over Dixon on punt coverage. AD is always in on the plays in ST. The run game has holes that I can drive a truck through, so I dont want to hear that Rock is busting through the line running the ball. The ceiling is already set for RC. We know what he has; he will not get much playing time on offense. We could get more and more improvement from AD starting this year. Dixon has shown flashes, none can say he hasnt. And Dixon is what, 6 years younger??? You make the call. No! I make the call, Dixon offers more talent, and ability, and energy to me than Cartwright.
Let me ask: If Jacobs goes down in-season with injury, who do you want as your short-yardage back?