There are 116 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

who is the 49ers top 5 players all time and in what order

i say 1.montanna,2.rice3.young4.lott5.craig
Originally posted by redniner49:
i say 1.montanna,2.rice3.young4.lott5.craig

Craig @ 5??? He's arguably not even a top-5 RUNNING BACK in Niner history (Gore, Hearst, guys way back when like Million Dollar Backfield and s**t). He probably is, but still...definitely not a top-5 player period in our history. IMO Willis is already there.
Originally posted by andes14:
Craig @ 5??? He's arguably not even a top-5 RUNNING BACK in Niner history (Gore, Hearst, guys way back when like Million Dollar Backfield and s**t). He probably is, but still...definitely not a top-5 player period in our history. IMO Willis is already there.

you have a point stat wise but craig was vital in our past game and a big factor in our 2 and 3rd superbowl
off the board selection, jimmy johnson
Rice
Montana
Lott
Haley even though he's a sellout
Willis at this point in his career
Originally posted by elguapo:
Rice
Montana
Lott
Haley even though he's a sellout
Willis at this point in his career

You hate Mormons or something?
My list:

Jerry Rice
Joe Montana
Steve Young
Ronnie Lott
Terrell Owens (soon to be Patrick Willis)

(Im sure I will get a ton of hate for the last one, but it was either him, Gore or Haley. I went with T.O)
Rice
Montana
Young
Lott
Nomineli
Joe Montana (greatest QB of all time)
Jerry Rice (greatest WR of all time)
Dwight Clark (who understood Walsh's complicated system)
Ronnie Lott (is Ronnie Lott)
Charles Haley
Montanna
Montanna
Montanna
Montanna
Montanna
Montana
Rice
Young
Lott
Willis
Rice
Montana
Lott
Young
Bob St. Clair.
FRANK GIRE!!!!
i would go

Montana
Rice
Lott
Haley
5 should probably be Willis--but for fun i will take a flyer---and go with Jesse Sapolu--offensive guard
Montanna
Gire
Goldston
C. Rodgers
Harbough