I never had a chance to see the Catch as I was 11 at the time and in Europe . I didn't even know there was such a thing as the NFL then.
Montana to Taylor in SB 23 made me a 49ers fan (yes, I was the original bandwagon fan).
My personal top though without a doubt was the first Eric Davis play in the Eric Davis Game (aka the 94 NFC Championship). I don't think I ever felt such joy at a single NFL play again: I knew we would get that Cowboys monkey off our back on that moment. And the justice of having Eric Davis make the play when everybody was on his case for being supposedly the weak link made it extra satisfying.
Only Arsenal winning the title at Liverpool with the last kick of the season in 1989 and Greece winning the European Championships in 2004 while 100-1 dogs can compare for sheer sporting joy (I'm a Greek living in North London you see
[ Edited by paulk205 on Aug 16, 2011 at 3:51 PM ]