There are 136 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Harbaugh or Luck?

Harbaugh or Luck?

Harbaugh can make Alex look good, gotta go with coach!
a Franchise coach can mold a qb into a franchise qb so i'll take the coach
  • lyer
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 136
im really surprised hardball is dominating so far in this poll.

i voted for him as well.
Originally posted by lyer:
im really surprised hardball is dominating so far in this poll.

i voted for him as well.

I think we've all seen what happens when all you have is talent, and no one capable of leading that talent.
Some coaches just know how to get the most out of QBs. Harbaugh is one of those rare people. I'll take the coach all day.

It's no coincidence that Josh Johnson, Luck, and Alex all played their best football under Harbaugh. I can't wait until Kap and Tolzein get settled in and more comfortable in the offense. They both look like they have better natural abilities than Alex. I really like Kap's arm strength and willingness to through the ball down the field. From what little we've seen from Tolzein, it appears that he's extremely accurate and has nice poise in the pocket.

Luck looks like he might be playing in South Beach next season. The Dolphins are horrible.
Originally posted by strickac:
Luck looks like he might be playing in South Beach next season. The Dolphins are horrible.

The Suck for Luck Sweepstakes are currently as follows;
Rams, Dolphins and Colts are all 0-6
Vikings are 1-6
Cards and Jags are 1-5

Of course it all means nothing if he pulls an Eli Manning and says he will only play for his coach!
Harbaugh could be here 'til he's 80. Luck wouldn't be here past 40. Also, Harbaugh has no shot at suffering a career ending injury.
Originally posted by Texas9erFan:
Is this the thread where we talk about Andrew Luck saying "it doesn't matter who tries to draft him, because he will only play for his former coach???"





This would be great!!! I would trade two 1st rounds to get Luck. Look, Oakland did that for Palmer!!
I kno its the bye week n all but this Andrew Luck talk is crazy... we are 5-1 and we will not suck for luck
Originally posted by Texas9erFan:
Originally posted by strickac:
Luck looks like he might be playing in South Beach next season. The Dolphins are horrible.

The Suck for Luck Sweepstakes are currently as follows;
Rams, Dolphins and Colts are all 0-6
Vikings are 1-6
Cards and Jags are 1-5

Of course it all means nothing if he pulls an Eli Manning and says he will only play for his coach!

Realistically, the Rams, Cards, Vikings, and Jags are out because it would be a huge surprise for those teams to select a QB. It looks like Miami and the Colts are the front-runners; although, the Colt would probably be willin to trade if Peyton is on track with his recovery. I think Miami's owner will be pretty aggressive to fix their QB situation. This looks like a solid crop of QB prospects too, so who knows? With all the rookie QBs playing well this season, we could see some talented guys falling in the draft. There's not too many teams desperate at the position... Mia, Den, Sea, Wash... That's about it.
So are you saying that Jim can turn anyone off the street in to Andrew Luck? I guarantee that piece Kapertits (sorry, not a fan of his) ends up being nothing, even with all the help in the world.
Coach is one of a kind! Gotta have Harbs
So I make a thread about Luck that could actually happen and it gets locked. This dude makes a thread thats not even based in reality but it stays open? Ok......

I do agree it should have been in the Draft section of the site.

P.S. Normally I wouldnt make a thread like that, but it's the bye week and very slow.
[ Edited by Oakland-Niner on Oct 23, 2011 at 8:24 PM ]
Originally posted by Nicks240:
So are you saying that Jim can turn anyone off the street in to Andrew Luck? I guarantee that piece Kapertits (sorry, not a fan of his) ends up being nothing, even with all the help in the world.

What did Kaep do to you. This level of hate can only be personal He hasn't shown or done anything other than be a 2nd round pick qb in the draft.
luck will dictate where he goes even if he comes out for the draft depending on who lands the number 1 or 2 slots eli manning sititaution any coach whos offensive minded can turn any qb around