Well its basically true. I mean what does Alex do well??? anything?? He is horrible on short passes to the point where I think I can throw a short pass better than him. The play yesterday where there was a PI called on the falcons but was taken back because Smiths throw was so bad that it was called uncatchable is beyond belief. Through 4 games he has looked like a rookie this year and his stats back that.
I definitely think it's #2. After the KC game Crabtree made similar comments, but it was about Raye. Not sure of the exact quote, but he was asked about the game and he basically said that I just go out and play I don't make the calls.
Originally posted by walker807: Well its basically true. I mean what does Alex do well??? anything?? He is horrible on short passes to the point where I think I can throw a short pass better than him. The play yesterday where there was a PI called on the falcons but was taken back because Smiths throw was so bad that it was called uncatchable is beyond belief. Through 4 games he has looked like a rookie this year and his stats back that.
Even though I routinely defend Smith, I am severely questioning if he has what it takes to be an NFL QB upstairs. And I'm not referring to intelligence, more along the lines of gumption.
But Crabtree needs to keep his mouth shut. He is the reason we lost Week 1, and he might be a big part of the reason Smith is losing faith in his receivers and maybe even himself.
Originally posted by DesiDez: So Crabtree pointed out the obvious: Alex sucks period
I'm glad someone in this organization doesn't have their lips PERMANENTLY attached to Alex's a**.
But here comes the Crabtree is a cancer posts, when in reality, #11 has and will always be a cancer.
Who turned a three yard reception for a first down into an interception before the end of the half against Seattle? Who is the receiver that is killing Smith's stats? Oh, Crabtree? As I recall, this guy got chewed by VD for slacking, and that slacking is now paying NEGATIVE dividends.
I just wonder exactly how many games they are going to waste on Alex this season before pulling the plug. That Shaun Hill trade is looking pretty bad right now. I'm pissed cause I actually supported Alex until this season where there were no more excuses for him and the truth is plain that he actually is just a really bad QB.
GOOD. ALL players need to hear this and think this way as do our idiotic fans. Sing and Johnson cant play the game. The players need to want it an need to want the win as much if not more than the coaches like VD said in the post game video. He is just speaking the truth good for him for having some balls. Again quit putting all the blame on Sing he didnt fumble last play to win it or throw the ball straight at Falcon players. Player win games and this is not happening in SF right now.
This fan site is dedicated to the 49ers and their fans. It is in no way affiliated with the NFL or any of its teams. All teams and players mentioned on this site are registered trademarks of the NFL. The use of any team names, words, trademarks, logos or photos have been used for descriptive purposes only. The content and information from other sites is the property of their respective owners. Player and team photos used with permission from USA TODAY Sports Images.