Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
Originally posted by susweel:
Im happy we won but I will not praise a mediocre at best QB effort.
We disagree on his performance, then. Great ball placement, gutsy block to free Gore, ballsy end zone run, 75% completion percentage, no sacks (good pocket presence) and no turnovers. I'd call that a good performance, not "mediocre at best." Look at it this way: If VD, Gore or Morgan keep their feet, the yardage gets close to 200 and Smith's has a TD throw. Would you call that a good performance?
Those are big "ifs" and changes the game.
Not really. ONE broken ankle tackle.
But see how that one act would have changed the stat line? Smith did well re: things within his control. He cannot control a WR/RB/TE failing to capitalize on a good throw.
No your just blaming them for not making a super star caliber play. Okay how about missing Crabs wide open in the endzone, and consistently dumping the ball down on third down short of the first down marker.
Did you ever think about the fact that we constantly set ourselves up for failure on 3rd down by running it on 1st and 2nd down?
Or do you expect Smith to overcome 3rd and 12s all day? The circumstances this week ( offense not gelled yet, not having learned enough of the playbook yet to put forth a complete balanced gameplan) were far too complicated to just look at the stat line and say 'oh, he had a bad/good/mediocre game as a QB'
My point is that we need to move on from this game. We cannot expect to see these types of games because that is not what Harbaugh envisioned. Week 1 was in a way a set back for Harbaugh, and I'm just glad that despite the circumstance, we were able to pull out a TEAM win. I don't care if the offense didn't win it vs the Seahawks on September 11th, 2011. I'm content with a TEAM win, and look forward to Harbaugh moving more and more towards his goal to establish this team with a flexible/balanced WCO attack, and an aggressive, dominating defense.
Rome wasn't built in a day.