There are 134 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Who do you WANT to be QB

Who do you WANT to be QB

Brees of course
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by hedsup:
Scott Tolzien

what is a hed sup?

Heads Up?
Let's win our 6th with Alex!
Originally posted by ninerfan818:
Originally posted by HessianDud:
Originally posted by hedsup:
Scott Tolzien

what is a hed sup?

Heads Up?

i prefer to think of it as hed sup, since misspelling your user name is too sad.
Originally posted by Wu-5Rings:
Originally posted by 11ThrowItNDaDirt:
Im not hating on any Alex fan. I just wish people would ask what has he actually done? He led one the lowest ranking passing offenses in the league. And he wants to get paid for that? Could you produce what he did at your job and still have one? I just want them to move on, for the good or bad. How many people said Hunter, Davis, Culliver, etc were not ready? We will never know until Colin is given a fair chance.

This- I just want to move from the Alex era already...


I agree also. Alex should be thanking our def and special teams unit
Originally posted by Mann716:
Originally posted by Wu-5Rings:
Originally posted by 11ThrowItNDaDirt:
Im not hating on any Alex fan. I just wish people would ask what has he actually done? He led one the lowest ranking passing offenses in the league. And he wants to get paid for that? Could you produce what he did at your job and still have one? I just want them to move on, for the good or bad. How many people said Hunter, Davis, Culliver, etc were not ready? We will never know until Colin is given a fair chance.

This- I just want to move from the Alex era already...


I agree also. Alex should be thanking our def and special teams unit

Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee tooooooooooooooooooooooo
For those who seem quite comfortable to move on to Kap and/or Tolzien, I want you to temper your enthusiasm with the following question:

Out of over 100 QBs darfted during the last ten years, how many QBs drafted in the 2nd round or later have shown themselves to be franchise or elite QBs? Kap was the 6th QB drafted last year.

How many who were the 6th QB drafted or later have shown themselves to be franchise or elite? You are going to have to go back 12 years to find Tom Brady (7th one chosen that year). Frankly gentlemen, history is not on your side.

Is it possible? Yes, but not likely. The great Walsh drafted six QBs after Montana. As great a QB coach as he was, how many do you remember?
Johnson or CK if we throw in Wallace.
Smith. Guy has earned the $8mil/yr and another year or two with Harbaugh after last season. Kaep will still be there if it doesn't work out with Smith again, but all signs point to Smith improving - age, 2011 performance, better WRs, etc.
IMO have Smith sign a 3 year contract, however the problem is Smith now understands that he will get 1 more year of playing time but after that he will have to battle Kap, possible FA and Tolzien for the job. So the question is do we get the Smith who pulled off the New Orleans come from behind victory along with 5 other come from behind victories and a Smith who improves with OTA's etc., or are we getting the Smith who is he going to go back to being afraid of making mistakes?

The other huge question that must be answered has Smith lost complete trust with Harbaugh and is he feeling like his team mates have lost respect for him because of mangments attempt to get Manning or when things cool down will he be analytical enough to recognize the team had the chance to have 1 of the best QB's who ever played the game?
Originally posted by Bejaard49er:
IMO have Smith sign a 3 year contract, however the problem is Smith now understands that he will get 1 more year of playing time but after that he will have to battle Kap, possible FA and Tolzien for the job. So the question is do we get the Smith who pulled off the New Orleans come from behind victory along with 5 other come from behind victories and a Smith who improves with OTA's etc., or are we getting the Smith who is he going to go back to being afraid of making mistakes?

The other huge question that must be answered has Smith lost complete trust with Harbaugh and is he feeling like his team mates have lost respect for him because of mangments attempt to get Manning or when things cool down will he be analytical enough to recognize the team had the chance to have 1 of the best QB's who ever played the game?
Its all speculation. I seriously doubt if Smith does better than last year and the team does well that there will be an open competition.

Now if he doesn't I believe he's gone but are you haters seriously rooting for Smtih to fail?
Originally posted by jacklegniner:
I really don't understand the zone talk here. I agree with anyone saying that Alex did good last year. The 13-3 record was more than anyone expected. But, with all that being said, Out of 31 other teams in the NFL, only 1 team has brought in Alex to make him an offer... and the Dolphins might have been just gameplay. I think the rest of the NFL see's him as a serviceable guy but never going to be anything great. So, there are ALex Haters that just think he sucks and then there are people that just want to move on because Alex is never going to be that good. The rest of the team seems perfect in almost every position. The QB just seems average. I don't want to lose but I would rather roll the dice and see if Kaep or Tolzien can be great...

After we came so close to the Super Bowl you want to "roll the dice" ?????????

We just had our greatest season in almost 20 years. Lets get a full off season under our belts and go get us a ring
Originally posted by captveg:
Smith. Guy has earned the $8mil/yr and another year or two with Harbaugh after last season. Kaep will still be there if it doesn't work out with Smith again, but all signs point to Smith improving - age, 2011 performance, better WRs, etc.
If the question was just try out Smith for 1 more year than I would be ok with it. Last year was just a one year contract. I just don't want to lock him up for 3 years...
  • NP9er
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 163

Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
Joe Montana

Nick Montana