Originally posted by jdt84_2:
Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Who cares if players are going to these workouts or not? NFL experts are questioning whether or not these player led workouts are beneficial or not.
umm i would wager they do. i don't think it is coincidence that manning and the colts have the best offense, manning and his WR workouts constantly. and players may not come in in football shape but hey will be closer and not have as steep a curve.
1) PLayers can come in football shape without going to player run workouts.
2) You are talking about Peyton Manning. The master of the offense the Colts run. Someone who could recite the playbook in his sleep. That guys, working with his team on the system he knows.
Now lets compare #2 to our situation. They have one of the best QBs in NFL history practicing an offense that he knows. We have an underachieving quarterback practicing complex offense which he is attempting to learn on his own on the fly.
I dont care if you like Alex or not, you HAVE to admit that there is plenty of reason (aside from conditioning) to suspect that these workouts could be more harmful than beneficial.